Expert opinion and specialised knowledge

The rule the exception sits under

The opinion rule says evidence of an opinion cannot prove the very fact that opinion was about. In the Commonwealth Act this is s 76(1).

Section 76(2) creates an exception. It covers opinions in a certificate or document made under regulations, if those regulations give it evidentiary effect (meaning the regulations say it counts as evidence).[^cite:evidence-act-cth-s76]

You can only cite “s 76(1)” or “s 76(2)” in Acts that actually split the section this way. NSW, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory all use the same two-subsection structure as the Commonwealth.

Victoria is different. Its s 76 is just one unnumbered subsection, stating only the basic rule. The Victorian Act even notes that the Commonwealth and NSW Acts have an extra subsection that Victoria lacks.[^cite:expert-s76-divergence]

This means in Victoria the certificate exception is not part of s 76 at all. A Victorian lawyer must find that exception somewhere else, not assume it sits within s 76.

Finally, note what the rule actually targets. Section 76 only stops an opinion being used to prove the fact it addresses. If the opinion is tendered for some other purpose, s 76 does not apply. This mirrors the same structural point made elsewhere about s 60 and hearsay evidence.

Two exceptions besides s 79

Section 79 is not the only way around the opinion rule. The note to s 76 lists other exceptions too, including s 50(3) (summaries of complex documents), s 78A (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander traditional laws and customs), and s 81 (admissions). Other provisions, in this Act or elsewhere, may also create exceptions.

Two exceptions often solve an expert-opinion problem without needing s 79.

Section 77 says the opinion rule does not apply if the opinion is admitted because it is relevant for some purpose other than proving the fact it states. This mirrors s 60 for hearsay. The evidence must actually be admitted on that other basis — it is not enough that it could be relevant that way.

Section 78 covers lay opinions. Two conditions must both be met: the opinion must be based on what the person actually saw, heard or perceived, and the opinion must be necessary to properly explain that perception.

The necessity condition does the real work. Saying “the car was going very fast” usually meets it, because you cannot easily describe that perception just by listing facts. Saying “he clearly intended to defraud her” usually does not, because the opinion is not necessary to explain what was perceived — not because the topic is forbidden.

So argue the necessity condition under s 78, not a general complaint that the opinion intrudes on the tribunal’s role — that objection belongs under s 80.

A useful approach, though not a strict rule, is to first ask what purpose the opinion is tendered for. Section 76 only applies where the opinion is tendered to prove the fact it states. From there, check whichever exceptions fit the facts: s 77 (admitted for another purpose), s 78 (necessary lay opinion), or s 79 (based on specialised knowledge). The Act does not set an order, and you need not exhaust one exception before trying another.

Section 79: the two limbs

Section 79(1) says expert opinion evidence can escape the opinion rule in two ways. First, the person must have specialised knowledge, built on training, study or experience. Experience alone is enough; a formal qualification is not required.

Second, the opinion must be wholly or substantially based on that knowledge. This is where experts can still fail, even with real expertise. If the opinion strays outside their field, or the link to the knowledge is not shown, it will not count.

How much explanation this needs depends on the opinion. A simple, well-recognised application to known facts may need little justification.

Section 79(2) confirms that specialised knowledge includes knowledge of child development and behaviour, including the effects of sexual abuse. Experts with this knowledge can give opinions about children generally, or about child victims of sexual or similar offences.

Section 80: what is no longer an objection

Section 80 scraps two old common law objections. You can’t object to opinion evidence just because it touches a fact in issue or an ultimate issue (the final question the court must decide).

You also can’t object just because the opinion covers a matter of common knowledge.

But watch the phrase “only because.” Section 80 only removes these as standalone objections. The opinion still must satisfy s 79 to be admissible, and ss 135 and 137 can still apply to exclude it.

Applying this in a problem question

First work out what opinion is being given, and exactly what fact it is used to prove. If it is not tendered for that fact, s 76 does not apply.

Next, identify the specialised knowledge behind the opinion, and its source — training, study or experience.

Then check whether the opinion is wholly or substantially based on that knowledge. You must explain how the reasoning moves from the knowledge to the opinion.

Do not object that the opinion deals with the ultimate issue or with common knowledge. Section 80 removes that objection.

Finally, deal separately with the exclusions in Part 3.11. Passing s 79 is not the end of the analysis. Under s 135, a court may refuse evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice, confusion or wasted time — this is a discretion. Under s 137, in criminal cases, a court must refuse prosecution evidence if its probative value is outweighed by unfair prejudice to the defendant. This threshold is lower than s 135’s, and it is a duty, not a discretion.

A worked application

A doctor gives two pieces of evidence in a personal injury claim. First, that the plaintiff was in a great deal of pain. Second, that the injury looks like a fall from standing height, not from a ladder.

The pain statement is an opinion based on what she perceived. This goes through s 78. It answers the opinion-rule objection if the opinion is necessary to adequately convey her perception to the court. No expertise needs to be shown here.

The mechanism-of-injury statement is different. It is a conclusion from her training and experience, not a perception. This needs s 79, which has two parts: her specialised knowledge, and whether this opinion is substantially based on that knowledge.

The second part asks about the basis of the opinion itself. Being given some facts to assume is not enough to satisfy it. Whether those assumed facts are actually proven is a separate question.

If the link between the imaging and her conclusion is not shown, the objection succeeds under the second limb. Section 80 cannot fix this: it only removes objections based on the opinion being about a fact in issue, an ultimate issue, or common knowledge.

Where the authority sits

The opinion rule and its exceptions sit in Part 3.3 of the Evidence Act 1995, in the Commonwealth, New South Wales, and the other uniform Acts. Sections 77, 78 and 80 use the same wording everywhere. Section 79 states the same rule everywhere too, though the ACT’s s 79(1) and s 79(2) are worded slightly differently without changing the substance. Section 76 is the exception: Victoria has no s 76(2).

This uniform scheme does not apply in Queensland, Western Australia or South Australia. Those States still use the common law of opinion evidence.

Western Australia needs special care. Its new Evidence Act 2025 (WA) sets out the opinion rule in s 90(1), exceptions in ss 91 to 94, and abolishes certain grounds in s 95. Section 94(1), the specialised knowledge exception, copies the Commonwealth’s s 79(1) test.

But assent is not commencement — assent means the Act is formally approved, commencement means it actually takes legal effect. The WA Act was assented to on 25 September 2025, but only Part 1 and s 384 are currently in force. Parts 2 to 9 do not commence until 18 September 2027.

Until then, a Western Australian state proceeding is governed by the Evidence Act 1906 (WA) and the common law. A federal court sitting in Western Australia instead applies the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), because s 4(1) says it applies to all federal court proceedings.

So the uniform scheme currently operates in six jurisdictions only. There is no operative Western Australian section number yet for the opinion rule. Always check commencement before citing a section from an Act that has merely been passed.

Self-check

Before moving on, check yourself.

Can you name both parts of s 79, and say which part the facts actually raise doubt about?

Do you know exactly what s 80 covers, and just as importantly, what it does not cover?

Have you remembered that the opinion rule is structured around its purpose? Not all opinion evidence is automatically inadmissible.

Finally, check the subsection you plan to cite. Does it exist, and is it currently in force, under the Act that applies in this court?

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.