The safeguard mechanism and Australia’s legislated climate targets

The targets, and whom they bind

Section 10 sets Australia’s targets: net emissions 43% below 2005 levels by 2030, plus net zero by 2050. The 2030 target works both as a point target and as a ten-year emissions budget.

Reaching a target means getting emissions to or below that level. Section 10(1) does not stop further reductions beyond the target.

The targets must align with the Paris Agreement and Australia’s nationally determined contribution (its pledged emissions goal). Any new or adjusted contribution must show progression, not backsliding.

Parts 3 to 5 bind government, not emitters. The Minister must table an annual climate change statement, addressing whether emissions are tracking toward the safeguard outcomes.

The Climate Change Authority advises on that statement and on new targets. The Minister must consider this advice, and must explain in Parliament if key advice is rejected. The Minister must seek advice on a new contribution at least every five years.

The targets create accountability for government, not direct duties on emitters. Parts 2 to 5 impose no obligation on emitters. The Act also preserves State or Territory laws operating alongside s 10(1).

Which facilities are caught

The safeguard mechanism only applies to a designated large facility. This is a facility whose covered emissions exceed a set threshold in a financial year. The threshold is 100,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalence.

Covered emissions means scope 1 emissions, except for kinds the rules exclude. The responsible emitter is the person with operational control of the facility.

The Act also sets six safeguard outcomes. These include a total cap of 1,233 million tonnes of net emissions between 1 July 2020 and 30 June 2030. The cap must fall to no more than 100 million tonnes by the 2029-30 financial year, and reach zero for any financial year after 30 June 2049.

The limit, the duty and the penalty

Each monitoring period (a financial year, part of one, or a multi-year period the Regulator declares) ends with a comparison against the limit. The net emissions number is the facility’s covered emissions, reduced by surrendered carbon units (like ACCUs and safeguard mechanism credit units), but never below zero.

It can also increase where ACCUs are issued for abatement at that facility, if the conditions in s 22XK(4)-(5) are met. The safeguard rules can change how much a surrendered unit counts for.

The baseline emissions number is set under the safeguard rules. If net emissions exceed the baseline, an excess emissions situation exists, unless the Regulator has made an exemption declaration.

The responsible emitter must ensure no excess emissions situation exists by 1 April after that financial year. Breaching this duty is a civil penalty provision.

Under s 22XF, the penalty amount (in penalty units) equals the gap between net emissions and baseline. The Court then sets the actual pecuniary penalty under s 31, capped by that figure.

An exemption declaration can only be made on the emitter’s application. The Regulator must be satisfied the excess directly resulted from a natural disaster, criminal activity, or circumstances the rules treat as exceptional, and that reasonable steps were taken beforehand and afterward to mitigate the risk.

How the baseline declines

The Act does not set baselines itself. It leaves this to the Rule.

For most facilities, the baseline uses an emissions reduction contribution plus the facility’s production and emissions intensity numbers. Landfill facilities have their own separate formula.

The default contribution starts at 0.951 for the year beginning 1 July 2023. It falls by 0.049 each year, reaching 0.657 by 1 July 2029. After that it falls by 0.03285 a year, but never below zero.

A baseline under 100,000 is normally raised to 100,000. This does not apply if it is only low because of a borrowing adjustment. Shale gas extraction facilities always have a zero baseline. From the financial year after 30 June 2049, every baseline becomes zero.

Trade-exposed baseline-adjusted facilities work differently. Their contribution falls using a formula based on a ratio of cost impacts. The decline rate must stay between a set minimum and the default decline rate. The minimum is 0.01 for manufacturing facilities, 0.02 for others. Their baseline still depends on production and emissions intensity numbers.

[^cite:rule-safeguard-baselines]

A responsible emitter may apply for safeguard mechanism credit units. This applies where a facility’s baseline exceeds its covered emissions, counting any ACCUs that increased its net emissions number. The credit units are calculated from the baseline without the 100,000 minimum, minus those emissions and units. Conditions apply, including that the facility must not be a landfill facility.

A safeguard mechanism credit unit is a prescribed carbon unit. This means it can later be surrendered to reduce a net emissions number.

[^cite:nger-s22xs-safeguard-rules]

Who can change the numbers, and how the Acts feed each other

The Minister sets the safeguard rules. But this can only happen if the Minister is satisfied the rules match legislated outcomes: the total emissions cap from 2020 to 2030, the decline to 100 million tonnes by 2029, the decline to zero after 2049, and the rolling average. The Minister must also publish reasons.

If the Authority advises under s 14 that emissions are not declining as required, the Minister must consult publicly. If still satisfied the rules need changing, the Minister must amend them. This is how targets affect a facility indirectly, through Authority advice and Ministerial rule-making.

The Acts link to environmental approvals in one place. If the Environment Minister approves an action under the EPBC Act and is satisfied it will likely increase emissions from a large facility (or create one), any emissions estimate must go to the Minister, the Climate Change Secretary and the Authority.

This duty only requires passing on the information. It does not let emissions estimates be used to refuse EPBC approval.

State and Territory laws can still apply alongside federal law, where they operate concurrently. The exception is s 5 of the NGER Act, which excludes State and Territory laws on reporting emissions or energy data, where the regulations say so, and only as applied to a constitutional corporation.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out what the question asks. A national target under s 10 of the Climate Change Act is not the same as a facility’s obligation.

For a facility, check coverage. Are its scope 1 covered emissions above the Rule’s threshold, currently 100,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalence a year, and who holds operational control?

Then compare net emissions with the baseline for the monitoring period. Allow for surrendered units and Australian carbon credit units issued for the facility, and check if an exemption declaration applies.

If an excess emissions situation exists on 1 April after the financial year, identify the responsible emitter’s civil penalty duty. The specified amount, the gap between the two numbers, caps the penalty a Court may order under s 31.

If the question asks whether the framework works, point to the annual statement, the Authority’s advice, and the Minister’s duty to consult and amend the rules. Also check the current compilation of the Rule, since its figures can change.

Self-check

Before moving on, check a few things.

Keep the targets in the Climate Change Act separate from the duty in s 22XF of the NGER Act. These are two different rules, not one.

Check that national targets and aggregate safeguard outcomes come from the Acts. The facility threshold and baseline figures should come from the Rule, with its compilation date noted.

Confirm that the EPBC link in s 15A of the Climate Change Act only passes on an estimate. It is not a ground for refusing anything.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.