Duties to clients: costs disclosure and informed choice

States the costs-disclosure and fair-costs obligations in Part 4.3 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law that make a lawyer’s duty to keep a client informed concrete, including who is protected, what must be disclosed and understood, and what follows from non-compliance.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
nsw, vic
Subjects
ethics-and-professional-responsibility
Topics
duties-to-client

Learning outcomes

  • Classify a client under s 170 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law and say which of the Part 4.3 obligations follow.
  • State what a law practice must disclose about costs, when, and what it must do to satisfy itself that the client has understood and consented.
  • State the consequences of failing to make the required costs disclosure, distinguishing the contractual and recovery consequences from the disciplinary capability.

Duties to clients treats the duty to keep a client reasonably informed as one of four client-facing duties, and notes that it connects to costs disclosure. This article takes up that connection. Legal costs are the place where the duty stops being general and becomes a set of dated, written obligations with stated consequences, found in Part 4.3 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law. The text read is the New South Wales consolidation of the Law, which applies as a law of New South Wales and, because it is the Law set out in the Victorian application Act, of Victoria.1 The consolidation read is dated as at 1 July 2022, so amendments since then and the Victorian text itself were not compared. Western Australia and the jurisdictions that are not Uniform Law jurisdictions are not stated here.

Why costs belong among the duties to the client

Part 4.3 opens by stating three objectives: that clients are able to make informed choices about their legal options and the costs of pursuing them, that law practices charge no more than fair and reasonable amounts, and that there is a framework for assessing costs (s 169).2 The first corresponds to a professional rule. A solicitor must provide clear and timely advice to assist a client to understand relevant legal issues and to make informed choices about action to be taken, consistent with the terms of the engagement (r 7.1 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules 2015), and must deliver legal services competently, diligently and as promptly as reasonably possible (r 4.1.3).5 Costs are advice a client needs in order to choose, and the Law makes that need a legal obligation of the law practice.

Who is protected

Part 4.3 does not apply to a “commercial or government client”, or to a third party payer who would be one, but s 170 itself and ss 181(1), (7) and (8), 182, 183 and 185(3) to (5) do (s 170(1)). A commercial or government client is defined by a list, which includes a law practice, a public company, a large proprietary company, a body incorporated outside Australia and a government authority in Australia or abroad (s 170(2); the list is longer and is not set out in full here). For such a client the fair-and-reasonable requirement in s 172 and the disclosure obligations in ss 174 to 178 therefore do not apply, though the ban on contingency fees in s 183 does. Classifying the client is the first step.

Fair and reasonable costs

A law practice must charge costs “no more than fair and reasonable in all the circumstances”, and in particular costs that are proportionately and reasonably incurred and proportionate and reasonable in amount (s 172(1)). Section 172(2) lists what regard must be had to, including the skill, experience and seniority of the lawyers, the complexity, novelty or difficulty of the issues, the labour and responsibility involved, the circumstances of acting (urgency, time spent), the quality of the work and the retainer and instructions given. A costs agreement is prima facie evidence that the costs disclosed in it are fair and reasonable if the Division 3 disclosure requirements were complied with and the agreement does not contravene, and was not entered into in contravention of, any provision of Division 4 (s 172(4)); that makes it evidence of fairness and not proof of it. A law practice must also not act in a way that unnecessarily increases the costs payable, and must act reasonably to avoid unnecessary delay that does so (s 173).

Disclosure

Section 174 is the central obligation.3 When or as soon as practicable after instructions are initially given, a law practice must give the client information disclosing the basis on which costs will be calculated and an estimate of the total costs (s 174(1)(a)). That information must include the client’s rights to negotiate a costs agreement, to negotiate the billing method, to receive a bill and request an itemised bill, and to seek the assistance of the designated local regulatory authority in a costs dispute (s 174(2)(a)). When anything previously disclosed changes significantly, the practice must disclose the change, with enough information about its effect on costs to let the client make informed decisions about the future conduct of the matter (s 174(1)(b) and (2)(b)).

Two features separate the duty from handing over a document. First, once a disclosure is made under s 174(1) the practice “must take all reasonable steps to satisfy itself that the client has understood and given consent to the proposed course of action for the conduct of the matter and the proposed costs” (s 174(3)). Secondly, disclosure must be in writing, but the requirement for writing does not affect the s 174(3) obligation (s 174(6)). Where total costs, excluding GST and disbursements, are not likely to exceed a lower threshold, disclosure is not required, and below a higher threshold it may be made on a uniform standard form. If a practice that has not made the full disclosure becomes aware, or ought reasonably to become aware, that costs are likely to exceed the relevant threshold, it must inform the client in writing and make the disclosure then required (s 174(4), (5), (7) and (8)). The Uniform Rules prescribe the amounts; until a Uniform Rule does so the Law’s transitional schedule fixes the lower threshold at $750 and the higher at $3000 (Sch 4 cl 18(3) and (4)). Whether the Uniform Rules have since prescribed other amounts is not established by the sources cited here, so a student should check the current Rules.

