Donoghue v Stevenson
Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562
A friend bought Mrs Donoghue ginger beer in an opaque bottle. After she alleged that a decomposed snail emerged, could she sue the manufacturer despite having no contract with him?
Qualified by Sullivan v Moody (2001) 207 CLR 562
For a modern Australian duty question, the broad neighbour formulation is not a complete test. In Sullivan v Moody the joint reasons said that proximity gives little practical guidance in cases not analogous to an established duty category and that different classes of case raise different problems, requiring attention to the factors for and against a duty ([48]-[50]). That qualification concerns the general method for recognising duties; it does not displace the established manufacturer-and-consumer duty decided in Donoghue.
What happened?
Mrs May Donoghue alleged that a friend bought her a bottle of ginger beer made by Mr David Stevenson at a cafe in Paisley. The bottle was dark and opaque. After some of its contents had been poured and consumed, she alleged that the decomposed remains of a snail came out, causing shock and gastroenteritis.
Mrs Donoghue had no contract with the manufacturer because her friend bought the drink. She sued in negligence. At this stage the courts were deciding a legal question on the pleadings: if her allegations were later proved, did they disclose a duty owed by the manufacturer to her? The facts, breach and damage had not yet been tried.
What did the Court decide?
By a majority of three to two, the House of Lords allowed Mrs Donoghue’s appeal, restored the Lord Ordinary’s decision and remitted the action to the Court of Session. Lord Atkin, Lord Thankerton and Lord Macmillan held that the pleaded circumstances could give rise to a duty of care. Lord Buckmaster dissented, and Lord Tomlin agreed with his reasons.
The decision let the action proceed to proof. It did not find that there was a snail, that Mr Stevenson had been negligent or that Mrs Donoghue was entitled to damages.
Proposition
What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis
Principle analysis
Lord Atkin stated the product-specific rule at 599. A manufacturer owes the ultimate consumer a duty to take reasonable care where the product is supplied in a form intended to reach that consumer as it left the manufacturer, there is no reasonable possibility of intermediate examination, and lack of reasonable care in preparing or putting up the product risks injury to life or property.
At 580, Lord Atkin expressed the broader neighbour principle: reasonable care must be taken to avoid reasonably foreseeable injury to persons so closely and directly affected that they ought reasonably to be contemplated. That general formulation explains his route to the result, but it should be read with the narrower question the appeal decided.
Lord Thankerton relied on the direct relationship created by excluding intermediate interference or examination. Lord Macmillan likewise emphasised intended consumption in a sealed container and added that the consumer still bore the burden of proving the defect, carelessness and circumstances creating the duty.
Ratio and obiter
Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.
Ratio · Lord Atkin
Read judgment: p 599 (PDF p 27) (opens in a new tab)
Lord Atkin’s manufacturer-and-consumer proposition answers the legal question on which the appeal depended. Accepting it meant that Mrs Donoghue’s pleaded case disclosed a duty and could proceed to proof; rejecting it would have ended the action.
Classification unresolved · Lord Atkin
Read judgment: p 580 (PDF p 15) (opens in a new tab)
The neighbour principle supplies Lord Atkin’s general explanation of when a duty of care arises and guides his result. Its formulation is broader than the product liability issue actually decided, so treating every word as either binding ratio or disposable obiter would hide a real question of scope.
Separate reasoning · Lord Thankerton
Read judgment: pp 603–604 (PDF p 30) (opens in a new tab)
Lord Thankerton reached the majority result through the direct relationship created when the manufacturer intentionally excluded intermediate interference or examination. His reasoning supports the duty on the pleaded facts without simply adopting Lord Atkin’s whole formulation.
Separate reasoning · Lord Macmillan
Read judgment: pp 621–622 (PDF p 42) (opens in a new tab)
Lord Macmillan separately treated the sealed container, intended consumption and absence of intermediate examination as circumstances supporting a duty. He stressed that negligence and the original defect still had to be averred and proved.
Separate reasoning · Lord Buckmaster and Lord Tomlin, dissenting
Read judgment: pp 577–578 (PDF p 13) (opens in a new tab), p 599 (PDF p 27) (opens in a new tab)
Lord Buckmaster would have dismissed the appeal because he considered the authorities opposed to such a duty and feared that the proposed principle could not be confined. Lord Tomlin expressly agreed with his reasoning and conclusion. These are dissenting reasons, not qualifications adopted by the majority.
Why does this case matter?
The case shows how a court can recognise a duty beyond contract while deciding the threshold question whether pleaded facts are legally capable of supporting a claim. That procedural posture matters: a famous appellate statement about duty did not prove the accident, breach or damage. Reading the separate speeches also shows why a majority for one order does not necessarily produce one identical set of reasons.
Exam and application relevance
Use Donoghue v Stevenson to explain the foundation of a manufacturer’s duty to an ultimate consumer and the neighbour principle’s role in the development of negligence. State the precise product rule before moving to the broader formulation, and identify Lord Atkin as its author.
For an Australian problem, do not treat the neighbour principle as a complete modern duty test. Sullivan v Moody (2001) 207 CLR 562 at [48]–[50] explains why proximity gives little practical guidance outside analogous established duties and why different classes of case require attention to different factors. Identify whether the claimed duty is already established, then apply current Australian authority and applicable civil liability legislation. Keep duty separate from breach, causation and damage. If the question concerns the case itself, say that the House of Lords decided legal sufficiency on assumed pleaded facts and remitted the action for proof.
Check your understanding
1. Why did the absence of a contract between Mrs Donoghue and Mr Stevenson not end the pleaded claim?
2. Which features of the product and its distribution made the relationship between manufacturer and consumer sufficiently direct?
3. What did the House of Lords leave unresolved when it remitted the action for proof?
4. Why should Lord Atkin’s formulation at 580 be distinguished from the narrower manufacturer-and-consumer proposition at 599?