The Treasurer’s foreign investment powers: national interest, national security and the last resort power

The Treasurer’s powers under the Foreign Acquisitions and Takeovers Act 1975 (Cth): the national interest and national security tests, conditions, prohibition and disposal orders and their time limit, the call-in and last resort powers from 1 January 2021, and why challenge runs through s 75(v) and s 39B rather than the ADJR Act, with narrow Tribunal review under s 130A.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
investment-and-financial-regulation
Topics
foreign-investment-review

Learning outcomes

  • Identify whether the national interest test or the national security test governs an order or condition under ss 67, 69 and 74 of the Foreign Acquisitions and Takeovers Act 1975 (Cth), and explain that neither is defined in the Act.
  • Apply the s 77 time limit, and state when the Treasurer may call in an action under s 66A and when the call-in power is excluded.
  • Work through the s 79A gateways, the intelligence-advice requirement, the s 79B redaction power and the s 79C preconditions before a last resort order.
  • Choose the correct route of challenge: judicial review under s 75(v) of the Constitution or s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), not the ADJR Act, and Tribunal review under s 130A only of a s 79A national security risk decision.
  • Explain what Canwest and Wight v Pearce decided about review of divestiture orders, and why the case law on the current powers is thin.

Once an action is within the Foreign Acquisitions and Takeovers Act 1975 (Cth) (FATA), Part 3 gives the Treasurer a toolkit: no objection, conditions, prohibition and disposal. Two tests govern its use, the national interest and national security. Since 1 January 2021 the Treasurer has also had a power to call in actions that did not have to be notified, and a “last resort” power to revisit actions already cleared. This article explains those powers and how a decision under them can be challenged, and assumes the four categories of action are already understood.

This is Commonwealth law, stated from Compilation No. 35 of the Act (compilation date 5 December 2025). The case law on the Act is thin. The two Federal Court decisions cited here applied general administrative law to an earlier version of the Act, and no decision on the 2021 powers or on Tribunal review under the Act is among the authorities cited here, so the powers are taught from the statute.

Two tests: national interest and national security

For a significant action (other than one called in by a notice under s 66A(4)), the Treasurer may prohibit it if satisfied that taking it would be contrary to the national interest (s 67(1)), and may order disposal if satisfied that its result is contrary to the national interest (s 69(1)).1 For a notifiable national security action that is not a significant action, an action the Treasurer has called in, or a notified reviewable national security action, the standard is narrower: the action, or its result, must be contrary to national security (ss 67(1A), 69(1A)). The conditions power in s 74 is split the same way.2

Neither standard is defined in the Act. The Foreign Investment Policy, a statement of government policy and not law, says the national interest is not defined and that the Act confers on the Treasurer the power to decide in each case.3 It lists considerations including national security, competition, taxation, consistency with other government policy, impacts on the economy and community, and the character of the investor. It treats national security as a subset of the national interest, assessed on advice from national security agencies, and describes the framework as a “negative test”: a proposal is presumed to proceed unless found contrary to the national interest or national security.

The ordinary toolkit and its time limit

If the Treasurer does not object, they give a no objection notification, without conditions (s 75) or with conditions (s 74). A condition may be imposed only if the Treasurer is satisfied that it is necessary to ensure the action is not contrary to the national interest, or to national security, as the case requires (s 74(2)). If the Treasurer objects, a prohibition order under s 67 can prohibit the whole or part of a proposed acquisition, issue of securities, agreement or business start-up, and an interim order of the same kind may be made for up to 90 days while the Treasurer considers it (s 68). For an action already taken, a disposal order under s 69 typically directs the acquirer to dispose of the interest within a specified period to persons who are not its associates. Section 70 limits disposal orders against a person who acted within a no objection notification.

These powers are time-limited.4 The Treasurer must not make an order or decision under Division 2 after the decision period ends, unless, for example, an interim order has been registered (s 77(1), (2)). The period is 30 days from the triggering event, such as receipt of a notice (s 77(8)). Before it ends, the Treasurer may extend it by notice with reasons, by up to 90 days in total, without observing the natural justice hearing rule (s 77A). The limit does not apply where the period began with the person’s own notice of a proposed action and the person took the action before the period, or an interim order’s period, ended (s 77(3)). Note 2 to s 77 points to the last resort powers for what remains after the time limit expires.

