Equity’s jurisdiction: intervention and its limits

What engages equity’s jurisdiction and what disciplines it: why “unconscionable” is a conclusion drawn from established principle rather than a ground of relief, when equity will restrain the exercise of a legal right, and what the Judicature system did not fuse. Built on four High Court decisions and the divisions within them.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, vic, qld, wa, sa, tas, nt, act
Subjects
equity-and-trusts
Topics
equitable-jurisdiction

Learning outcomes

  • Identify which recognised equitable principle a claim invokes before characterising any conduct as unconscionable.
  • State what generates the “equity” in a given doctrine, and use it to decide whether a court will restrain the exercise of a legal right.
  • Distinguish conduct assessed at the acquisition of a legal right from conduct assessed at its enforcement.
  • Attribute an equitable formulation to the reasons that contain it, and check whether the bench divided before writing that the Court held something.

Equity acts upon legal rights without denying that they exist, and a court of equity asks not whether an outcome is harsh but whether an established equitable principle requires the holder of a legal right to be restrained from asserting it. The prior question is therefore which equity is invoked: “unconscionable” is the conclusion a court reaches once a recognised principle is satisfied, not a ground of relief standing on its own. Get that order wrong and the answer asserts unfairness without identifying a doctrine. The decisions below are of the High Court of Australia and bind lower courts in every State and Territory, so the doctrine is uniform across Australia; the High Court can reconsider its own decisions.

“Unconscionable” is a conclusion, not a cause of action

In Tanwar Enterprises Pty Ltd v Cauchi (2003) 217 CLR 3151 a purchaser who had missed an essential completion date sought specific performance. The joint reasons of Gleeson CJ, McHugh, Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ — five of seven, Kirby J and Callinan J agreeing in the result in separate reasons — explained that “unconscientious” and “unconscionable” are used across a broad range of the equity jurisdiction and “describe in their various applications the formation and instruction of conscience by reference to well developed principles”. A court has first regard to those principles “rather than entering into the case at that higher level of abstraction involved in notions of unconscientious conduct in some loose sense where all principles are at large”.

Their Honours named two false notions the phrase “unconscionable conduct” encourages: that there is a distinct cause of action, akin to an equitable tort, wherever a plaintiff points to conduct meriting the epithet; and that there is an equitable defence to the assertion of any legal right whenever reliance on it has become unconscionable.

Why conduct that was innocent can still bar enforcement

The same reasons cut the other way. Legal rights may be acquired by conduct which pricks no conscience at the time — a misrepresentation may be wholly innocent — yet at the time of attempted enforcement it may be unconscientious to rely upon the rights so acquired. Misconduct at formation is neither necessary nor sufficient.

The purchaser nevertheless lost. The majority found nothing to suggest the vendors had lulled it into a false sense of security: they had withdrawn earlier termination notices in return for completion obligations in unqualified terms, and a third party’s failure to supply finance was within the purchaser’s contemplation. “Equity does not intervene to prevent the effective exercise of those rights.”

The jurisdiction to relieve against forfeiture

Equity does intervene where a recognised head of relief is engaged. In Legione v Hateley (1983) 152 CLR 4062 the purchasers of land in Victoria had paid a $6,000 deposit on a price of $35,000 and were to pay the residue on 1 July 1979, time being of the essence. They tendered the balance four days after the vendors’ notice requiring the default to be remedied had expired, and by then they had erected a dwelling on the land, which rescission would have handed to the vendors. Mason and Deane JJ held that specific performance may be decreed at the suit of a purchaser in breach of an essential condition, but “only in exceptional circumstances”, and that whether those exist “hinges on the existence of unconscionable conduct”. Their Honours identified five subsidiary questions: the vendor’s contribution to the breach; whether the breach was trivial or slight, and inadvertent rather than wilful; the damage the vendor suffered; the purchaser’s loss and the vendor’s gain if forfeiture stands; and whether specific performance, with or without compensation, safeguards the vendor.

