Expert opinion and specialised knowledge

The specialised knowledge exception: the purpose-based opinion rule in s 76, the two limbs of s 79, and what s 80 does and does not do about ultimate issue and common knowledge.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, vic, tas, act, nt
Subjects
evidence
Topics
opinion

Learning outcomes

  • State both limbs of s 79 and identify which the facts put in doubt.
  • Distinguish the lay opinion exception in s 78 from the specialised knowledge exception in s 79.
  • Explain why the opinion rule is purpose-based.
  • Apply s 80 as removing standalone objections rather than conferring admissibility.

Opinion evidence is generally inadmissible, and the exception for expertise is the one most litigated. The uniform evidence legislation frames it narrowly: not “is this person an expert” but whether the opinion is wholly or substantially based on specialised knowledge which is itself based on the person’s training, study or experience.

This article states the position under the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Sections 77, 78 and 80 are enacted in the same terms in New South Wales, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory, and s 79 states the same rule in all six — the ACT Act words it differently, saying “completely or substantially” where the others say “wholly or substantially”.6 Section 76 is the exception. The Victorian Act states the opinion rule in a single unnumbered subsection and has no s 76(2) at all, so a pinpoint to “s 76(1)” or “s 76(2)” is a pinpoint to nothing in a Victorian proceeding.7

The rule the exception sits under

The opinion rule is that evidence of an opinion is not admissible to prove the existence of a fact about the existence of which the opinion was expressed. In the Commonwealth Act that is s 76(1), and s 76(2) excepts an opinion contained in a certificate or other document given under regulations made under another Act, to the extent the regulations give it evidentiary effect.1

Cite the rule by subsection only in the Act that has those subsections. New South Wales, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory each enact s 76 in the same two subsections. Victoria does not: its s 76 is one unnumbered subsection stating the rule, and the Act carries its own note that “The Commonwealth Act and New South Wales Act include an additional subsection”. So in a Victorian proceeding the certificate exception is not part of s 76, and must be found elsewhere rather than assumed from the section.7

Note the shape. The rule is about using an opinion to prove the fact opined on. An opinion tendered for some other purpose is not caught by s 76 at all, which is the same structural point that s 60 makes about hearsay.

Two exceptions besides s 79

Section 79 is not the only way past the rule, and reaching for it when a simpler exception answers the problem is a common misstep. The Act’s own note to s 76 lists further exceptions besides ss 77 to 79 — among them summaries of voluminous or complex documents under s 50(3), Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander traditional laws and customs under s 78A, and admissions under s 81 — and records that other provisions of the Act or of other laws may operate as exceptions as well.1 The two that most often answer an expert-opinion problem without reaching s 79 are these.

Section 77 — relevant otherwise than as opinion. The opinion rule does not apply to an opinion admitted because it is relevant for a purpose other than proving the fact opined on.2 This is the exact structural mirror of s 60 for hearsay, and like s 60 it turns on the evidence being admitted on the other basis, not merely being capable of relevance to it.

Section 78 — lay opinions. The rule does not apply to an opinion expressed by a person if two cumulative conditions are met: the opinion is based on what the person saw, heard or otherwise perceived about a matter or event; and evidence of the opinion is necessary to obtain an adequate account or understanding of that perception.3

The necessity limb is what stops s 78 becoming a general licence for impressions, and it is the limb to argue. A witness saying “the car was going very fast” will ordinarily satisfy it, because the perception cannot be adequately conveyed as a list of primary facts. A witness saying “he was clearly intending to defraud her” ordinarily will not — not because the subject matter is off limits, but because evidence of that opinion is not shown to be necessary to obtain an adequate account or understanding of what the witness perceived. Work the statutory condition; do not substitute a general objection that the opinion trespasses on the tribunal’s function, which s 80 answers.

A workable sequence — a habit of problem-solving, not a requirement of the Act — is to start with the tendered purpose, because s 76 bites only where the opinion is tendered to prove the fact opined on, and then to work whichever exceptions the facts actually raise: is the opinion admitted for another purpose (s 77); is it a lay opinion necessary to convey a perception (s 78); is it based on specialised knowledge (s 79). The Act prescribes no order among the exceptions and does not require one to be exhausted before another is reached. They are alternatives, and on facts about an expert s 79 is often the only one in play.

Section 79: the two limbs

Section 79(1) provides that if a person has specialised knowledge based on the person’s training, study or experience, the opinion rule does not apply to evidence of an opinion of that person that is wholly or substantially based on that knowledge.4

There are two limbs and both must be satisfied:

  1. Specialised knowledge, based on training, study or experience. The source is disjunctive — experience alone can found it, and a formal qualification is not required.
  2. The opinion must be wholly or substantially based on that knowledge. This is the limb on which an expert opinion can fail even though the expertise is unquestioned: an opinion that strays beyond the expert’s field, or where the connection between the knowledge and the conclusion is not demonstrated, is not shown to be substantially based on it. How much articulation that takes varies with the opinion; a straightforward application of a recognised field to identified facts may need little.

