Enforcing a registered mortgage: the default notice and the power of sale
The statutory sequence a mortgagee of Torrens land must complete before it can sell: the default that must have occurred and for how long, the notice and what it must say, who else must receive a copy, whether the mortgage may shorten or dispense with the notice, the standard the statute imposes on the sale, the order in which the proceeds are applied, and why a purchaser’s title survives a defective exercise of the power.
Learning outcomes
- Determine whether a mortgagee’s power of sale over Torrens land has arisen, by identifying the default, the period it must have continued and the notice the jurisdiction’s statute requires.
- State what a default notice must contain and who besides the mortgagor must be served with a copy in the relevant jurisdiction.
- Identify whether the mortgage itself may shorten or dispense with the statutory notice in the relevant jurisdiction.
- Apply the statutory order in which sale proceeds must be applied, and state the standard the statute imposes on the mortgagee in selling where it imposes one.
- Explain why a purchaser’s registered title generally survives a defective exercise of the power of sale, and what remedy that leaves the mortgagor.
A mortgagee of Torrens land that wants its money back almost always sells the land, and the question a problem asks is rarely whether the mortgagee has a power of sale. It has one, which comes from the statute, the mortgage, or both. The question is whether that power has arisen — and the answer is a sequence of statutory conditions the mortgagee must complete in order: a default of the right kind, continuing for a stated period, a notice saying stated things, served on stated people, followed by a further stated period. This article states that sequence for all eight States and Territories. The characterisation of the mortgage as security rather than ownership, the mortgagee’s other remedies and the equity of redemption are treated in Mortgages.
The power of sale is statutory, and so are its preconditions
Every Torrens statute states that a registered mortgage is not a transfer of the land. The older Acts say so negatively — a registered mortgage “has effect as a security but does not operate as a transfer of the land mortgaged or charged”, to which Victoria and Tasmania add that it is an interest in land1256710 — while Queensland and the Northern Territory say it positively and in identical words: a registered mortgage “operates only as a charge on the lot or interest for the debt or liability secured by the mortgage”.38
The mortgagee therefore takes no ownership of the land; what it holds is a security interest. Its power to sell may come from the statute, from the mortgage, or from both: Queensland’s implied power to sell the mortgaged property is one that “takes effect as a term of the mortgage” and the section conferring it “applies subject to any agreement to the contrary”,4 and the Northern Territory regulates the exercise of a power of sale “whether conferred by an Act or an instrument of mortgage”.9 What each of the eight statutes supplies is the set of conditions on which the power may be exercised — the conditions tabulated below, subject to the variations by agreement explained after them. Those conditions are not always in the Torrens statute: Queensland and the Northern Territory do not state them there at all, because a registered mortgagee there has the powers and liabilities of a mortgagee under part 8 of the Property Law Act 2023 (Qld)3 or under Part 7 of the Law of Property Act 2000 (NT).8 A student answering from the Torrens statute alone will find the characterisation and miss the rules.
Two clocks in five jurisdictions, one in three
The older pattern runs two periods: the default must continue for a stated time before a notice may be served at all, and the notice then has its own period to run before the power of sale arises. Victoria, Western Australia, South Australia and the Australian Capital Territory each use one month and one month; Tasmania uses 30 days and 30 days, the only jurisdiction of the eight to measure both periods in days.256710
New South Wales, Queensland and the Northern Territory run one period only, measured from service of the notice. In New South Wales the power in s 58 becomes exercisable where the notice’s requirements are not met “within one month after service of the notice”, or within any longer period the mortgage fixes.1 Queensland’s notice “requires the default to be remedied within 30 days after the notice is given to the mortgagor”.4 The Northern Territory splits the period by the kind of default: 30 days for a default in paying principal or interest, but “the default has continued for 14 days after the service of the notice” where the default is in observing a provision of the mortgage.9
| Jurisdiction | Before notice | After notice | Provisions |
|---|---|---|---|
| NSW | no separate period | 1 month after service | Real Property Act 1900 ss 57, 581 |
| Vic | 1 month | 1 month after service | Transfer of Land Act 1958 ss 76, 772 |
| Qld | no separate period | 30 days after notice given | Property Law Act 2023 s 1144 |
| WA | 1 month | 1 month after service | Transfer of Land Act 1893 ss 106, 1085 |
| SA | 1 month | 1 month from the notice | Real Property Act 1886 ss 132, 1336 |
| Tas | 30 days | 30 days from service or publication | Land Titles Act 1980 ss 77, 787 |
| NT | no separate period | 30 days, or 14 days for a non-monetary default | Law of Property Act 2000 s 899 |
| ACT | 1 month | 1 month after service | Land Titles Act 1925 ss 93, 9410 |
