Calderbank v Calderbank
Calderbank v Calderbank [1976] Fam 93
A settlement offer made in confidence, yet shown to the court when it decides who pays. Where did that device come from?
Clarified by Agosti & Agosti [2021] FedCFamC1F 72
What Calderbank itself decided, recounted by an Australian court. Wilson J sets out the terms of the wife’s offer and records that “[i]n Calderbank, Cairns LJ held that the wife was entitled to her costs. Scarman LJ and Sir Gordon Wilmer agreed” ([15]-[16]). On the device itself his Honour is explicit that it was not a holding: Oliver and Fox LJJ in Cutts v Head treated Cairns LJ’s formulation as dictum only, however convenient practitioners found it ([17]). Cairns LJ had drawn the idea from existing practice in the Lands Tribunal and the Admiralty Court ([14]). Wilson J treats the authority as “well known since 1975” ([18]).
Clarified by Hazeldene’s Chicken Farm Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority (No 2) [2005] VSCA 298
Australian courts have settled what a refused Calderbank offer actually buys, and it is less than practitioners often assume. Warren CJ, Maxwell P and Harper AJA record and reject the argument “that a Calderbank offer gives rise to a presumption that the party rejecting the offer should pay the offeror’s costs on an indemnity basis if the offeree receives a less favourable result”, agreeing with Redlich J that the authorities point to “an approach that involves no preconceptions” and that a special costs order follows only “where it is concluded that the rejection of the offer was unreasonable” ([18]-[19]). Their Honours note the same rejection by the New South Wales Court of Appeal, the Federal Court and the Queensland Court of Appeal. The correct approach is “to treat the rejection of a Calderbank offer as a matter to which the Court should have regard when considering whether to order indemnity costs” ([20]). At [25] they list six matters a court should ordinarily consider: the stage of the proceeding at which the offer was received; the time allowed to consider it; the extent of the compromise offered; the offeree’s prospects of success assessed as at the date of the offer; the clarity of the offer’s terms; and whether it foreshadowed an indemnity costs application.
Clarified by legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 131
In the uniform evidence jurisdictions the costs exception now has a statutory footing of its own: s 131(2)(h) provides that the exclusion of evidence of settlement negotiations does not apply where the communication is relevant to determining liability for costs. The practice this case named still governs how such an offer is framed and when refusing it is unreasonable, but a party no longer depends on the reservation alone for the court to see the offer on costs.
What happened?
A wife offered her husband a house in English ancillary relief proceedings. The real question: can a “without prejudice” offer later be used on costs? Without consent, such letters usually couldn’t be. Unlike money claims, there was no clear equivalent protection here.
What did the Court decide?
The Court of Appeal awarded the wife her costs. Later, in Cutts v Head, Oliver and Fox LJJ called Cairns LJ’s formulation mere dictum, not the actual holding. Cairns LJ drew on existing Lands Tribunal and Admiralty Court practice. Decided 1975; usually cited as [1976] Fam 93.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
A settlement offer may be made in a without prejudice communication on terms reserving the right to rely on it when costs are argued, so that a party who refuses a reasonable offer and does no better risks an adverse costs order.
Why does this case matter?
A Calderbank offer raises the stakes in costs disputes: lose after refusing one, and you may face indemnity costs, not just ordinary costs.
But beating your own offer doesn’t automatically trigger this. Courts ask whether refusal was unreasonable, judged at the time, not with hindsight from the result.
The device’s origins lie in dictum from an English matrimonial appeal, itself borrowed from the Lands Tribunal. It became entrenched through practice, not formal rule-making.
Check your understanding
Your client refuses a Calderbank offer of $400,000 and recovers $360,000 at trial. Opposing counsel says indemnity costs follow. What is the actual question, and what is being assessed as at when?