Minors’ contracts in New South Wales: presumptively binding, repudiation and court orders

How the Minors (Property and Contracts) Act 1970 (NSW) decides whether a minor’s contract binds: the s 17 starting rule, the routes to a presumptively binding civil act, affirmation, repudiation by 19 and the court’s adjustment powers.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
nsw
Subjects
contract
Topics
contract-formation

Learning outcomes

  • State the starting rule for a minor’s civil act under the Minors (Property and Contracts) Act 1970 (NSW) and what ‘presumptively binding’ means.
  • Identify the Part 3 routes by which a minor’s civil act becomes presumptively binding, including by court order, approval or certificate.
  • Apply the Act’s repudiation and affirmation provisions, with their time limits and conditions, and describe the court’s powers on adjustment.

Capacity gives the general picture and tells the student that several jurisdictions have legislation modifying the common law position, so the applicable Act must be checked. This article does that for one jurisdiction, and in New South Wales the starting point is the Act’s own rule in s 17 rather than a general option to avoid. It states the scheme of Part 3 of the Minors (Property and Contracts) Act 1970 (NSW), which governs a contract made by a minor in New South Wales, and it is a New South Wales article only. The other States and Territories have their own legislation; it is not stated here, and its section numbers and rules must not be assumed to match.

What this covers

The Act does not speak of contracts alone. It speaks of a civil act, defined to include “a contract”, an election to rescind or determine a contract, a disposition of property and many other acts (s 6(1)). A minor is “a person under the age of 18 years” (s 6(1))1, and a person aged 18 or upwards is not under the disability of infancy in relation to a civil act in which that person participates (s 8).

The order of the Act’s Part 3 gives three questions: is the civil act binding on the minor at all; if it is not, can the minor repudiate it, and by when and how; and what can a court order either way. It does not cover the minor’s liability in tort (s 48 deals with that), the common law rules on necessaries, or capacity arising from mental incapacity or corporate status, none of which is stated here.

The starting rule and what “presumptively binding” means

Section 17 states the starting rule: “Where a minor participates in a civil act, the civil act is not binding on the minor except as provided by this Act.”1 The Act then lists the situations in which a civil act is presumptively binding on the minor. The expression is defined by its effect in s 6(3): where a civil act is or becomes presumptively binding on a person who participated as a minor, it is binding on that person and their personal representative as if the person were not under the disability of infancy at the time, and, except where the Act makes other provision, it is binding in favour of all persons.

So a presumptively binding civil act is binding in the ordinary way, subject to the Act’s other provisions, and one that is not presumptively binding is not binding on the minor unless some other provision of the Act makes it so.

When a civil act is presumptively binding

Part 3 gives a number of separate routes. The grouping of them below is a study aid and not a classification the Act itself uses.

The general route: a civil act for the minor’s benefit.2 Under s 19, where a minor participates in a civil act and their participation “is for his or her benefit at the time of his or her participation”, the civil act is presumptively binding. The time at which benefit is measured is the time of participation, not the time of a later dispute.

The limit on understanding.2 Under s 18, Part 3 does not make a civil act presumptively binding where the minor participates, or appears to participate, “while lacking, by reason of youth, the understanding necessary for his or her participation in the civil act”.

Dispositions of property.2 Section 20(1) applies where a minor makes a disposition of property for consideration, the consideration is not manifestly inadequate at the time, and the minor receives the whole or any part of it; the disposition is then presumptively binding. Section 20(2) applies where a disposition is made to a minor for consideration the minor gives or is to give, and the consideration is not manifestly excessive; the disposition is then presumptively binding. Section 20(3) withholds the effect of s 20(2) from a promise by the minor which is the consideration for a disposition to the minor, save to the extent that, under Part 3 of the Sale of Goods Act 1923 (NSW) or otherwise, a promise may operate as a disposition of property, and s 20(4) provides that s 20(2) does not make presumptively binding a disposition of property whose burden, under a covenant or other promise, runs with the property so as to impose an obligation or restriction on the person to whom it is made, in the manner and circumstances it describes. Whether a given contract involves a disposition of property is a separate question that the Act’s definition of “disposition of property” in s 6(1) must answer; this article does not work that definition through.