The stated period is not always the operative one, so the instrument must be read before the statute’s figure is used. Victoria, Western Australia, South Australia, Tasmania and the Australian Capital Territory each let the mortgage fix a different period in either direction;256710 New South Wales admits only a period exceeding one month;1 the Northern Territory allows agreement on the monetary period but not below one day, and fixes the 14 days for a non-monetary default without any such latitude;9 and Queensland’s 30 days applies despite any agreement to the contrary.4
What the notice must say, and who else must receive it
South Australia, Tasmania and the Australian Capital Territory require a demand to pay the money then due or observe the covenants, plus a warning — “and that sale will be effected if such default be continued” in South Australia, “and that sale will be effected unless the default be remedied” in the Australian Capital Territory.6107 Queensland requires the notice to state the nature of the default and the 30-day remedy period, and the Northern Territory requires the approved form.49 New South Wales is the most prescriptive: the notice must identify itself as a notice under s 57(2)(b) of the Act, require the default to be remedied or the money paid, specify any reasonable amount demanded for the costs of preparing and serving it, and notify the mortgagor of the period and of the proposed sale.1
Service is a separate question. Where a notice is required under s 57(2)(b), New South Wales requires a copy of the notice to be served on later registered mortgagees and chargees, on caveators claiming as unregistered mortgagees or chargees, and on priority-notice lodgers making that same claim; the power does not arise until that is done.1 Victoria requires service on the mortgagor and on such other persons as appear by the Register to be affected.2 Western Australia lists the permitted modes: service “is not properly effected unless” the notice is delivered personally, sent by registered post to an address in the Register or known to be current, sent by a prescribed electronic means, or “left in a conspicuous place on the mortgaged or charged land”.5 Section 106(3) also preserves facsimile service where the recipient had specified in writing, under the former s 106(2)(d), that notices could be served that way. South Australia, Tasmania and the Australian Capital Territory instead permit the notice to be left on the land or at the mortgagor’s usual or last known place of abode.6710
The structure parallels the lessor’s notice before forfeiting a lease, discussed in Leases: dealings, breach and termination: specify the default, allow a period to remedy it, and only then take the remedy.
Whether the mortgage can cut the notice away
Two jurisdictions let the mortgage dispense with the notice and two forbid it. In New South Wales the mortgage may dispense with the notice or the waiting period, but only for a non-monetary default: s 58A(1) expressly excludes notice or lapse of time relating to default in payment of principal, interest, an annuity, a rent-charge or other money.1 Tasmania draws no such line — any notice or lapse of time prescribed by s 77 or s 78 “may, by agreement expressed in the mortgage or encumbrance or otherwise in writing, be dispensed with”.7 Queensland’s s 114 and the Northern Territory’s s 89 each apply despite any contrary agreement or provision in the mortgage.49
The Northern Territory’s s 89(1) has one statutory exception, inserted by the Land Legislation Amendment Act 2023 (NT) with effect from 2 January 2024. Where mortgaged freehold property has been disclaimed by a bankrupt’s trustee under s 133(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) or by a liquidator under s 568(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), and the conditions in s 89A(1) or (2) are met, s 89A(4) lets the mortgagee exercise the power of sale “[d]espite section 89(1)” once notice in the approved form has been given to each person with an interest in the property and to the Registrar-General. Section 89A(5) forbids the sale until 30 days after the last of those notices, and s 89A(6) excludes a power of sale conferred under the Land Title Act 2000 (NT). The same Act amended ss 90 and 93; the change to s 93 is that, where the money arises from the sale of such disclaimed property, s 93(3) requires the residue mentioned in s 93(2)(g) to be paid into the court. So the notice periods stated for the Northern Territory in this article are the rule for an ordinary default and are qualified, not displaced, for disclaimed property.9
New South Wales adds a protection from the other end: a clause accelerating the whole debt on default has no force or effect until the s 58 powers have actually become exercisable by reason of that default, and compliance with the notice in time means the default is deemed not to have occurred.1
The standard on sale, and where the money goes
Four jurisdictions put a standard inside the statute. Victoria and Tasmania require the mortgagee to sell “in good faith and having regard to the interests of the mortgagor”.27 Queensland and the Northern Territory state a duty as to price: “The mortgagee must take reasonable care to ensure the property is sold at the market value of the property”,4 and in the Northern Territory it is the mortgagee’s duty “to take reasonable care to ensure that the property is sold at its market value”.9 Neither duty can be bargained away: in the Northern Territory “An agreement or a term of an agreement is void to the extent that it relieves” a mortgagee of it,9 and the Queensland section applies despite any agreement to the contrary, with specific obligations as to advertising, evidence of value, maintenance and sale by auction, and a maximum penalty, for a mortgage prescribed by regulation.4 The power-of-sale sections of New South Wales, South Australia, Western Australia and the Australian Capital Territory state no standard as to price on their face; the general constraint on a selling mortgagee is treated in Mortgages.
