Oceanic Sun Line Special Shipping Co Inc v Fay

High Court of Australia · 1988

ContractContract Terms

Oceanic Sun Line Special Shipping Co Inc v Fay (1988) 165 CLR 197; [1988] HCA 32

A passenger books a cruise and pays in Sydney. The ticket, handed over in Greece, contains a clause sending any dispute to the courts of Athens. Is the clause part of the contract?

What happened?

Dr Fay, a Queensland resident, booked a Greek island cruise through a Sydney agent in 1983. When the fare was paid, an exchange order was issued. In Athens the exchange order was exchanged for a passenger ticket, which contained a clause giving the courts of Athens exclusive jurisdiction. The clause was not known to Dr Fay when the contract was made. The passengers boarded the ship at Piraeus. He was injured on the ship in Greek waters and sued in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The shipowner sought a stay on the basis of the Athens clause and, alternatively, on forum non conveniens grounds. Yeldham J refused the stay. The Court of Appeal affirmed by majority, Glass and McHugh JJA, with Kirby P dissenting.

What did the Court decide?

The appeal to the High Court was dismissed, with costs, by three Justices to two. Wilson and Toohey JJ, in a joint judgment, would have allowed the appeal and stayed the proceedings.

Proposition

What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added

Principle analysis

Conditions printed on a ticket issued after a contract of carriage was made cannot be added to it by the ticket; the question is whether they were part of the bargain when it was made. Brennan J held that a carrier relying on an exemption clause in such a document cannot rely on it where the passenger was not aware of it when the contract was made, unless the carrier did all that was reasonably necessary to bring the clause to the passenger’s notice at that time. Brennan J and Gaudron J held that the exclusive jurisdiction clause was not incorporated. Wilson and Toohey JJ reached the same view as a provisional conclusion for the stay application. Deane J formed the same view on the material before the Court, while finding it unnecessary to decide the clause’s effect.

Why does this case matter?

A student who sees a clause on a ticket may treat it as part of the contract because the passenger received it and was on notice that terms existed. An examiner rewards the student who asks what the parties had actually agreed, and who checks which Justices decided that question and which only expressed a provisional view.

Exam and application relevance

In a question about printed conditions on a ticket or booking document, ask which documents the parties had actually agreed to. Attribute each view to the Justice who expressed it, and check whether the view was a decision or a provisional view on a stay application. Read the disposition as a three to two result on the stay, not as a holding of the whole Court on every point.

Check your understanding

1. When did the contract of carriage come into existence in this case, and what did the passenger receive afterwards?

2. Whose reasons state the notice principle, and on what footing did Wilson and Toohey JJ express their view of the contract?

3. How did Wilson and Toohey JJ vote on the appeal?