Wardley Australia Ltd v Western Australia

High Court of Australia · 1992

ContractConsumer And Competition LawMisleading And Deceptive Conduct

Wardley Australia Ltd v Western Australia (1992) 175 CLR 514; [1992] HCA 55

A State gave an indemnity after a merchant bank’s assurances, and sued years later. Does the limitation period for a misleading-conduct claim start when the statement was made, or when the loss happens?

What happened?

In October 1987 Rothwells Ltd, a merchant bank, was short of liquidity after large withdrawals of deposits, and a rescue package was arranged. The State of Western Australia gave an indemnity in favour of the National Australia Bank against any net loss that might arise if Rothwells did not pay a bills facility in full. The indemnity was executed on 26 October 1987 and signed for the State by the Premier (joint reasons).

The State’s case was that the appellants, Wardley Australia Ltd and Wardley Australia Securities Ltd, made representations at a meeting on 24 October 1987 about Rothwells’ accounts and its loans to related companies. The State said those representations were misleading or deceptive, that it gave the indemnity in reliance on them, and that it suffered loss (joint reasons).

The State commenced proceedings on 24 October 1990. The original claim relied on the representations made on the Saturday. By an amendment introducing par 16(c) on 14 January 1991, the State pleaded an additional representation made at a meeting on Sunday, 25 October 1987, that Rothwells was a sound financial institution with substantial net assets, and alleged that it executed the indemnity in reliance on that representation as well. The appellants’ case was that a claim under s 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) on that representation accrued when the indemnity was executed on 26 October 1987, so that the amendment was made more than three years later and was statute-barred. The question was therefore whether it was. French J had struck out par 16(c) of the amended statement of claim, and the Full Court of the Federal Court allowed the State’s appeal from that order (joint reasons).

What did the Court decide?

The appeal was dismissed with costs. All seven Justices dismissed it. The joint reasons, given by four of the Justices, and separate reasons by Brennan, Deane and Toohey JJ all reached that result, so the amended claim was not shut out by the limitation period at that stage.

Proposition

What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added

Principle analysis

The accrual rule. The joint reasons say that because loss or damage is the gist of the statutory cause of action under s 82(1), the cause of action “does not accrue until actual loss or damage is sustained”. The limitation period in s 82(2) therefore runs from that time, and not from the conduct.

Contingent exposure. Where the plaintiff’s liability under the indemnity was contingent, the joint reasons say that the State “suffered no loss until that contingency was fulfilled and time did not begin to run until that event”, because the indemnity generated “an executory and contingent liability” (joint reasons).

Toohey J. Toohey J said that “There can be no ‘action’ under sub-s.(1) unless the plaintiff has suffered loss or damage”, and that until that time no cause of action has accrued.

Causation. The joint reasons also say that the word “by” in s 82(1) expresses causation without defining it, and should be read as the common-sense concept of causation (joint reasons).

Why does this case matter?

A student who fixes the limitation date from the statement itself, or from the date a document was signed, may choose a date the claim cannot use. The examiner will look at the plaintiff’s position on each date in the facts, not only at the defendant’s conduct.

Exam and application relevance

In a limitation problem, list the date of the conduct, the date of any transaction, and the date on which any loss or contingent liability arose. Then ask which of those dates the limitation period runs from, and check whether a contingency in the problem had occurred before the period expired.

The record concerns s 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), as it stood in 1992. The Act was renamed the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), and the damages action and its limitation period are now in Schedule 2 to that Act. The reasoning applies to the provision as it read in 1992. Read the current consolidation before applying it to a claim now, and do not assume the wording is unchanged.

Check your understanding

1. What was the indemnity, and on what date was it executed?

2. What did the joint reasons say is the gist of the statutory cause of action?

3. What did the joint reasons say about the State’s position while its liability under the indemnity was contingent?

4. What did Toohey J say about when a cause of action under s 82(1) accrues?

5. What did the joint reasons say about the word “by” in s 82(1), and what should a student check before applying this case to a current claim?