Shanahan v Scott

High Court of Australia · 1957

Legal Research And MethodResearchDelegated LegislationReading Legislation And Delegated Legislation

Shanahan v Scott [1957] HCA 4; (1957) 96 CLR 245

A Victorian regulation forbade anyone to put eggs into cold storage without the Egg Board’s consent. The Act let the Board market eggs vested in it. Could a general power to make regulations reach eggs the Board never owned?

What happened?

Victorian legislation let producers seek a marketing board for a rural product, with the product able to be vested in the board. The Egg and Egg Pulp Marketing Board’s reg 44 made it an offence to cold store or preserve eggs without the Board’s consent, except up to thirty dozen for domestic use.

Henry Shanahan, a manager of a New South Wales firm, was charged. The magistrate dismissed the information on s 92 grounds. Lowe J held reg 44 valid.

On appeal, s 92 was abandoned. Was reg 44 within power?

What did the Court decide?

The High Court (Dixon CJ, Williams, Webb, Fullagar and Kitto JJ) allowed the appeal with costs by a majority, discharged the Supreme Court’s order and ordered that the order nisi to review be discharged with costs. Dixon CJ, Williams, Webb and Fullagar JJ, in joint reasons (pp 248 to 255), held that reg 44 was invalid. Kitto J dissented (pp 255 to 260).

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

The joint judges looked at s 43(1) of the Victorian Marketing of Primary Products Acts 1935-1953. It let the Governor in Council make regulations for purposes “necessary or expedient” for the Act.

They said this kind of power is strictly ancillary. It cannot extend the Act’s scope. It only allows subsidiary means of carrying out what the statute already enacts. It cannot widen the Act’s purposes or vary the legislature’s plan.

The Acts set up a scheme for collective marketing. Producers could set up a marketing board for a commodity, and vest that commodity in the board.

The judges rejected the argument that a specific power to make regulations “regulating” storage supported regulation 44. A complete prohibition subject to consent is not “regulating” storage. The specific power concerned the manner and occasion of storage, not whether storage could happen at all.

So validity depended on the general words in s 43(1). The judges said this test is imprecise, but not unlimited. Earlier decisions gave some guidance.

A regulation confined to eggs vested in the board would merely fill in a detail of the plan. But regulation 44 went further. It covered eggs the board never had, eggs already sold unconditionally, and eggs from another State.

That meant regulation 44 supplemented the legislative plan, rather than complementing it, echoing language used in Carbines v Powell.

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Ratio · Dixon CJ, Williams, Webb and Fullagar JJ (joint reasons)

Read judgment: p 250 (PDF p 6) (opens in a new tab), pp 253–255 (PDF p 9) (opens in a new tab)

The statement of what a power to make regulations necessary or expedient for the administration or objects of the Act authorises (p 250), and its application to reg 44 (pp 253 to 255), are the reasoning that decided the appeal: the Court held the regulation ultra vires because it extended the plan of the Acts, and that is the ground of the order allowing the appeal.

Separate reasoning · Kitto J (dissenting)

Read judgment: pp 255–260 (PDF p 11) (opens in a new tab)

Kitto J applied the same power on a different reading of what is necessary or expedient for a particular commodity and would have dismissed the appeal. He dissents from the result and from the joint reasons’ view that reg 44 extended the legislative plan, so his reasoning is not part of the Court’s holding.

Why does this case matter?

Matching facts to a regulation is only partial work. Examiners want students who trace its power and explain what it adds to the Act.

Exam and application relevance

Cite the joint reasons; attribute Kitto J’s view to him, as a dissent.

They read the particular Victorian Acts, so another Act turns on its own terms.

Decided 1957. Check the current enabling provision, the current regulation, and later authority before relying on it.

Check your understanding

Who wrote the joint reasons? Who dissented? What order followed?

Which eggs did reg 44 reach beyond those vested in the board?

How did Kitto J differ?

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail. The full case note is the complete statement.