Other routes.2 The Act also makes presumptively binding a disposition by way of gift that is reasonable when made (s 21), a civil act done pursuant to a contractual or other duty binding on the minor (s 22), certain investments in government securities (s 23) and a receipt by a married minor for rents, profits or other income (s 25).

Protection of strangers.2 Under s 24, a person who is not a party to the civil act and who, without notice that the minor was a minor, acquires property affected by it for valuable consideration, or acts otherwise than as a volunteer and so as to alter their position on the basis of its validity, may rely on the civil act as presumptively binding on the minor, in favour of that person and those claiming under that person. Both conditions in s 24 must be read together: the person must have acquired property affected by the civil act for valuable consideration, or have acted otherwise than as a volunteer and so as to alter their position on the basis of the civil act’s validity, and in either case without notice of the minor’s age.

Binding by order of a court or by certificate

A minor, or someone dealing with one, need not wait to see whether the general routes apply. The Act provides three ways of making a civil act presumptively binding in advance.

  • Supreme Court capacity order.3 On application by a minor, the Supreme Court may grant the minor capacity to participate in civil acts, whether in a description or in all civil acts, on such terms as it thinks fit, and it must not do so unless the order appears to be for the minor’s benefit (s 26(1)–(3)). A civil act authorised by a grant of capacity is presumptively binding (s 26(4)).
  • Local Court approval.3 The Local Court may, on application by a minor, approve a contract proposed to be made by the minor, or a disposition of property proposed to be made by or to the minor; a contract or disposition made under an approval is presumptively binding (s 27(1)–(2)). The Court must not make an order unless it appears that the minor would not undertake obligations under the proposed contract, or dispose of property under the proposed disposition, to the value of $10,000 or upwards and that the order is for the minor’s benefit (s 27(5)). A refusal does not prevent a further application to the Supreme Court under s 26 (s 27(6)).
  • Certified dispositions.3 A disposition of property by a minor for consideration is presumptively binding if a certificate meeting s 28 is given before, but not more than seven days before, the disposition, by a solicitor instructed and employed independently of any other party or by the NSW Trustee and Guardian. Section 28(2) lists what the certificate must state, including that the person giving it is satisfied that the minor understands the true purport and effect in law of the disposition and makes it freely and voluntarily. Section 29 makes a parallel provision for dispositions to a minor, and s 29(3) and (4) limit the effect of s 29 in the same way that s 20(3) and (4) limit s 20(2).

When a civil act is not presumptively binding

The Act provides for affirmation and repudiation, and each has time limits and conditions.

Repudiation by the minor.4 Under s 31(1), and subject to ss 33 and 35 and s 31(2), the minor may repudiate a civil act “at any time during his or her minority or afterwards but before the minor attains the age of nineteen years”. The first limit is in s 31(2): a repudiation does not have effect if it appears that, at the time of the repudiation, the civil act is for the benefit of the minor participant. The second is s 35(1): where the civil act is presumptively binding on the minor in favour of another party, or of any other person, a repudiation under s 31 does not have effect as against that party or person. The third is procedural. A repudiation under s 31 affects a person only if a written notice, signed by the person repudiating or by their agent, is served on that person or on someone under whom that person claims, and it takes effect against the person served as if made on the date of service (s 33). Notice may be served as provided in s 170 of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) (s 33(3)).

Affirmation.4 A civil act made by a minor may be affirmed by the person after reaching 18, by a court on the minor’s behalf while they remain a minor, or after the person’s death by their personal representative (s 30(1)). Court affirmation during minority is by order on application by the minor participant or any other person interested in the civil act, and, subject to s 36, the court must not affirm unless affirmation appears to be for the minor participant’s benefit (s 30(1)(a), (2), (3)). An affirmation by the person or their personal representative may be by words, written or spoken, or by conduct, and need not be communicated to anyone (s 30(5)). An affirmed civil act is presumptively binding (s 30(4)).

Failure to repudiate.4 If a civil act is not repudiated under ss 31, 32 or 34 within the times those sections fix, it is presumptively binding on the minor participant (s 38).

Repudiation by a court.5 A court with jurisdiction under s 34 may repudiate a civil act on the minor’s behalf during minority, but not if it appears to the court that the civil act is for the minor’s benefit (s 34, subject to s 35). On application by a person interested in a civil act, where it appears to the court that the act is not presumptively binding on the minor in favour of the applicant, the court “shall either affirm the civil act under section 30 or repudiate the civil act under section 34 on behalf of the minor participant” (s 36).

