McRae v Commonwealth Disposals Commission

High Court of Australia · 1951

ContractVitiating Factors

McRae v Commonwealth Disposals Commission [1951] HCA 79; (1951) 84 CLR 377

A government agency sold a wrecked oil tanker that was not there, and the buyers sent a salvage expedition to find it. Was there ever a contract to break?

What happened?

The Commission advertised a tanker wreck for tender; the plaintiffs’ bid of £285 was accepted. No such reef existed, and the coordinates given showed no tanker, only a distant wrecked barge. The Commission’s information was unreliable gossip and a stranger’s offer. The plaintiffs fitted out a ship, searched, found nothing, and lost their vessel. They sued for breach of contract, deceit and negligence. Webb J found the contract void, awarding damages only for deceit. Both sides appealed.

What did the Court decide?

Full Court allowed the plaintiffs’ appeal, dismissed the cross-appeal. Judgment: £3,285 damages for breach of contract, plus costs. Deceit and negligence claims left undecided; McTiernan J concurred.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

Dixon and Fullagar JJ, with McTiernan J concurring, held the contract was not void. They said Couturier v Hastie never decided that issue.

The real question was what the Commission actually promised. Since buyers relied on the Commission’s assertion, this wasn’t mutual mistake. The contract promised a tanker existed, so the Commission breached it.

On mistake, they added: a party can’t rely on mutual mistake if they held it without reasonable grounds, or deliberately induced it in the other party.

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Ratio · Dixon and Fullagar JJ

Read judgment: p 408 (PDF p 9) (opens in a new tab), p 410 (PDF p 11) (opens in a new tab)

The construction of this contract supplied the ground for contractual liability: the Commission promised that a tanker existed at the specified place, and the buyers relied on that assurance. The words and circumstances excluded an implied condition precedent that the tanker existed. Its absence therefore constituted breach rather than preventing a contract from arising. The discussion of Couturier v Hastie explains why that authority did not compel the opposite result. McTiernan J concurred in the conclusions; his concurrence does not expressly adopt every step of the joint reasons.

Ratio · Dixon and Fullagar JJ

Read judgment: pp 409–410 (PDF p 10) (opens in a new tab)

This is an alternative ground for rejecting the Commission’s defence, expressly applied to the facts and repeated in the summary of liability. Even if the matter were analysed as mistake, the Commission could not avoid the contract on a belief it held without reasonable grounds and deliberately induced in the buyers. Its officers’ reckless assertions satisfied that narrower rule. The conditional form of this alternative ground does not make it merely obiter. Denning LJ’s broader statement in Solle v Butcher is quoted with an express reservation, so the joint reasons do not establish that wider statement as their rule.

Why does this case matter?

This case shows why “shared mistake” isn’t the automatic answer when goods don’t exist. At trial, that answer limited recovery under a different cause of action. On appeal, the buyers won reliance damages instead, despite having no tanker to value, though not every expense was recoverable.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail. The full case note is the complete statement.