The call-in power

Section 66A lets the Treasurer review a reviewable national security action, or a significant action that is neither a notifiable action nor a notifiable national security action, if the Treasurer considers that it may pose a national security concern.5 An action already taken can be reviewed only within the time prescribed by the regulations (s 66A(2)), which is 10 years (Regulation s 60A).6 The Treasurer must give written notice of the review (s 66A(4)), which starts a decision period (s 77(6)).

The power cannot be used if, when the review would start, the action has been notified to the Treasurer, a no objection notification has been given, an exemption certificate covers it, or the Treasurer has already made an order or decision about it under Division 2 or 3 (s 66A(5)). That is why voluntary notification matters. The Commonwealth’s national security guidance page, last updated in July 2023, says investors can choose to notify voluntarily and receive certainty that the investment can no longer be called in for review.7 A called-in action found contrary to national security can be prohibited, ordered to be disposed of or made subject to conditions under the national security limbs of ss 67, 69 and 74.

The last resort power

Division 3 of Part 3 allows the Treasurer to revisit an action after it has been cleared or the time limit has run. Section 79A(1) has two gateways, and both must be passed.8 Under para (a), the action must have been dealt with in a listed way: for example, a no objection notification not since revoked, an exemption certificate, or the decision period ending without an order or decision. Under para (b), there must be one of three triggers:

  • the person notified the action and made a statement that was false or misleading in a material particular, or omitted something without which it was misleading;
  • the business, structure or organisation of the person, or the person’s activities, have materially changed since para (a) was satisfied; or
  • the circumstances or market in which the action was, or is proposed to be, taken have materially changed since then.

On the review, the Treasurer must decide whether a national security risk relating to the action exists, and must obtain, and have regard to, advice from an agency in the national intelligence community (s 79A(2)). The Treasurer must notify the person of the review unless that would prejudice Australia’s national security interests. A proposed action is then prohibited until the review is completed and an order is registered or a specified notice is given; for an action already taken, the Treasurer may give directions to address the risk, but not a direction requiring action of a kind mentioned in s 79E, the disposal order provision (s 79A(3), (5)).

Section 79B requires written notice of the outcome: a statement that no national security risk exists, or the Treasurer’s reasons for deciding that one does.9 The Treasurer may redact reasons that would disclose the risk or prejudice national security, and information relied on in the review on national security grounds. A notice is valid even if all of its contents are redacted (s 79B(3)).

Before making an order, the Treasurer must be reasonably satisfied of a link between the trigger and the risk (s 79C).10 A false or misleading statement must directly relate to the risk. For a change in the person’s business or activities, the risk it poses must not have been reasonably foreseeable, or have been only a remote possibility, when para (a) was satisfied. A change in circumstances or market must alter the nature of the risk. The Treasurer must also be satisfied that reasonable steps have been taken to negotiate in good faith to eliminate or reduce the risk so as to avoid an order, that requiring compliance with an order is reasonably necessary for that purpose, and that existing Commonwealth, State or Territory regulatory systems would not adequately deal with it. Section 79F applies the same preconditions to the conditions powers in ss 79G, 79H and 79J.

The orders are a prohibition order where taking a proposed action would be contrary to national security (s 79D) and a disposal order where the result of an action is contrary to national security (s 79E).11 The lesser powers vary the conditions of a no objection notification (s 79G) or impose conditions by notice (s 79H), where reasonably necessary to eliminate or reduce the risk. In exercising these powers the Treasurer may have regard to any matter, and need not have regard to a particular matter unless the Division requires it (s 79K).

