Theunissen v Barter

Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales · 2025

PropertyEasements

Theunissen v Barter [2025] NSWCA 50

A registered easement gives the owners of a house use of the rooftop terrace in front of it for recreation and as a balcony or garden, but does not say that the use is theirs alone. May the owner of the roof also use it?

What happened?

The Theunissens and Ms Barter owned neighbouring blocks in Mosman, NSW. Lot 1, behind Lot 2, sits higher up. An easement, registered in 1996, lets the Theunissens use Ms Barter’s rooftop terrace for recreation and access.

The rooftop has no outside stairs. Ms Barter reaches it only by ladder through a skylight from inside her home. The trial judge found the skylight wasn’t originally meant for walking on.

The easement doesn’t say the Theunissens’ rights are exclusive. Richmond J held they weren’t exclusive. The Theunissens appealed. Ms Barter argued the appeal was incompetent; the Theunissens also sought leave to appeal, just in case.

What did the Court decide?

The NSW Court of Appeal (Mitchelmore JA, Kirk JA, Griffiths AJA) decided this on 31 March 2025. It held leave wasn’t needed, dismissed Ms Barter’s competency motion and leave summons, with costs against her. The appeal succeeded; earlier orders were set aside and replaced. Ground 2 wasn’t addressed.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

Kirk JA explained how to interpret an easement (a right over someone else’s land) set out in a written document. The task is to work out what the parties intended. This is judged from the text, context and purpose of the document, seen through the eyes of a reasonable person in the parties’ position. Admissible evidence can also be considered.

He discussed the High Court’s decision in Westfield. That case said ordinary contract-interpretation evidence rules did not apply to the easement in question. Kirk JA read this as limiting only evidence rules, not the basic approach to construing legal documents.

The Easement here did not expressly say the rights were exclusive. So the real question was whether, read in context, exclusivity should still be understood despite no express words.

Kirk JA then worked through the text piece by piece. The phrases “full and free right” and “use and enjoyment” were neutral, pointing neither way. The words “balcony” and “terrace” suggested exclusivity. Several provisos, including rights to lay, inspect, clean and maintain the surface, and clauses about entering and repairing the roof, also pointed towards exclusivity, though with varying weight. Some other points relied on by the primary judge did not help either side.

He also read the Easement alongside the deposited plan. This showed the servient owner (the one whose land carries the burden) had no easy way to access the rooftop. Kirk JA said this strongly supported the appellants’ position.

He concluded that the only point favouring the respondent was that exclusivity could easily have been stated expressly, but wasn’t. Weighing everything together, he found a reasonable person would conclude the Easement gave the dominant owner (the one benefiting from the right) exclusive use and enjoyment of the servient land. This included use as a balcony, terrace or garden.

Kirk JA said this conclusion, based on text and context alone, was enough to uphold Ground 1 of the appeal.

He then went on to consider the physical characteristics of the site as well, but only as a precaution. He said he did this in case his earlier reasoning on the textual and contextual factors was wrong.

On this further point, he said Westfield did not directly address the issue of physical characteristics. He said the High Court was not trying to give an exhaustive list of material that could be considered. The passage ends before explaining fully what the decision does or does not establish on this point.

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Proposition 1

Ratio · Kirk JA (Mitchelmore JA and Griffiths AJA agreeing)

Read judgment: [27] (opens in a new tab), [32]–[51] (opens in a new tab)

This is the reasoning by which Kirk JA held that the rights of recreation and enjoyment were exclusive. He said that the conclusion at [51] suffices to uphold Ground 1, subject to the validity issue, and the appeal was allowed on it ([51], [117], [150], [160]).

Proposition 2

Classification unresolved · Kirk JA (Mitchelmore JA and Griffiths AJA agreeing)

Read judgment: [54] (opens in a new tab), [63] (opens in a new tab), [72] (opens in a new tab), [90]–[108] (opens in a new tab), [112]–[117] (opens in a new tab)

Kirk JA states the position on physical characteristics as what it is sufficient to say for the purposes of resolving the matter ([108]) and applies it to reject the detail of the skylight and accept the layout and privacy point ([112]-[116]). But he had already concluded on text and context that the rights were exclusive ([51]) and took up the physical characteristics only in case that reasoning was in error ([54]), describing the privacy point as reinforcement ([116]-[117]); and he expressly left open exceptional cases of features not visible from the boundary ([105], [108]). A binary label would conceal that the Court of Appeal’s statement of principle was developed with a full survey of authority and stated in terms, yet was not strictly necessary to the result.

Proposition 3

Ratio · Kirk JA (Mitchelmore JA and Griffiths AJA agreeing)

Read judgment: [118]–[150] (opens in a new tab)

The respondent’s validity argument was a further ground on which the primary judge’s conclusion could be supported ([16]), and Kirk JA’s rejection of it ([149]-[150]) was necessary to his upholding ground 1 on the construction he had reached ([117], [150]).

Why does this case matter?

Disputes about the scope of a registered easement are often argued from the words of the instrument alone, or by gathering whatever facts either owner can produce. This decision is a useful vehicle for asking, of each fact a party offers, what it is offered to show.

Exam and application relevance

For an easement problem, start with the grant’s wording and plan, weighing each term. Ask what each extra fact proves, citing paragraphs. If invalidity is argued, note what the servient owner retains. Cite Kirk JA by paragraph. This is NSW Court of Appeal; binding there, persuasive elsewhere; check later cases.

Check your understanding

Which lot was dominant, which servient, and what area did the Easement cover ([17]-[19], [22])?

How could Ms Barter reach the rooftop? What did the primary judge find about the skylight ([23]-[24])?

Which orders were set aside, and what happened to ground 2 ([5], [160])?

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail. The full case note is the complete statement.