The safeguard mechanism and Australia’s legislated climate targets

How the Climate Change Act 2022 (Cth) states Australia’s legislated emissions targets, and how the safeguard mechanism in Part 3H of the National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting Act 2007 (Cth) turns them into facility baselines, a civil penalty duty and tradeable credits.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
environmental-and-planning-law
Topics
climate-and-resources-regulation

Learning outcomes

  • Distinguish the Commonwealth’s legislated emissions targets, which bind the Minister’s reporting and advice process, from the safeguard mechanism, which imposes a civil penalty duty on the responsible emitter of a covered facility.
  • Work out whether a facility is a designated large facility and whether an excess emissions situation exists, using the net emissions number and the baseline emissions number.
  • Trace how advice under the Climate Change Act 2022 and EPBC approvals feed back into the safeguard rules.

This article states Commonwealth law. Before asking what the law requires about greenhouse gas emissions, a student should ask a prior question: is the provision a national target, or an obligation on a particular facility? The Climate Change Act 2022 (Cth) states the targets and puts its duties on the Minister and the Climate Change Authority. The safeguard mechanism in Part 3H of the National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting Act 2007 (Cth) (the NGER Act) is where a limit falls on an emitter, and it does so through a legislative instrument, the Safeguard Mechanism Rule, which holds the figures. The general picture of climate and resources regulation is in Climate and resources regulation.

The targets, and whom they bind

Section 10 of the Climate Change Act states Australia’s targets: net emissions 43% below 2005 levels by 2030, implemented both as a point target and as an emissions budget for 2021 to 2030, and net zero by 2050.1 Reaching a target means getting net emissions to or below the target level, so s 10(1) does not stop emissions being reduced further. The targets are to be read consistently with the Paris Agreement and Australia’s nationally determined contribution, and a new or adjusted contribution must represent a progression or an enhancement.

Parts 3 to 5 of the Act put duties on government, not on emitters. The Minister must prepare an annual climate change statement within six months after each financial year and have it tabled, and the statement must address whether safeguard emissions are declining consistently with the safeguard outcomes. The Climate Change Authority must advise on that statement, the Minister must have regard to the advice, and the Minister must table reasons if a material aspect of written advice is not accepted. The Authority also advises on the targets for a new or adjusted nationally determined contribution when the Minister asks, and the Minister must ask for advice on a new contribution at least once every five years.2 A student should therefore treat the targets as a framework of accountability. Nothing in Parts 2 to 5 imposes an obligation on an emitter, and the Act says that s 10(1) is not intended to exclude State or Territory laws that can operate concurrently.

Which facilities are caught

The safeguard mechanism applies to a designated large facility: a facility whose covered emissions in a financial year exceed the number specified in the safeguard rules. Covered emissions are scope 1 emissions, other than kinds the rules exclude, and the responsible emitter is the person with operational control of the facility.5 The Rule sets the threshold at 100,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalence.7 The Act’s own objects state six safeguard outcomes, among them a cap of 1,233 million tonnes of total net safeguard emissions between 1 July 2020 and 30 June 2030, a fall to no more than 100 million tonnes for the financial year beginning 1 July 2029, and zero for any financial year beginning after 30 June 2049.4

The limit, the duty and the penalty

The limit is compared at the end of each monitoring period, which is a financial year, part of one, or a multi-year period the Regulator declares under the rules (or part of such a period). The net emissions number is the facility’s covered emissions, reduced (but not below zero) by prescribed carbon units surrendered for that purpose (Australian carbon credit units, safeguard mechanism credit units and any units the rules specify) and increased by Australian carbon credit units issued for an eligible offsets project where they are attributable to abatement at the facility. The safeguard rules can change how many units a surrender counts for, and the increase applies only where the conditions and exceptions in s 22XK(4)-(5) are met. The baseline emissions number is the number the safeguard rules ascertain. If the net emissions number exceeds the baseline an excess emissions situation exists, unless the Regulator has made an exemption declaration.5

The responsible emitter must ensure that no excess emissions situation exists by the 1 April after the financial year. Breach is a civil penalty provision. Section 22XF specifies, as the civil penalty amount, the number of penalty units equal to the difference between the net emissions number and the baseline; the Court determines the pecuniary penalty under s 31, up to a maximum fixed by reference to that amount.5 The Act requires the safeguard rules to allow an exemption declaration only on the responsible emitter’s application, and to require the Regulator to be satisfied that the excess is the direct result of a natural disaster, criminal activity or circumstances the rules treat as exceptional, with reasonable steps taken before and after to mitigate the risk.

