Wilson v Ferguson

Supreme Court of Western Australia · 2015

Intellectual Property And Technology LawEquity And TrustsConfidential InformationEquitable Remedies

Wilson v Ferguson [2015] WASC 15

A man angry at a break-up posts intimate images of his former partner to his Facebook friends, many of them her workmates. What can equity do for her once the images are already out?

What happened?

Ms Wilson and Mr Ferguson worked together at a WA mine and began a relationship in late 2012. They exchanged sexually explicit photos and videos, taken with her knowledge and consent. He once emailed her videos from her phone without telling her; she was upset but he promised no one would see them.

After she ended the relationship in August 2013, he posted the images on Facebook, visible to around 300 friends, many from the mine. She begged him to remove them; he did, hours later. She suffered distress, needed counselling, and lost wages.

She sued for an injunction, equitable compensation, and costs, dropping other claims. Ferguson did not defend or appear at trial, which proceeded without him.

What did the Court decide?

Mitchell J, of the Supreme Court of Western Australia, heard the matter on 2 December 2014. He found for the plaintiff on her equitable claim, granting a permanent injunction, $48,404 compensation, and costs (not indemnity costs).

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

Mitchell J, deciding the case alone, set out the elements of an equitable action for breach of confidence. The plaintiff must show the information was confidential, it was given or obtained in circumstances creating an obligation of confidence, and there was unauthorised use of it ([46]).

He explained this obligation as one of conscience, arising from how the information was communicated or obtained ([45]). The doctrine can cover images of a person, even images that person created, if shared in confidence ([47]).

He held the intimate images had “the necessary quality of confidence”. Intimate photos and videos shared between lovers are ordinarily confidential, given on the implicit condition they stay private ([56]).

The defendant’s conduct created an obligation of confidence. Emailing the videos to himself from her phone, without her knowledge or consent, was itself ordinarily enough to do this. The nature of the images also made it obvious they were for his viewing only ([57]-[58]). Posting them to Facebook, visible to hundreds of friends, was a misuse of them ([59]).

On detriment, Mitchell J noted Mason J in an earlier case had required proof that unauthorised use caused detriment to the party who shared the information. He observed this requirement “has been doubted in subsequent cases”, citing Ammon v Consolidated Minerals Ltd [No 3] ([43], footnote 4). He did not resolve that doubt, and detriment is not listed among the elements at [46].

Even so, at [59] he found that, to the extent detriment was required, the plaintiff had proved it. The disclosure caused her deep distress, time off work, and the need for counselling.

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Proposition 1

Ratio · Mitchell J

Read judgment: [45]–[47] (opens in a new tab), [55]–[58] (opens in a new tab)

Mitchell J’s statement of the elements, his finding that the images were confidential and his finding that the circumstances in which the defendant obtained them imposed an obligation of conscience were necessary to the conclusion at [55] that posting the images breached an equitable obligation of confidence, on which the injunction and the compensation rest ([2], [60]-[66], [85]).

Classification unresolved · Mitchell J

Read judgment: [43] (opens in a new tab), [59] (opens in a new tab)

At [43] Mitchell J reported that the requirement to show detriment had been doubted; at [59] he said that, to the extent it was necessary, the plaintiff had shown detriment. He did not decide whether detriment is a separate requirement. A single label would hide that the doubt is recorded, the question is left open, and the result would be the same either way.

Proposition 2

Ratio · Mitchell J

Read judgment: [71]–[83] (opens in a new tab), [85] (opens in a new tab)

Mitchell J’s conclusion that equitable compensation can be awarded for embarrassment and distress from a breach of confidence, and his reasons for following Giller, were necessary to the award of $35,000 for non-economic loss at [85].

Classification unresolved · Mitchell J

Read judgment: [84] (opens in a new tab), [86] (opens in a new tab)

Mitchell J said he was not expressing a view on non-economic equitable compensation for other equitable obligations ([84]) or on damages under s 25(10) of the Supreme Court Act 1935 (WA) ([86]). These are questions he reserved, not observations on the ground of decision.

Why does this case matter?

Cases about private images sit where several kinds of claim meet, and a weak answer picks a label for the wrong claim and then argues the remedy from the label. This decision shows a court working through one equitable claim from its elements to its remedies, step by step, which is the discipline an examiner looks for.

Check your understanding

How did the defendant get the videos, and what did the plaintiff say ([23])?

What did he post on 5 August 2013, and who could see it ([27]-[28])?

What two hurdles did Mitchell J identify to her money claim ([72])?

What did he not decide ([84], [86])?

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail. The full case note is the complete statement.