Use as a trade mark: infringement and removal for non-use
Why “use as a trade mark” is the gateway to infringement under s 120 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), how courts decide whether a sign is used as a badge of origin, and how use by the owner or an authorised user keeps a registration safe from removal for non-use.
Learning outcomes
- Decide objectively, from the context of the trade and the presentation of the sign, whether a sign was used as a trade mark in the sense of a badge of origin.
- Explain why use as a trade mark is a separate element of infringement under s 120 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) that must be established before deceptive similarity or a s 122 defence is considered, using Shell v Esso and Self Care v Allergan.
- Apply the non-use grounds in s 92(4), the timing rule in s 93 and the burden in s 100 to an application to remove a registered mark.
- Determine whether goods sold in Australia without the owner’s knowledge amount to use by the registered owner through an authorised user, applying E & J Gallo Winery v Lion Nathan.
Under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), which is Commonwealth law applying throughout Australia, the idea of use decides two different disputes. It decides whether a defendant has infringed a registered mark, because infringement requires that the defendant “uses as a trade mark” a sign. It also decides whether an owner keeps its registration, because a mark its owner has not used can be removed from the Register. In either dispute a student must first ask whether the sign was being used as a badge of origin, and by whom, because a sign that, in its context, only describes the goods or conveys a message about them is not used as a trade mark at all.
What “use as a trade mark” means
A trade mark is “a sign used, or intended to be used, to distinguish goods or services dealt with or provided in the course of trade by a person from goods or services so dealt with or provided by any other person” (s 17).1 Use of a mark in relation to goods means use “upon, or in physical or other relation to, the goods”, and use in relation to services means use in physical or other relation to the services (s 7(4), (5)).
In E & J Gallo Winery v Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd [2010] HCA 15, French CJ, Gummow, Crennan and Bell JJ held that distinguishing the owner’s goods from others’ goods and indicating a connection in the course of trade between the goods and the owner are essential characteristics of a trade mark, and approved the statement that use “as a trade mark” is use as a “badge of origin” (at [42]–[43]).2 In Self Care IP Holdings Pty Ltd v Allergan Australia Pty Ltd (2023) 277 CLR 186, the whole Court explained how that is decided (at [24]–[25]).3 The question is assessed objectively, without reference to the user’s subjective trading intentions, and by reference to context: the relevant trade, the way the words are displayed and how they would present themselves to readers. A descriptive element does not necessarily prevent use as a trade mark; where a sign is used for several purposes, it is enough if one purpose is to distinguish the goods; and the presence of a clear dominant brand is relevant but does not mean another part of a label cannot also distinguish.
Infringement needs use as a trade mark first
Infringement under s 120(1) has two separate and essential elements: the defendant used a sign as a trade mark in relation to goods or services, and the sign is substantially identical with or deceptively similar to a mark registered for those goods or services (Self Care at [22]).4 If the first element fails, the comparison of marks does not arise.
Shell Co of Australia Ltd v Esso Standard Oil (Australia) Ltd [1963] HCA 66; (1963) 109 CLR 407 is the classic example, decided under the Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth).5 Esso’s registered marks were drawings of a humanised oil drop. Shell broadcast animated television advertisements in which an oil-drop figure, constantly changing shape, personified Shell petrol. Kitto J, with whom Dixon CJ, Taylor J and Owen J agreed, held that the Act implied that infringing use must be use as a trade mark, and asked whether the pictures would have appeared to viewers as marks for distinguishing Shell petrol from other petrol (at 424–425). They would not: the only purpose that could be seen in the figure was to convey a message about the qualities of Shell petrol, so there was no infringement even assuming that the figure at moments was substantially identical with the marks (at 422, 425). McTiernan J dissented.
Self Care applied the same test under the 1995 Act. Self Care’s anti-wrinkle products carried the phrase “instant Botox® alternative”. The Court held that the phrase was not used as a trade mark because its size, font and presentation were inconsistent across the packaging and website, it appeared beside two clear badges of origin, FREEZEFRAME and INHIBOX, and it was a descriptive phrase with an ordinary meaning that the primary judge had called “ad-speak” (at [55]–[57]). Because there was no use as a trade mark, deceptive similarity did not arise, and it was unnecessary to consider the good faith descriptive use defence in s 122(1)(b) or the comparative advertising defence in s 122(1)(d) (at [61]).
That sequence matters in a problem answer. Section 122 applies “in spite of section 120”, so its defences, including good faith use of a sign to indicate the kind, quality, intended purpose or another characteristic of goods or services, are reached only if the elements of infringement are made out.6
Removal for non-use
A person may apply to have a registered mark removed from the Register, either to the Registrar or, if an action concerning the mark is pending, to a prescribed court (s 92(1), (3)). A non-use application may be made on two grounds only (s 92(4)):7
- that, when the application for registration was filed, the applicant had no intention in good faith to use the mark in Australia, to authorise its use in Australia, or to assign it to a body corporate for use by that body corporate in Australia, in relation to the goods or services to which the non-use application relates, and the owner has not used it, or not used it in good faith, in Australia before the period of one month ending on the day the non-use application is filed; or
- that the mark has remained registered for a continuous period of three years ending one month before the non-use application is filed, and at no time during that period did the person who was then the owner use it, or use it in good faith, in Australia for the relevant goods or services.
For a mark whose application for registration was filed on or after 24 February 2019, an application on the second ground may be made only after three years from the date the mark’s particulars were entered on the Register (s 93(2)); for earlier filings, the version of s 93 in force before that date continues to apply. The burden is on the owner, as the opponent of the application, to rebut the allegation of non-use (s 100(1)). Use by an authorised user, being a person who uses the mark under the owner’s control, including quality or financial control, is taken to be use by the owner (ss 7(3), 8). Even where the grounds are established, the Registrar or court may decide not to remove the mark if satisfied that it is reasonable to do so (s 101(3)).
Gallo shows how far “use by the owner” reaches. Wine bearing the BAREFOOT mark, sold by the owner’s licensee in the United States to a German distributor, was imported by an Australian wholesaler and sold in Australia during the statutory period, without the owner knowing (at [6]–[8]). The plurality held that this was use by the registered owner: an overseas owner who places the mark on goods, itself or through an authorised user, uses the mark in Australia when those goods are offered for sale and sold in Australia while still in the course of trade, whether or not it knowingly projected them into the Australian market (at [51]–[53]). The licensee was an authorised user because the owner exercised quality control (at [59]). The use was also in good faith: a relatively small amount of genuine use may be ordinary and genuine use judged by commercial standards, and 144 bottles offered for sale, with 41 proven sales, was enough (at [64]–[65]). Heydon J agreed with the substance of that reasoning (at [87]).
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the sign and the context in which it appeared, and ask objectively whether it was used to distinguish the defendant’s goods or services as a badge of origin.
- Weigh the presentation of the sign, whether it is descriptive, whether it appears beside a dominant brand and whether it conveys a message rather than an origin.
- Only if the sign was used as a trade mark, compare it with the registered mark and the registered goods or services under s 120, and then test any s 122 defence.
- For a removal question, identify the ground in s 92(4), fix the relevant period and check the timing in s 93.
- Ask whether the owner, or an authorised user under its control, used the mark in Australia in good faith during that period, remembering that the owner bears the burden and that a court may decline to remove the mark under s 101(3).