Standards of proof and how they are applied
Two standards across three questions in the uniform Acts: the civil balance of probabilities and what s 140(2) directs, the two standards s 141 carries in a criminal proceeding, and the balance of probabilities s 142 applies to admissibility questions except where the Act provides its own test.
Learning outcomes
- Apply the right standard to the right question, including admissibility under s 142.
- Explain what s 140(2) directs without treating it as a higher civil standard.
- Identify whose case a proposition belongs to, and where that allocation comes from, before naming a criminal standard.
- Check whether the Act supplies its own test before applying s 142, and work s 142(2)’s two matters.
The uniform evidence legislation works with two standards of proof — the balance of probabilities and beyond reasonable doubt — and the difficulty is never in reciting them. It is in getting the right one onto the right question, because the standard-of-proof Part applies them to three different questions: the case of a party in a civil proceeding, the case of the prosecution and the case of a defendant in a criminal one, and the facts that decide whether evidence comes in at all. Not everything has to be proved at all: ss 143 and 144 provide that proof is not required about the matters of law and of common knowledge they describe.
This article states the position under the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Sections 140, 141 and 142 are enacted to the same effect, under the same numbers, in New South Wales, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory, so what follows is the scheme’s common position and not a Commonwealth peculiarity.4
Civil proceedings: the balance of probabilities, and what informs it
Section 140(1) requires the court to find a party’s case proved if satisfied it has been proved on the balance of probabilities. Section 140(2) then directs that, without limiting what the court may take into account, it is to take into account the nature of the cause of action or defence, the nature of the subject-matter of the proceeding, and the gravity of the matters alleged.1
That second subsection is the one students skip. It does not create a higher standard for serious allegations — the standard remains the balance of probabilities — but it requires the gravity of what is alleged to bear on whether the court is satisfied. An answer that says “fraud must be proved to a higher civil standard” has misstated it; an answer that ignores s 140(2) altogether has missed the provision that does the work.
Criminal proceedings: two different standards in one section
Section 141 carries both. Under s 141(1) the court is not to find the prosecution’s case proved unless satisfied it has been proved beyond reasonable doubt. Under s 141(2) the court is to find the defendant’s case proved if satisfied it has been proved on the balance of probabilities.2
So the standard depends on whose case the proposition belongs to — but s 141 does not answer that prior question. Section 141 supplies standards; it does not allocate burdens. Which party bears the burden on a matter, and whether that burden is a legal one or only evidential, comes from the applicable law, including the law creating the offence or defence and any general burden provisions. Section 141(2) supplies the measure only where that law places a legal burden on the defendant; it does not itself put any defence onto the defendant. Saying “the criminal standard applies” without first asking whose case the proposition belongs to, and on what authority it belongs there, gets it wrong.
Admissibility questions: s 142
Section 142 is the provision that catches people out. Except as otherwise provided by the Act, the facts necessary for deciding whether evidence should be admitted, whether or not in the exercise of a discretion, and any other question arising under this Act, are to be found proved if the court is satisfied they have been proved on the balance of probabilities. Subsection 142(2) then does for an admissibility question what s 140(2) does for a civil case: in determining whether it is so satisfied, the matters the court must take into account include the importance of the evidence in the proceeding and the gravity of the matters alleged in relation to the question.3
The consequence is worth stating plainly: except as the Act otherwise provides, the facts that decide an admissibility question are proved on the balance of probabilities even in a criminal trial, where the charge itself must be proved beyond reasonable doubt. The two standards operate on different questions in the same proceeding.
“Except as otherwise provided by this Act” is not decoration. Where another provision supplies its own test for an admissibility question, that provision governs and s 142 does not. Section 88 is the one to know: for the purpose of determining whether evidence of an admission is admissible, the court is to find that a particular person made the admission if it is reasonably open to find that he or she made it. That is a lower threshold than the balance of probabilities, and it applies to the very question — who made this admission — a student is most likely to reach for s 142 to answer. So s 142 is the default, and the first step is to ask whether the Act has displaced it.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the question being proved: an element of the case, or a fact that decides admissibility.
- If admissibility, ask first whether another provision supplies its own test (s 88 does, for who made an admission). Otherwise apply s 142 and the balance of probabilities, whatever the proceeding, and work s 142(2)’s two matters.
- If an element, ask whose case it is — prosecution (s 141(1)) or defendant (s 141(2)) — or whether the proceeding is civil (s 140(1)).
- In a civil case, work s 140(2)’s three matters rather than reaching for a sliding scale.
Self-check
- Can I state which standard applies to an admissibility question, and why it is not the trial standard?
- Do I treat s 140(2) as directing what informs satisfaction, rather than as raising the standard?
- In a criminal case, do I ask whose case the proposition belongs to — and what puts it there — before naming a standard?
- Do I check whether the Act supplies its own test, as s 88 does, before reaching for s 142?
A worked application
A defendant is charged with an offence. The prosecution tenders an admission said to have been made during questioning; the defence objects under s 138, saying it was improperly obtained. The defence also relies on a statutory defence on which it bears the legal burden.
Two standards operate across three questions in the one trial, and matching them correctly is most of the answer.
Whether the admission was improperly obtained is a fact necessary for deciding whether evidence should be admitted. Section 142 applies: it is proved on the balance of probabilities, even though this is a criminal trial, and s 142(2) requires the court to take into account the importance of the evidence and the gravity of the matters alleged in relation to that question. The same standard governs a fact the court must find in order to exercise a discretion over admission, because s 142(1)(a) reaches an admissibility question “whether in the exercise of a discretion or not” — not every judicial discretion, only the questions s 142 names.
Whether the defendant made the admission at all is the exception the Act itself writes in. Section 88 supplies its own test, and the court is to find that he made it if it is reasonably open to so find.
The elements of the offence belong to the prosecution’s case, so s 141(1) applies: the court is not to find them proved unless satisfied beyond reasonable doubt.
The statutory defence, on which the defendant bears the legal burden, is the defendant’s case, so s 141(2) applies and the measure is the balance of probabilities.
Now change the proceeding to a civil claim alleging the same conduct as fraud. Section 140(1) applies and the standard is the balance of probabilities. Section 140(2) does not raise it — but it requires the court, in deciding whether it is satisfied, to take into account the nature of the cause of action, the nature of the subject-matter, and the gravity of the matters alleged. An allegation of fraud is grave, and that bears on satisfaction without creating a third standard. An answer that writes “the civil standard is higher for fraud” has stated a rule the Act does not contain.
Where the authority sits
The standards are statutory, in Part 4.1 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) and (NSW), the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic), the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT) and the Evidence (National Uniform Legislation) Act 2011 (NT). The Evidence Act 2001 (Tas) numbers its Parts within its Chapters, so the same three sections there sit in Chapter 4 (“Proof”), Part 1 (“Standard of proof”) — the section numbers are identical, only the Part label differs. Corroboration is Part 4.4 in the first five Acts and Chapter 4 Part 4 in Tasmania, and it is a different subject. Next door, Part 4.2 — Chapter 4 Part 2 in Tasmania — is where ss 143 and 144 remove the need for proof altogether. The three sections are enacted to the same effect in all six jurisdictions; the differences are drafting ones, and the Victorian Act says “an accused” where the others say “a defendant”. Identify the court before stating the standards: Queensland and South Australia have not enacted the uniform scheme for their own courts, and Western Australia has enacted it as the Evidence Act 2025 (WA) but its substantive Parts do not commence until 18 September 2027; in all three, the standards are found in the common law and those States’ own legislation — though the substance of the civil and criminal standards is not peculiar to the uniform Acts.