Company contracts: authority, execution and statutory assumptions

Separate a company’s legal capacity, an agent’s authority, statutory execution and the assumptions available to a person dealing with the company.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
corporations-and-commercial-law
Topics
corporate-personality, contract-formation

Learning outcomes

  • Separate corporate capacity from an individual’s authority.
  • Apply the statutory execution routes and their limits.
  • Test the available assumptions against knowledge or suspicion of irregularity.

A company’s contractual obligation presents several questions that should be kept separate. Does the company have capacity, did the person acting for it have authority, and was the document executed through an available route? Under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), a person dealing with a company may also receive statutory protection even when an internal step was defective. This article explains those statutory routes, rather than the full common-law doctrine of apparent authority.

Capacity does not identify the authorised decision-maker

Section 124 gives a company the legal capacity and powers of an individual, together with specified corporate powers. The fact that a transaction does not benefit the company’s interests does not affect its legal capacity under s 124(2). That proposition concerns capacity; it does not excuse a director’s breach of duty or establish that an employee had authority to make the transaction.1

Section 125 makes a related distinction. A constitution may restrict or prohibit the exercise of powers, or state company objects. A transaction is not invalid merely because it contravenes such a restriction or goes beyond the objects. The words “merely because” matter: the provision removes that particular invalidity argument, rather than guaranteeing validity against every possible objection.

For example, a constitution might require board approval for a large purchase. An answer that says “the company lacked capacity” because approval was omitted confuses internal governance with the company’s legal powers. The next questions concern authority, execution and the outsider’s statutory assumptions. Any internal breach of duty is an additional issue, not a substitute for those questions.

An authorised individual can act under section 126

Under s 126(1), an individual with express or implied company authority, acting on its behalf, may exercise its power to make, vary, ratify or discharge a contract, or execute a document including a deed. A common seal is unnecessary. The individual does not need appointment by deed merely to exercise this statutory power.

The current provision also allows execution as a deed where the document is expressed to be a deed, without witnessing and in physical or electronic form. Delivery is unnecessary under s 126(7). Section 126(3) preserves laws requiring particular procedures except to the extent inconsistent with the section. Do not turn a statutory relaxation of execution formalities into a claim that the transaction has no other legal requirements.

The premise remains authority. A person signing a company name does not obtain express or implied authority from the signature itself. If actual authority is disputed, identify its proposed source. A separate common-law authority argument requires the authorities that govern it; the statutory assumptions may offer another route where their conditions are satisfied.

Execution by the company under section 127

Section 127(1) allows execution without a seal by two directors, or a director and company secretary. For a proprietary company with a sole director, that director may sign if also the sole company secretary or if the company has no company secretary. “One director signed” is therefore insufficient information: company type, number of directors and secretary arrangements change the answer.

Section 127(2) supplies corresponding combinations for witnessing the fixing of a common seal. Under s 127(2A), observation may occur electronically or in person, with signature and an indication that the observer saw the fixing of the seal. The Act’s technology-neutral signing provisions also need attention where the problem turns on the method of electronic signature.

For a deed, s 127(3) requires the document to be expressed as a deed and executed under subsection (1) or (2). Execution under subsection (1) needs no witness under s 127(3A), and physical and electronic documents are permitted. Delivery is unnecessary under s 127(3B). Section 127(4) expressly leaves other methods of execution available, so failure to fit s 127 does not end the entire contractual inquiry.

Identify the particular assumption

Section 128 gives the entitlement to make the assumptions listed in s 129 in relation to dealings with a company. The company cannot assert in the relevant proceedings that a protected assumption is incorrect. Section 128(2) also addresses dealings with another person acquiring or purporting to acquire title to company property. Match the facts to the relevant dealing instead of treating the assumptions as general guarantees.

The assumptions have different subjects. Section 129(1) concerns compliance with the constitution and applicable replaceable rules. Subsections (2) and (3) concern due appointment and customary powers of persons identified in ASIC-public information or held out by the company. The reference to customary powers is a limit: being a director does not confer a statutory assumption of authority to make any conceivable bargain alone.

Section 129(4) concerns proper performance of duties. Subsections (5) and (6) concern apparent execution without or with a seal. For subsection (5), the document must appear signed in accordance with s 127(1); the provision permits assumptions about specified offices stated next to signatures. Section 129(7) addresses the authority of certain officers or agents to warrant a document’s genuineness or the accuracy of a certified copy. Name the assumption and show its factual basis.

Knowledge, suspicion and public information

Section 128(3) permits assumptions even where an officer or agent acts fraudulently or forges a document in connection with the dealings. Fraud therefore does not itself dispose of the outsider’s statutory argument. But subsection (4) prevents a person making a particular assumption if, at the time of dealing, that person knew or suspected it was incorrect.

The inquiry is assumption-specific. An outsider who actually suspects that the apparent second director’s signature is unauthorised cannot simply invoke the execution assumption as if subsection (4) did not exist. Equally, s 130 says information is not attributed merely because it is publicly available from ASIC. Actual knowledge or suspicion should not be replaced by a fictional rule that everybody has read the register.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the company, transaction and dealing for which enforceability is disputed.
  2. Address capacity under ss 124–125 separately from internal approval and officers’ duties.
  3. Test authority under s 126 or execution under s 127, preserving other available routes.
  4. Specify the s 129 assumption relied on and establish the facts that engage it.
  5. Apply the knowledge-or-suspicion qualification in s 128(4), without imputing ASIC-public information under s 130.

The statutory route can defeat an internal-irregularity objection without resolving every contract defence. Keep questions such as misrepresentation, illegality and the terms of the agreement distinct from the company-law execution analysis.