The bench divided, and that matters to how the test is cited. Gibbs CJ and Murphy J accepted the jurisdiction by a different route, asking whether an order would prevent rather than cause injustice, and said the appeal should be dismissed while concurring in the remitter. Brennan J held that such a purchaser has no entitlement to relief against forfeiture of the land interest independent of the right to a decree enforcing the contract. The five questions are Mason and Deane JJ’s formulation, not a unanimous test.

Twenty years later the Court put those questions in their place. The joint reasons in Tanwar held that what Mason and Deane JJ said about the subsidiary questions “must be treated with care”, and that the vendors there were correct to challenge the doctrinal basis for treating them as determinative. The questions are subsidiary to the basic issue in Legione, which was the purchaser’s claim to relief against forfeiture of her interest in the land; their relevance cannot be assessed without first asking what interest in the land the purchaser had, whether that interest attracts the forfeiture jurisdiction, and how equity’s attitude to forfeiture relates to its attitude to express time stipulations. Work the five questions as a freestanding checklist and you have skipped the step that decides whether there is anything to relieve against.

What generates the “equity”: the penalties jurisdiction

Andrews v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2012] HCA 303 shows the same structure in another doctrine. In a single set of joint reasons, French CJ, Gummow, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ stated that the penalty doctrine is not engaged where the prejudice from failure of the primary stipulation cannot be evaluated and assessed in money terms. “It is the availability of compensation which generates the ‘equity’ upon which the court intervenes; without it, the parties are left to their legal rights and obligations.” Their Honours also rejected a limit urged on the jurisdiction: fees charged otherwise than upon breach, where the customer had no obligation to avoid the triggering event, are not for that reason incapable of characterisation as penalties.

The Judicature system did not merge the doctrines

The same reasons settle what the Judicature system achieved. Their Honours held that its only relevant effect was upon the procedures of the unified court system and not upon substantive doctrine: afterwards, in whichever court an action about a penalty was brought, a money remedy, declaratory and injunctive relief and an account became available in the one action. Earlier litigation illustrated the place of the penalty doctrine “in a court where there is a unified administration of law and equity but equitable doctrines retain their identity”.

Discretion exercised within principle

The discipline on the discretion was put most directly by Deane J in Muschinski v Dodds (1985) 160 CLR 5834. Proprietary rights, he said, are governed by principles of law rather than by judicial discretion or subjective views about which party ought to win, undefined notions of justice having given way in equity to ordered principle. It follows that the “mere fact that it would be unjust or unfair in a situation of discord for the owner of a legal estate to assert his ownership against another provides, of itself, no mandate for a judicial declaration that the ownership in whole or in part lies, in equity, in that other”. Fairness is not thereby irrelevant: general notions of fairness and justice “remain relevant to the traditional equitable notion of unconscionable conduct which persists as an operative component of some fundamental rules or principles of modern equity”.

That reasoning carried the orders without commanding the whole Court: the appeal was allowed, with Mason J agreeing in Deane J’s conclusions and proposed orders, while Brennan J and Dawson J would have dismissed it.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Name the equity relied on — relief against forfeiture, the penalty doctrine, estoppel, breach of fiduciary duty — before using the word “unconscionable” at all.
  2. State the conditions that doctrine imposes and work through them on the facts.
  3. Ask whether insistence on the legal right is unconscientious now, not only whether the right was acquired honestly.
  4. Identify what generates the equity in that doctrine: contribution to the breach, the availability of compensation, an induced assumption.
  5. Check whether the bench divided before writing “the Court held”.

Where the authority sits

Case law, in decisions of the High Court of Australia that bind lower courts in every Australian jurisdiction. No statute states the threshold for equitable intervention, and the Judicature provisions of each jurisdiction’s superior court legislation govern the administration of the two bodies of doctrine, not their content.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.