Pre-registration contracts and the promoter’s liability

Apply statutory company ratification, the contracting person’s damages liability, discretionary court orders against the company or person, and signed releases before incorporation.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
corporations-and-commercial-law
Topics
corporate-personality, contract-formation

Learning outcomes

  • Identify a pre-registration contract within s 131.
  • Apply the ratification and timing requirements.
  • Distinguish personal liability, discretionary court orders against the company or person, and signed releases.

A founder may arrange a lease, equipment purchase or service contract before the proposed company is registered. The first question is whether the person contracted on behalf of, or for the benefit of, that proposed company before it existed. Sections 131–133 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) then determine statutory ratification and liability. The later appearance of a company name does not by itself resolve who bears the promise.

Identify the transaction and the registration date

Section 131(1) covers a person entering, or purporting to enter, a contract on behalf of or for the benefit of a company before registration. That wording matters: it reaches purported action for a company not yet registered rather than assuming an ordinary existing principal. Establish the contract, the person making it, the proposed company’s identity and the relevant dates.1

Section 119 places the company’s existence at the beginning of its registration day. A contract on an earlier day presents the pre-registration issue directly. For a contract on the registration day, apply the beginning-of-day rule rather than treating the company as nonexistent until the certificate arrives. The examples here concern a contract on an earlier day. A person who simply contracts in their own name without the connection required by s 131 should not be forced into this Part by calling them a promoter after the event.

The label promoter is convenient here for the person whose conduct engages the provisions. The statutory language, however, concerns the person who enters or purports to enter the relevant contract. A student should apply that language to each participant instead of imposing liability on every founder or proposed director merely because they helped establish the enterprise.

Ratification makes the company bound and entitled

Under s 131(1), the company becomes bound by the contract and entitled to its benefit if the company, or a company reasonably identifiable with it, is registered and ratifies within the statutory time. The time is the period agreed by the parties; in its absence it is a reasonable time after the contract was entered into. Registration and ratification are separate requirements.

The reasonable-identifiability wording avoids making exact correspondence of the original proposed name the entire inquiry. But it does not allow any subsequently registered company to adopt the bargain merely because a founder prefers it. Identify why the registered company is reasonably identifiable with the one contemplated. A disputed identification or purported ratification may require authorities beyond the statutory text.

Where there is no agreed time, the reasonable time runs from the contract, not automatically from registration. An agreed time runs as the parties agreed it. Suppose the parties agree that ratification must occur within 30 days of signing. A company registered on day 29 does not acquire a fresh 30-day period from s 131 merely because registration consumed most of the agreed interval. Where no time was agreed, explain which facts bear on reasonableness rather than substituting a fixed statutory number of days that the section does not provide.

Failure to register or ratify exposes the contracting person

Section 131(2) imposes damages liability to each other party if the company is not registered, or is registered but does not ratify or enter a substitute contract within the applicable time. The substitute-contract possibility matters: an answer that treats formal ratification as the sole way to avoid this particular liability omits part of the provision.

The statutory measure is what the company would have owed that party had it ratified and then failed to perform the contract at all. That is not necessarily the amount the other party happened to spend before incorporation. Identify the promised performance and the loss attributable to assumed total non-performance. General damages issues may require additional authority; the statutory formula should not be replaced by an unexplained refund of expenses.

The provision is also not a general indemnity for every cost connected with the proposed enterprise. Its liability runs to the other parties to the qualifying contract, with the stated measure. Keep that claim separate from allegations that the contracting person made a misleading statement or breached an independent duty. Section 133’s displacement rule requires attention before importing other rights on the same pre-registration contract.

Court orders operate in two different situations

Section 131(3) addresses damages proceedings where the company was registered but did not ratify or enter a substitute. The court may do what it considers appropriate, including ordering the company to pay all or part of the person’s damages liability, transfer property received because of the contract, or pay an amount to a party. The court’s power is discretionary; registration alone does not automatically transfer the promoter’s liability to the company.

Section 131(4) addresses a different sequence: the company ratifies but fails to perform all or part of the contract. The court may order the person to pay all or part of the damages ordered against the company. Ratification therefore does not justify an absolute statement that the contracting person is permanently free of any liability under the Part.

Separate those two pathways in the facts. “Company exists, therefore company pays” ignores subsection (3)’s conditions and discretion. “Company ratified, therefore promoter cannot pay” ignores subsection (4). A careful conclusion states the available order and the decision the court still has to make, rather than converting a power into an automatic consequence.

Release is possible; indemnity is excluded

Under s 132(1), a party may release the person from all or part of the s 131 liability to that party by signing a release. Check who signed, which person’s liability is released and whether the release is complete or partial. An informal assumption that the company will eventually pay is not the signed release specified by the section.

Section 132(2) denies the person a right of indemnity against the company for liability under the Part, despite rules of law or equity and even where the person acted or purported to act as trustee. Distinguish that denial from the court’s discretionary orders under s 131(3). The availability of an order against the company is not a general personal right to reimbursement.

Section 133 replaces rights and liabilities anyone would otherwise have on the pre-registration contract. Its focus is the contract, so do not turn it without further analysis into an immunity from every independent legal wrong. Equally, do not start by applying an old common-law promoter rule while disregarding the statutory replacement.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the contracting person, proposed company, bargain and registration date.
  2. Test the registered company’s identity and timely ratification under s 131(1).
  3. If registration or timely ratification/substitution fails, apply s 131(2) and its damages measure.
  4. Distinguish the discretionary orders in subsections (3) and (4) according to what happened next.
  5. Check signed releases, the exclusion of indemnity and s 133 before adding other contractual liabilities.