In New South Wales, Victoria and the Australian Capital Territory the proceeds run through the same broad sequence: the expenses of the sale, then the money owing on the mortgage, then subsequent mortgages and encumbrances in order of priority, then what is left to the mortgagor.1210 Victoria qualifies both ends of that sequence. The first item is “all costs charges and expenses properly incurred incidental to the sale and consequent on such default”, so costs flowing from the default itself are recoverable before the debt; and the residue under s 77(3)(d) is payable “to the mortgagor or into the Supreme Court” under s 69 of the Trustee Act 1958 (Vic), while on a sale by a mortgagee of land charged with a subsequent annuity, or a sale by an annuitant, the residue must instead be paid into an interest-bearing deposit in the joint names of the annuitant and the Registrar, to meet the accruing payments of the charge.2 Three jurisdictions add to that list. Tasmania inserts the claims of persons who had lodged caveats subsisting when the power was exercised, after subsequent mortgagees and before the mortgagor.7 For a selling mortgagee not entitled to the benefit of an overriding statutory charge, the Northern Territory puts a person with Commonwealth-law priority, a registered overriding statutory charge and a prior discharging mortgagee ahead of the selling mortgagee.9 Queensland makes the character of the mortgagee’s holding explicit: “The proceeds of sale must be held by the mortgagee in trust”, to be applied in the statutory order.4 The Western Australian and South Australian power-of-sale sections cited here state no order of application.56
Why a defective sale does not usually undo the purchaser’s title
A mortgagee that sells without completing the sequence has acted beyond its power, and a student’s instinct is that the sale must be void. That does not necessarily follow. In Victoria “the title of the purchaser shall not be impeachable on the ground that no case had arisen to authorize the sale”,2 and in the Australian Capital Territory “the title of the transferee shall not be impeachable on the ground that no case has arisen to authorise the sale”.10 Each adds that a person damnified has a remedy in damages against the person who exercised the power. The Northern Territory says the same of a breach of the duty as to price, and Queensland lets a person who suffers loss from a breach of that duty or an improper exercise of the power claim compensation.94
New South Wales, Western Australia, Tasmania and Queensland relieve the purchaser of particular inquiries rather than of inquiry at large, and it is worth reading which. In New South Wales the purchaser is “not concerned to inquire as to the fact of any default or notice having been made or served as referred to in section 57 (2)”;1 in Western Australia “no purchaser shall be bound to see or inquire whether such default as aforesaid shall have been made” or whether the notice was served, “or otherwise into the propriety or regularity of” the sale;5 in Tasmania the purchaser “shall not be concerned to inquire whether any default or notice has been made or given”;7 and in Queensland the buyer “need not inquire whether the power of sale was properly exercised, including, for example, whether notice of the sale was given”.4 Sections 132 and 133 of the Real Property Act 1886 (SA) contain no purchaser-inquiry protection of this kind.6 So once the transfer is registered, the mortgagor’s complaint about the notice is usually a claim for money against the mortgagee rather than a claim to get the land back, and a mortgagor who wants the land must act before the sale is completed.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the jurisdiction and then the Act. For Queensland and the Northern Territory, move straight from the Torrens statute’s routing provision to the Property Law Act 2023 (Qld) or the Law of Property Act 2000 (NT); the notice rules are not in the Land Title Act.
- Characterise the default as a default in paying money or in observing a covenant. That changes the waiting period in the Northern Territory and decides whether the mortgage could dispense with notice in New South Wales.
- Read the mortgage before using the statute’s period, and check which direction that jurisdiction allows the period to move.
- Count both clocks where the jurisdiction has two: how long the default had continued before the notice was given, and then the further period, measured from the trigger the section names — service of the notice in Victoria, Western Australia and the Australian Capital Territory, “the date of such notice” in South Australia, and “the date of service or publication of the notice” in Tasmania.
- Test the notice against the subsection, content first and then service. Ask who else had to receive a copy — later mortgagees and caveators in New South Wales, persons appearing by the Register in Victoria — and, in Western Australia, whether the manner of service was permitted.
- If the sale has settled, trace the proceeds through the statutory order and ask whether the claim is for damages or compensation against the mortgagee rather than for recovery of the land.
Self-check
- Have I named the Act, the jurisdiction and the section, rather than “the power of sale provision”?
- Have I checked whether this jurisdiction requires the default to continue before notice as well as after it, and read the mortgage for a period that displaces the statutory one?
- Have I asked whether anyone besides the mortgagor had to be served, and whether this jurisdiction’s statute states a standard as to the price obtained?