Challenging a decision

The ADJR Act is not available. Schedule 1 to the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) lists classes of decisions to which that Act does not apply, and para (h) is “decisions under the Foreign Acquisitions and Takeovers Act 1975”.12

Judicial review runs through the constitutional route. The High Court has original jurisdiction in matters in which mandamus, prohibition or an injunction is sought against an officer of the Commonwealth (Constitution s 75(v)).13 The Federal Court has corresponding jurisdiction under s 39B(1) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), subject to exceptions in that section, and jurisdiction in matters arising under laws of the Parliament (s 39B(1A)(c)).14 The grounds are the general grounds of judicial review.

The decided cases illustrate this, with two cautions. Both are first-instance decisions of single judges of the Federal Court, persuasive rather than binding, and both were decided under the Act’s earlier numbering. In Canwest Global Communications Corporation v Treasurer of the Commonwealth of Australia [1997] FCA 730, Hill J held that the Court had jurisdiction to review divestiture orders made under the former s 18(4), although review was circumscribed by the breadth of the national interest consideration entrusted to the Treasurer.15 His Honour held that, there being no indication in the Act that natural justice was excluded, the Treasurer had to give a person affected an opportunity to be heard before making such an order. The four orders were set aside because the companies directed to sell had not been given that opportunity. In Wight v Pearce [2007] FCA 26, Besanko J quashed a divestiture order under the former s 21A(4) because the applicant had not been told that alleged visa violations might be taken into account, nor invited to comment on them.16 His Honour declined to infer that the decision-maker had not in fact been satisfied that the acquisition was contrary to the national interest, saying a court will be slow to interfere with a Minister’s decision about what is in the national interest. Neither case concerned ss 66A or 79A to 79E, which did not then exist.

Merits review is narrow. Section 130A allows an application to the Administrative Review Tribunal for review of one decision: a decision of the Treasurer under s 79A that a national security risk exists in relation to an action.17 The applicant is the person given a s 79B(1) notice that such a risk exists, and that rule applies despite s 17 of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth). Section 130A does not extend to the orders and notices under ss 67, 69, 74 and 79D to 79H, or to national interest decisions. Where the Tribunal makes findings, the Treasurer must not exercise powers in respect of the action inconsistently with them, except on the basis of later matters or material changes, or of evidence not available at the time of the review (s 130L). The Tribunal may order the Commonwealth to pay a successful applicant’s costs (s 130M). Section 130A was inserted with Division 3 from 1 January 2021, then providing for review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, and was amended in 2024.18

One question is left open by the text. Section 79B(3) allows a notice to be validly given with all its contents redacted, while Canwest and Wight both turned on what a person had to be told before an adverse decision. How the hearing rule applies to a last resort decision whose reasons are redacted is not resolved by any authority cited here.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Classify the action and choose the test: national interest for a significant action other than one called in under s 66A(4); national security for a notifiable national security action that is not significant, a called-in action or a notified reviewable national security action (ss 67, 69, 74).
  2. Check the timing: is a decision period running or extended, has the time limit expired, and was the action taken during the period (s 77)?
  3. If the action was not notified, can it be called in under s 66A, given the exclusions in s 66A(5) and the 10-year limit?
  4. If it was cleared or the time limit has run, apply s 79A: the para (a) basis, the para (b) trigger, the intelligence advice, and the s 79C or s 79F preconditions.
  5. Identify the route of challenge: judicial review under s 75(v) or s 39B on general grounds such as denial of procedural fairness, not the ADJR Act (Sch 1 para (h)); Tribunal review under s 130A only of a s 79A decision that a national security risk exists.

Suppose an investor received an unconditional no objection notification for an Australian data business in 2022, and in 2026 the business begins storing personal information for a defence agency. Para (a)(i) is satisfied, and the change may be a material change in the circumstances in which the action was taken under para (b)(iii). The Treasurer must obtain intelligence advice and decide whether a national security risk exists. Before ordering disposal, the Treasurer must be reasonably satisfied that the change alters the nature of the risk posed in 2022, and must meet the negotiation, necessity and existing-systems conditions in s 79C. The investor can seek Tribunal review of the risk decision under s 130A, but a challenge to the disposal order itself must go to the Federal Court or the High Court.