The Treasurer’s foreign investment powers: national interest, national security and the last resort power

Two tests: national interest and national security

There are two main tests under the Act. One is the national interest test. The other is the national security test, which is narrower.

For a significant action, the Treasurer may prohibit it if satisfied it would be contrary to the national interest (s 67(1)). The Treasurer may also order disposal if the result is contrary to the national interest (s 69(1)). This does not apply to an action called in under s 66A(4).

A narrower test applies to certain national security actions. These include a notifiable national security action that is not significant, an action the Treasurer has called in, or a notified reviewable national security action. For these, the action or its result must be contrary to national security, not merely the national interest (ss 67(1A), 69(1A)). The conditions power in s 74 follows this same split.

Neither “national interest” nor “national security” is defined in the Act itself.

The Foreign Investment Policy gives guidance, but it is government policy, not law. It says the national interest is undefined, and the Act lets the Treasurer decide case by case. It lists relevant factors: national security, competition, taxation, consistency with other policies, economic and community impacts, and the investor’s character.

The Policy treats national security as one part of the broader national interest test. National security assessments draw on advice from security agencies. The Policy also calls this a “negative test,” meaning a proposal is presumed to proceed unless shown to be contrary to the national interest or national security.

The ordinary toolkit and its time limit

If the Treasurer does not object, they issue a no objection notification. This can be without conditions (s 75) or with conditions (s 74). A condition can only be imposed if the Treasurer is satisfied it is necessary to protect the national interest or national security (s 74(2)).

If the Treasurer does object, different orders apply. A prohibition order (s 67) can stop all or part of a proposed action. An interim order (s 68) can pause things for up to 90 days while the Treasurer decides. For action already taken, a disposal order (s 69) usually requires the acquirer to sell the interest to a non-associate within a set time. Section 70 limits disposal orders where the person acted under a no objection notification.

These powers are time-limited. The Treasurer generally cannot make an order after the decision period ends, unless an interim order has been registered (s 77(1), (2)). The period is normally 30 days from a triggering event, like receiving a notice (s 77(8)).

Before that period ends, the Treasurer may extend it by written notice with reasons. The total extension cannot exceed 90 days, and the natural justice hearing rule does not apply here (s 77A).

The time limit does not apply if the person themselves started the period by giving notice, and then took the action before that period (or an interim order period) ended (s 77(3)).

Note 2 to s 77 says that once the time limit runs out, the Treasurer may still rely on the last resort powers.

Challenging a decision

You cannot use the ADJR Act to challenge these decisions. Schedule 1 of that Act excludes decisions made under the Foreign Acquisitions and Takeovers Act.

Instead, judicial review goes through the Constitution. The High Court has jurisdiction under s 75(v) to grant mandamus, prohibition or an injunction against a Commonwealth officer. The Federal Court has similar jurisdiction under s 39B of the Judiciary Act, subject to some exceptions. Ordinary judicial review grounds apply.

Two cases illustrate this, but with cautions: both are single-judge Federal Court decisions (so persuasive, not binding), and both used the Act’s old section numbers. In Canwest, Hill J found the Court could review divestiture orders, though review was limited because the national interest test gives the Treasurer wide discretion. His Honour also held natural justice applied: the Treasurer had to let affected persons respond before ordering divestiture. The orders were set aside because this hadn’t happened.

In Wight v Pearce, Besanko J quashed a divestiture order because the applicant wasn’t told that visa issues would be considered, denying them a chance to comment. However, his Honour refused to find the Treasurer hadn’t actually turned his mind to the national interest test, noting courts are slow to second-guess such decisions. Neither case dealt with the current national security provisions, which didn’t exist yet.

Merits review is narrow. Section 130A allows an application to the Administrative Review Tribunal, but only for one kind of decision: the Treasurer’s finding under s 79A that a national security risk exists.

Applying this in a problem question

Working through a problem question means following five steps in order.

First, classify the action. Use the national interest test for a significant action, unless it was called in under s 66A(4). Use the national security test for a notifiable national security action that is not significant, not a called-in action, and not a notified reviewable national security action (ss 67, 69, 74).

Second, check timing. Work out if a decision period is running or extended, whether the time limit expired, and whether the action happened within that period (s 77).

Third, if the action was never notified, ask whether it can still be called in under s 66A. Check the exclusions in s 66A(5) and the 10-year limit.

Fourth, if the action was cleared or the time limit expired, apply s 79A. This means checking the para (a) basis, the para (b) trigger, the intelligence advice, and the preconditions in s 79C or s 79F.

Fifth, identify how to challenge the decision. Judicial review goes under s 75(v) or s 39B, on general grounds like denial of procedural fairness (explained as unfairness in the process) -- not under the ADJR Act (Sch 1 para (h)). Tribunal review under s 130A is only available for a s 79A decision that a national security risk exists.

The example: an investor got an unconditional no objection notification in 2022 for a data business. In 2026 the business starts storing personal information for a defence agency. This satisfies para (a)(i), and may count as a material change under para (b)(iii).

The Treasurer must get intelligence advice and decide if a national security risk now exists. Before ordering disposal, the Treasurer must be reasonably satisfied the change alters the nature of the 2022 risk, and must meet the s 79C conditions on negotiation, necessity, and existing systems.

The investor can seek Tribunal review of the risk decision under s 130A. But a challenge to the disposal order itself must go to the Federal Court or High Court.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →