Masters v Cameron

High Court of Australia · 1954

ContractContract Formation

Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353

A farm owner and a buyer signed a memorandum fixing the land, the price and the date for possession, and a deposit was paid. It was also expressed to be subject to a formal contract. Was anyone bound before that contract was signed?

What happened?

Mrs Cameron agreed to sell her Western Australian farm to Mr Masters for £17,500, signing a memorandum on 6 December 1951. It included fencing terms, a possession date, and a final sentence making the agreement “subject to” a formal contract acceptable to her solicitors. A £1,750 deposit was paid to the selling agent, Dalgety & Co Ltd. After signing, Masters took steps consistent with ownership, and Mrs Cameron sold her sheep and bought a house in Perth. The purchasers then had financial trouble and denied being bound. Dalgety brought proceedings, and Wolff J held a binding contract existed, awarding Mrs Cameron the deposit. The purchasers appealed to the High Court.

What did the Court decide?

The High Court allowed the appeal, with costs, and discharged the Supreme Court’s judgment. It answered four framed questions, including whether a binding contract existed and who was entitled to the £1,750.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

When parties agree on terms but plan a formal contract later, the Court said there are three possible situations.

First, parties may finish all terms and intend to be bound immediately. They just want the terms restated more fully later, with no change in effect.

Second, parties may fully agree on all terms, intending no changes. But they make performance of some terms conditional on signing a formal document.

Third, parties may not intend any binding deal until they actually execute a formal contract.

The first two situations create a binding contract. The third does not, because the terms were never meant to bind on their own.

Whether a contract exists depends on the parties’ intention, shown through their words. No special wording is required.

Phrases like “subject to contract” are read naturally. Such words usually show the parties intended a future contract, not an immediate one. But the Court said no phrase, including “subject to contract”, always produces that result.

Here, the document had all essential contract terms. The final sentence required the formal contract to satisfy the vendor’s solicitors. This meant no binding contract had yet been made.

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Proposition 1

Ratio · Dixon CJ, McTiernan and Kitto JJ (joint judgment of the Court)

Read judgment: pp 360–362 (opens in a new tab)

These pages state the framework within which the Court decided whether the memorandum bound the parties: the three kinds of case, the consequence of each, and the principle that the answer depends on the intention disclosed by the parties’ language. The Court applied that framework to the memorandum at 364 and the decision that there was no binding contract depends on it.

Proposition 2

Ratio · Dixon CJ, McTiernan and Kitto JJ (joint judgment of the Court)

Read judgment: pp 362–364 (opens in a new tab)

These pages state the prima facie effect of a ‘subject to a formal contract’ qualification, qualify it by recognising that no formula is intractable, and apply it to the memorandum in the case. They are the ground on which the Court answered the first question (whether a binding contract was made) against the respondent.

Proposition 3

Ratio · Dixon CJ, McTiernan and Kitto JJ (joint judgment of the Court)

Read judgment: pp 364–367 (opens in a new tab)

These pages contain the answers to the second, third and fourth questions put to the Court: the destination of the deposit, the estoppel claim and the consequent orders. They follow from the answer to the first question and are necessary to the orders made.

Why does this case matter?

A problem that says a formal document is to follow invites an answer from a rule of thumb, and the usual errors run in both directions. An examiner rewards an answer built on what the parties said and did about the later document, and one that notices that money paid and conduct after signing raise questions of their own.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail. The full case note is the complete statement.