How the baseline declines

The Act leaves baselines to the Rule. For an existing or new facility other than a landfill facility, which has its own formula, the baseline is worked out from an emissions reduction contribution and the facility’s production and emissions intensity numbers. The default contribution is 0.951 for the financial year beginning 1 July 2023 and falls by the default decline rate of 0.049 a year to 0.657 for the year beginning 1 July 2029, and then by 0.03285 a year, not below zero. A baseline below 100,000 is lifted to 100,000 unless it is below that merely because of a borrowing adjustment, a shale gas extraction facility has a zero baseline, and every baseline from the financial year beginning after 30 June 2049 is zero. For a trade-exposed baseline-adjusted facility the contribution falls by an amount set by a formula using a ratio of cost impacts, between minimum decline rates of 0.01 for a manufacturing facility and 0.02 otherwise and the default decline rate; the baseline also depends on the facility’s production and emissions intensity numbers.7

The responsible emitter of a facility whose baseline exceeds its covered emissions, together with any Australian carbon credit units that increase its net emissions number, may apply to the Regulator for safeguard mechanism credit units, calculated from the baseline as it would be without the 100,000 minimum less those emissions and units, subject to conditions that include that the facility is not a landfill facility. Because a safeguard mechanism credit unit is a prescribed carbon unit, it can later be surrendered to reduce a net emissions number.6

Who can change the numbers, and how the Acts feed each other

The Minister makes the safeguard rules, but only if satisfied that they are consistent with the outcomes on the cap on total emissions between 1 July 2020 and 30 June 2030, the declines to no more than 100 million tonnes for the financial year beginning 1 July 2029 and to zero for financial years beginning after 30 June 2049, and the rolling average, and that they take the other two outcomes into account, and the Minister must publish reasons. If the Authority advises under s 14 of the Climate Change Act that emissions are not declining consistently and that the rules need amendment, the Minister must consult publicly and, if satisfied the rules need amending, amend them.6 The targets therefore reach a facility indirectly: through the Authority’s advice, the Minister’s rule-making and the baselines the Rule sets.

The Acts connect to environmental approval in one place. Where the Environment Minister approves an action under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth), is satisfied that it is likely to increase scope 1 emissions from a designated large facility or create a new one, and has an estimate of those emissions, the estimate must be passed to the Minister, the Climate Change Secretary and the Authority.3 That section requires the information to be passed on. It does not make emissions a ground for refusing approval, and the EPBC assessment process is described in EPBC assessment approaches and controlled actions.

State and Territory laws are not excluded where they can operate concurrently, subject to s 5 of the NGER Act, which excludes State and Territory laws on reporting or disclosing emissions, energy consumption or production that the regulations prescribe, so far as they would apply to a constitutional corporation.6

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Decide whether the question is about a national target or about a facility’s obligation. A target in s 10 of the Climate Change Act is not an obligation on an emitter.
  2. For a facility, test coverage: are its covered emissions (scope 1) above the number in the Rule, currently 100,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalence in a financial year, and who has operational control?
  3. Compare the net emissions number with the baseline for the monitoring period, after allowing for surrendered units and Australian carbon credit units issued in relation to the facility, and check whether an exemption declaration is in force.
  4. If an excess emissions situation exists on the 1 April after the financial year, identify the civil penalty duty on the responsible emitter and the specified amount measured by the difference between the two numbers, which caps the penalty a Court may order under s 31.
  5. If the question is whether the framework is working, identify the annual statement, the Authority’s advice and the Minister’s duty to consult and amend the rules, and check the current compilation of the Rule, because the figures are there and can change.

Self-check

  • Have I separated the targets in the Climate Change Act from the duty in s 22XF of the NGER Act?
  • Have I sourced the national targets and the aggregate safeguard outcomes to the Acts, and the facility threshold and baseline figures to the Rule with its compilation date?
  • Have I said that the EPBC link in s 15A of the Climate Change Act passes on an estimate and does not create a ground of refusal?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.