Section 79(2) puts beyond doubt that specialised knowledge includes specialised knowledge of child development and child behaviour, including the impact of sexual abuse on children, and that an opinion of a person with that knowledge includes an opinion about the development and behaviour of children generally, or of children who have been victims of sexual offences or similar offences.4

Section 80: what is no longer an objection

Section 80 abolishes two common law rules. Evidence of an opinion is not inadmissible only because it is about a fact in issue or an ultimate issue, or about a matter of common knowledge.5

The words “only because” matter. Section 80 removes those as standalone objections; it does not make such an opinion admissible if it fails s 79, and it does not displace ss 135 and 137.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the opinion and the fact it is tendered to prove — if it is not tendered to prove that fact, s 76 does not bite.
  2. Establish the specialised knowledge and its source in training, study or experience.
  3. Ask whether the opinion is wholly or substantially based on that knowledge, and say how the reasoning runs from one to the other.
  4. Do not object that the opinion goes to the ultimate issue or to common knowledge; s 80 answers that.
  5. Consider the exclusions in Part 3.11 of the Commonwealth Act separately — getting past s 79 is not the end — and do not call them all discretions. Under s 135 the court may refuse to admit evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger that it might be unfairly prejudicial to a party, misleading or confusing, or cause undue waste of time. Under s 137, in a criminal proceeding, the court must refuse to admit evidence adduced by the prosecutor if its probative value is outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice to the defendant — a lower threshold than s 135, and a duty rather than a discretion.

A worked application

A treating doctor is called in a personal injury claim. She gives evidence that the plaintiff “was in a great deal of pain” on presentation, and separately that the mechanism of injury is consistent with a fall from standing height rather than from a ladder.

The two statements take different routes. “In a great deal of pain” is an opinion based on what she perceived — the plaintiff’s presentation — so s 78 is the provision to work, and it will answer the opinion-rule objection if evidence of the opinion is necessary to obtain an adequate account or understanding of that perception. That is the question to argue: say what she observed, and why those observations cannot be adequately conveyed to the court without the opinion. No expertise need be established for that route.

The mechanism of injury is not a perception; it is a conclusion drawn from training and clinical experience, so it needs s 79. Both limbs must be worked: her specialised knowledge from training, study or experience, and whether this particular opinion is wholly or substantially based on that knowledge. Note what the second limb asks and what it does not: it asks about the basis of the opinion, so the fact that she was supplied with some of the factual assumptions is not itself an answer to it. Whether those assumptions are made good on the evidence is a separate question. If the connection between the imaging and the conclusion is not demonstrated, the second limb is where the objection bites, and s 80 will not save it: s 80 removes only the objection that the opinion is about a fact in issue, an ultimate issue or a matter of common knowledge.

Where the authority sits

The opinion rule and its exceptions are statutory, in Part 3.3 of the Evidence Act 1995 in the Commonwealth and New South Wales and in the corresponding Part of each other uniform Act. Sections 77, 78 and 80 are enacted in the same terms across the scheme, and s 79 states the same rule everywhere, the ACT Act’s wording of s 79(1) and s 79(2) being a difference of expression and not of substance. Section 76 is the one provision that is not uniform in structure, Victoria having no s 76(2).6 Identify the court before stating the test. The uniform scheme does not govern the own courts of Queensland, Western Australia or South Australia, and the common law of opinion evidence continues to apply in those States.

Western Australia is the one to watch, and the distinction to hold onto is between enactment and commencement. The Evidence Act 2025 (WA) states the opinion rule in s 90(1), the exceptions in ss 91 to 94 — s 94 being the specialised knowledge exception, whose subsection (1) reproduces the Commonwealth s 79(1) test — and the abolition of the ultimate issue and common knowledge grounds in s 95. It was assented to on 25 September 2025, but those provisions are not in operation: only Part 1 and s 384 have commenced, and Parts 2 to 9 begin on 18 September 2027. Until that day a Western Australian State proceeding is governed by the Evidence Act 1906 (WA) and the common law — a federal court sitting in Western Australia applies the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), which by s 4(1) “applies to all proceedings in a federal court”, the uniform scheme is operative in six jurisdictions and no other, and there is no operative Western Australian section number to cite for the opinion rule. Check the commencement before citing a section of an Act that has been passed.

Self-check

  • Can I name both limbs of s 79 and say which one the facts put in doubt?
  • Do I know what s 80 does and does not do?
  • Have I kept the opinion rule’s purpose-based structure in view, rather than treating all opinion as inadmissible?
  • Does the subsection I am citing exist, and is it in operation, in the Act that governs this court?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.