Duties to clients: costs disclosure and informed choice
Why costs belong among the duties to the client
Part 4.3 sets out three goals. Clients must be able to make informed choices about their legal options and costs. Law practices must charge no more than fair and reasonable amounts. There must also be a framework for assessing costs (s 169).
The first goal matches a professional conduct rule. Solicitors must give clear, timely advice so clients understand the issues and can make informed choices (r 7.1). Solicitors must also act competently, diligently, and as promptly as reasonably possible (r 4.1.3).
Costs information helps clients make that choice. The Law turns this need into a legal duty for law practices.
Who is protected
Most of Part 4.3 does not apply to a “commercial or government client”. A third party payer who would count as one is also excluded. But s 170 itself, and ss 181(1), (7), (8), 182, 183 and 185(3) to (5), still apply (s 170(1)).
Section 170(2) defines a commercial or government client with a list. It includes a law practice, a public company, a large proprietary company, a body incorporated outside Australia, and a government authority in Australia or abroad. The full list is longer than shown here.
For this kind of client, two things drop away: the fair-and-reasonable requirement in s 172, and the disclosure duties in ss 174 to 178. The ban on contingency fees in s 183 still applies, though.
Because the rules differ so much, working out what kind of client you have comes first.
Fair and reasonable costs
Costs must be fair and reasonable, not just whatever was agreed. Section 172(1) says costs must be no more than fair and reasonable in all the circumstances.
Section 172(2) lists things to consider. These include the lawyer’s skill and experience, how complex the matter is, the work and responsibility involved, and the instructions given.
Having a costs agreement helps, but does not guarantee fairness. Under s 172(4), it is prima facie evidence (meaning evidence accepted unless disproved) that costs are fair, but only if disclosure rules were followed and the agreement does not breach other requirements.
Section 173 also stops a law practice from acting in ways that unnecessarily increase costs. This includes avoiding unnecessary delay that would add to costs.
Disclosure
Section 174 is the main disclosure duty. When instructions first start (or soon after), a law practice must tell the client how costs will be calculated and give a total cost estimate (s 174(1)(a)).
This disclosure must include the client’s rights: to negotiate the costs agreement and billing method, to get a bill, to request an itemised bill, and to seek help from the local regulatory authority in a dispute (s 174(2)(a)).
If anything disclosed changes significantly, the practice must disclose the change. It must explain enough about the effect on costs for the client to make informed decisions (s 174(1)(b), (2)(b)).
Two features make this more than just handing over paperwork. First, after disclosure under s 174(1), the practice must take reasonable steps to confirm the client actually understood and agreed to the plan and costs (s 174(3)).
Second, disclosure must be in writing. But the writing requirement doesn’t remove the separate s 174(3) duty to check understanding (s 174(6)).
Disclosure isn’t required if total costs (excluding GST and disbursements) probably won’t exceed a lower threshold. Below a higher threshold, disclosure can use a standard form instead of full disclosure.
If a practice realises—or should realise—that costs will likely exceed the relevant threshold, it must tell the client in writing and make the full disclosure then required (s 174(4), (5), (7), (8)).
The Uniform Rules are meant to set these threshold amounts. Until they do, a transitional schedule sets the lower threshold at $750 and the higher at $3000 (Sch 4 cl 18(3), (4)). The passage doesn’t say whether the Uniform Rules have since changed these figures, so check the current Rules.
Three further duties extend this same idea. If a practice plans to retain a second practice for the client, it must give the same s 174(1) disclosures about that second practice—unless it stops acting once the second practice is retained (s 175).
Any disclosure required under s 174 or s 175 must also be given in writing to an associated third-party payer. This only applies to matters relevant to costs that payer must cover (s 176).
Consequences of non-compliance
Section 178(1) lists four results of breaching disclosure rules. The costs agreement, if any, becomes void. The client or an associated third party payer need not pay until the costs are assessed, or a dispute is resolved by the designated local regulatory authority.
The practice also cannot start or continue proceedings to recover costs until then. Finally, the breach may amount to unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct. This last consequence is only possible, not automatic.
If disclosure was given to just one of the client or associated third party payer, that person still must pay. They can still be sued for the costs (s 178(2)).
Section 178(3) allows the Uniform Rules to remove or change these consequences in some cases. Whether they actually do so is not covered here, so check the current Rules.
Costs agreements and bills
A client can require a written, negotiated costs agreement (s 179). It must be in writing, or evidenced in writing, and cannot exclude the client’s right to have costs assessed (s 180(2) and (4)). Subject to the Law, it is enforceable like any other contract (s 184).
A law practice must not agree to be paid a percentage of any award, settlement or recovered property, unless a fixed costs provision applies. Breaching this carries a civil penalty of 100 penalty units (s 183).
This is different from an uplift fee under s 182. A conditional costs agreement may include an uplift fee only if the practice reasonably believes success is reasonably likely. The uplift cannot exceed 25 per cent of legal costs, excluding disbursements (s 182(2)). Group costs orders in representative proceedings are a separate topic, not covered here.
Clients also have ongoing rights. If billed a lump sum, a person entitled to assessment can request an itemised bill within 30 days of the bill becoming payable; the practice must provide it within 21 days (s 187). Clients can also request a free written report of costs incurred so far, if the request is reasonable (s 190).
A practice cannot sue for costs unless it has given a compliant bill (s 194(1)). It must also wait until any costs dispute before the local regulatory authority is resolved, and at least 30 days after the bill — or itemised bill — was given (s 194(2)).
Applying this in a problem question
First, check the jurisdiction and client. This is the Uniform Law in its New South Wales version, under Part 4.3. Most of it does not apply to a commercial or government client, under s 170.
Next, work out when disclosure was needed. This could be at initial instructions, a significant change, a second practice retained, a third party payer, or a settlement about to be executed. Match the timing to s 174(1), s 175, s 176 or s 177.
Then check what was disclosed, and how. Also ask whether the practice took all reasonable steps to ensure the client understood and consented, under s 174(3). Written disclosure alone does not prove this second part.
If disclosure was missing, apply s 178(1), which has four parts. Note that disciplinary action is only a possibility, not a certainty.
Finally, treat two more questions separately. Ask whether the amount charged was fair, under s 172. Then ask whether the agreement’s form was proper, including whether the fee was a prohibited contingency arrangement or a permitted conditional one.
Where the authority sits
These duties come from a statute: Part 4.3 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law. This Law applies in New South Wales and Victoria.
The Conduct Rules add more support. They require lawyers to work competently and to help clients make informed choices.
The article does not mention any court cases. It does not explain how courts or costs assessors apply the “fair and reasonable” standard.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.