Use as a trade mark: infringement and removal for non-use
Infringement needs use as a trade mark first
Infringement under s 120(1) needs two separate elements. The defendant must have used a sign as a trade mark, and that sign must be substantially identical with or deceptively similar to a registered mark (Self Care at [22]). If the first element fails, the court does not need to compare the marks.
Shell v Esso is the classic example. Esso’s marks were drawings of a humanised oil drop; Shell ran ads with a similarly shaped oil-drop figure promoting its own petrol. Kitto J held that infringing use must be use as a trade mark, meaning a sign that distinguishes the trader’s goods from others. He found Shell’s figure was not used this way: it only conveyed a message about petrol quality, not origin. So there was no infringement, even though the figure sometimes looked substantially identical to Esso’s marks. McTiernan J dissented.
Self Care applied the same test under the current Act. Self Care used “instant Botox® alternative” on its products. The Court held this was not trade mark use: its presentation was inconsistent, it sat beside two clear brand names (FREEZEFRAME and INHIBOX), and it was merely descriptive “ad-speak”. Because there was no trade mark use, the Court did not need to consider deceptive similarity, nor the defences in s 122(1)(b) (good faith descriptive use) or s 122(1)(d) (comparative advertising).
This order matters for problem answers. Section 122 defences apply “in spite of section 120”, so they only become relevant once infringement under s 120 is first established.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by identifying the sign and the context it appeared in. Ask objectively whether it was used as a trade mark — meaning used as a badge of origin to distinguish the defendant’s goods or services.
Then weigh how the sign was presented. Is it descriptive? Does it sit beside a dominant brand? Does it just convey a message, rather than showing origin?
Only if the sign was used as a trade mark do you compare it with the registered mark and registered goods or services, under s 120. Then test whether any s 122 defence applies.
For a removal question, first identify the ground relied on under s 92(4). Fix the relevant time period and check the timing rules in s 93.
Finally, ask whether the owner, or an authorised user it controls, used the mark in Australia in good faith during that period. The owner carries the burden of proving this, but a court may still decide not to remove the mark, under s 101(3).
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.