What follows a repudiation

A repudiation does not leave the parties where they happen to be. Under s 37, a court may on application make orders confirming the civil act or anything done under it, wholly or in part, or adjusting the rights arising from it or from the repudiation (s 37(1))5. Except so far as the court confirms the civil act or anything done under it, it is to make the orders it thinks fit for the purpose of securing, so far as practicable, that each minor participant makes just compensation for property, services and other things derived under the civil act “to the extent that the derivation of that property or of those services or things is for his or her benefit”, that each other participant makes just compensation for what that participant derived, and that, subject to those, the parties are restored to their positions before the civil act (s 37(4)). The court may not make an order adversely affecting the rights of a person in whose favour the civil act is presumptively binding without that person’s consent (s 37(3)).

Where a party was induced to participate by a fraudulent misrepresentation by the minor as to the minor’s age or another matter affecting the minor’s capacity, the court may confirm the civil act and what was done under it (s 37(2)).

On enforcement by a minor, s 39 provides that, subject to s 37, a court is not to give judgment or make an order in favour of a minor participant, or the participant’s personal representative, for enforcement of the civil act unless it is presumptively binding on the minor in favour of the person against whom the order is sought.5

Two points outside the contract itself

A guarantor of a minor’s obligation is bound to the extent the guarantor would be bound if the minor were not a minor (s 47(1))6. A person under 21 is answerable for a tort whether or not it is connected with a contract or is in substance a cause of action in contract (s 48).

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Fix the jurisdiction and the date. This article states New South Wales law as set out in the version of the Act published as current on the NSW legislation website in October 2026. If the contract is governed by another State’s or Territory’s law, this article does not state the answer.
  2. Confirm that the party was a minor, a person under 18, when they participated in the civil act (ss 6(1), 8). A person aged 18 or upwards is not under the disability of infancy in relation to a civil act in which they participate (s 8).
  3. Ask first whether any route in Part 3 makes the civil act presumptively binding: benefit at the time of participation (s 19), a disposition for consideration (s 20), gift, duty, or one of the other routes in ss 21–25, or a prior court order, approval or certificate (ss 26–29). Remember the limit on understanding in s 18, and that s 19 measures benefit “at the time of his or her participation”.
  4. If it is presumptively binding, remember that s 6(3) makes it binding “except where other provision is made by this Act”, and that s 35(1) removes a repudiation’s effect as against a party in whose favour the act is presumptively binding.
  5. If it is not presumptively binding, ask whether the minor has repudiated, whether the repudiation was in time (before the minor turned 19, s 31(1)), whether, for a repudiation by the minor under s 31, it was in signed writing and served (s 33), and whether the civil act was for the minor’s benefit when repudiated (s 31(2)). Then ask whether the person has affirmed after turning 18, which s 30(5) allows by words or by conduct without communication.
  6. Address the consequences of repudiation under s 37: just compensation, restoration and the possibility of confirmation by the court. Orders under s 37 are made by a court on application, and the section contemplates compensation by both sides; do not describe the result of repudiation without addressing it.
  7. If the other party is the one resisting, remember s 39 on enforcement by the minor, and s 47 on a guarantor.

Self-check

  • Have I said that this is a New South Wales analysis and not assumed that other jurisdictions’ legislation matches it?
  • Have I started from s 17 (not binding except as the Act provides) and then identified the route that makes the civil act presumptively binding, rather than listing the common law exceptions?
  • Have I separated repudiation by the minor (s 31, with notice under s 33) from repudiation by a court (s 34) and from affirmation (s 30)?
  • Have I recorded the limits on repudiation: it does not take effect if the act is for the minor’s benefit at the time of repudiation (s 31(2)), nor against a person in whose favour it is presumptively binding (s 35(1))?
  • Have I dealt with what follows repudiation under s 37, including the qualification that the minor’s compensation is limited to what was derived for the minor’s benefit?
  • Have I avoided saying anything about the common law necessaries rule, mental incapacity or corporations as though this article covered it?

Where the authority sits

The authority is the Minors (Property and Contracts) Act 1970 (NSW), Parts 1, 3 and 5, in the version published as current on the NSW legislation website in October 2026. No case is cited here, so the article does not state how courts have applied the benefit test, the understanding limit or the adjustment power in s 37.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.