Three further obligations extend the same idea. A practice that intends to retain another law practice for the client must disclose the details specified in s 174(1) for the second practice, unless it ceases to act for the client when the second practice is retained (s 175). A disclosure required under s 174 or s 175 must also be made in writing to an associated third party payer, but only to the extent the matters are relevant to costs the payer must pay (s 176). And a practice negotiating the settlement of a litigious matter must, before the settlement is executed, disclose a reasonable estimate of the costs payable by the client if the matter settles, including another party’s costs the client is to pay, and of contributions likely to be received from another party (s 177).

Consequences of non-compliance

Section 178(1) states four consequences of contravening the Part’s disclosure obligations: the costs agreement concerned, if any, is void; the client or an associated third party payer is not required to pay the costs until they have been assessed or the costs dispute has been determined by the designated local regulatory authority; the practice must not start or maintain proceedings to recover the costs until then; and the contravention is capable of constituting unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct of a principal or involved associate. The last is “capable of” that outcome and is not automatically either. Where disclosure was made to one of a client and an associated third party payer but not the other, the one told remains liable to pay the costs and may be sued for them (s 178(2)). The Uniform Rules may provide that these consequences do not apply, or apply with modifications, in specified circumstances (s 178(3)); whether they do is not established by the sources cited here, so a student should check the current Uniform Rules.

Costs agreements and bills

A client has the right to require and to have a negotiated costs agreement (s 179).4 It must be written or evidenced in writing, and cannot provide that the costs are not subject to assessment (s 180(2) and (4)); subject to the Law it may be enforced like any other contract (s 184). A law practice must not enter a costs agreement under which the amount payable is calculated by reference to the amount of any award or settlement or the value of property recovered, unless it adopts an applicable fixed costs provision, and a contravention carries a civil penalty of 100 penalty units (s 183). That prohibition is distinct from the uplift fee a conditional costs agreement may provide for under s 182, which in a litigious matter requires a reasonable belief that success is reasonably likely and may not exceed 25 per cent of the legal costs (excluding disbursements) otherwise payable (s 182(2)). Legislation on court-ordered group costs in representative proceedings is separate from s 183 and is not covered here. The Law also gives rights during and after the retainer: where a bill is a lump sum, a person entitled to apply for assessment may request an itemised bill, the request to be made within 30 days after the costs become payable, to be given within 21 days (s 187), and a client may, on reasonable request, obtain a free written report of costs incurred to date (s 190). A practice may not start proceedings for costs unless a compliant bill has been given (s 194(1)), and not until any costs dispute before the designated local regulatory authority has been closed or resolved and at least 30 days have passed after the later of the bill or an itemised bill requested under s 187 (s 194(2)).

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the jurisdiction and the client. Part 4.3 as stated here is the Uniform Law as read in its New South Wales text, and a commercial or government client falls outside most of it (s 170).
  2. Locate the moment: initial instructions, a significant change, a second practice retained, a third party payer, or a settlement about to be executed, and match it to s 174(1), s 175, s 176 or s 177.
  3. Ask what was disclosed and in what form, and then whether the practice took all reasonable steps to satisfy itself that the client understood and consented (s 174(3)); a written disclosure alone does not answer the second question.
  4. If disclosure was not made, apply s 178(1) in its four parts, remembering that disciplinary consequences are stated as a capability.
  5. Treat fairness of the amount as a separate question under s 172, and the agreement’s form as a third, including whether the fee basis is a prohibited contingency arrangement or a permitted conditional one.

Self-check

  • Have I classified the client under s 170 before applying ss 172 to 178?
  • Have I kept the duty to take reasonable steps about understanding and consent apart from the duty to give written information?
  • Have I stated the thresholds as the Law’s transitional figures, subject to the Uniform Rules, which are not covered here?

Where the authority sits

The obligations are statutory, in Part 4.3 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law as it applies in New South Wales and Victoria, and are reinforced by the Conduct Rules’ duties to deliver services competently and to advise so that the client can make informed choices. This article states no judicial authority; how courts and costs assessors apply the fair-and-reasonable standard is not covered by the sources cited.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.