Standards of proof and how they are applied
Criminal proceedings: two different standards in one section
Section 141 contains two different standards of proof, not one.
Under s 141(1), the court must not find the prosecution’s case proved unless it is proved beyond reasonable doubt. This is the criminal standard, and it is a high one.
Under s 141(2), the court can find the defendant’s case proved if it is proved on the balance of probabilities. This is the civil standard, and it is lower than the criminal one.
Which standard applies depends on whose case the proposition belongs to. But s 141 does not tell you whose case it is — that question comes from elsewhere.
Section 141 only supplies the standards of proof. It does not decide which party carries the burden of proving something, or whether that burden is legal (meaning they must actually prove it) or only evidential (meaning they must just point to some evidence).
That earlier question — who bears the burden, and why — depends on other applicable law, such as the law creating the offence or defence.
Section 141(2) only sets the standard for a defendant’s case where other law has already placed a legal burden on the defendant. It does not itself create or impose any such burden.
So it is wrong to simply say “the criminal standard applies” without first asking whose case is in issue, and what authority puts it there.
Admissibility questions: s 142
Section 142 trips many students up. It sets the standard of proof for admissibility questions: whether evidence should be admitted, and other questions under the Act. Unless the Act says otherwise, these facts need only be proved on the balance of probabilities (the civil standard, meaning more likely than not).
This applies even in criminal trials, even though the charge itself needs proof beyond reasonable doubt. The two standards apply to different questions within the same case.
Like s 140(2) for civil cases, s 142(2) lists factors the court must weigh. These include the importance of the evidence and the seriousness of the matters in question.
But s 142 only applies by default. If another section sets its own test for an admissibility question, that section applies instead. Section 88 is the key example: it asks only whether it is reasonably open to find a person made an admission, a lower bar than balance of probabilities.
So before reaching for s 142, check whether another provision already covers the question.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out what you’re proving: an element of the case, or a fact affecting admissibility.
If it’s about admissibility, check whether another provision sets its own test first. For example, s 88 has its own test for who made an admission. If no special provision applies, use s 142 instead. This applies the balance of probabilities, in any proceeding, and you work through the two matters listed in s 142(2).
If it’s an element of the case, ask whose case it belongs to. Use s 141(1) for the prosecution’s case, or s 141(2) for the defendant’s case. In a civil proceeding, use s 140(1) instead.
For a civil case, work through the three matters in s 140(2). Don’t treat this as a sliding scale of proof.
Self-check
Before moving on, test yourself with these questions.
First, can you say which standard of proof applies when a court decides if evidence is admissible? Can you explain why this differs from the standard used at trial?
Second, do you understand s 140(2) correctly? It guides what a court considers when reaching satisfaction. It does not change how high that standard is.
Third, in a criminal case, do you first ask whose case a proposition belongs to, and what places it there, before naming the standard that applies?
Finally, do you check whether the Act itself sets a specific test, as s 88 does, before applying s 142?
A worked application
Here is one example pulling several standards together. A defendant is charged, the prosecution tenders an admission, and the defence objects under s 138, saying it was improperly obtained. The defence also relies on a statutory defence it must prove.
Whether the admission was improperly obtained decides if the evidence can be used. Section 142 applies, so this is proved on the balance of probabilities, even in a criminal trial. Section 142(2) also makes the court weigh the evidence’s importance and the gravity of what is alleged.
Whether the defendant made the admission at all is different. Section 88 says the court only needs to find it reasonably open to conclude he made it.
The elements of the offence are the prosecution’s job. Section 141(1) applies, so they must be proved beyond reasonable doubt.
The statutory defence is the defendant’s job. Section 141(2) applies, so it only needs the balance of probabilities.
Now imagine the same conduct is claimed as fraud in a civil case. Section 140(1) applies, and the standard is still the balance of probabilities. Section 140(2) does not raise that standard — it only makes the court consider the seriousness of what is alleged when deciding if it is satisfied. Saying “fraud needs a higher civil standard” states a rule the Act does not contain.
Where the authority sits
These standards of proof come from statute. Part 4.1 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth and NSW), the Victorian, ACT and NT equivalents all place the rules there. Tasmania’s Act numbers Parts within Chapters, so the same sections sit in Chapter 4, Part 1 instead. The section numbers stay the same across all six; only the Part label differs in Tasmania.
Corroboration (evidence supporting other evidence) is a separate topic, found in Part 4.4 (Chapter 4 Part 4 in Tasmania). Nearby, Part 4.2 (Chapter 4 Part 2 in Tasmania) deals with ss 143 and 144, which remove the need for proof in some situations.
All six jurisdictions apply these three sections to the same effect. Differences are only drafting style — for example, Victoria says “an accused” where others say “a defendant”.
Before stating the standard, check which court is involved. Queensland and South Australia have not adopted this uniform scheme for their own courts. Western Australia has enacted it as the Evidence Act 2025 (WA), but its substantive Parts don’t commence until 18 September 2027.
In Queensland, South Australia, and (until 2027) Western Australia, the standards come from common law and each State’s own legislation instead. Even so, the substance of the civil and criminal standards is not unique to the uniform Acts.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.