Mann v Paterson Constructions Pty Ltd

High Court of Australia · 2019

RemediesRemedies Framework

Mann v Paterson Constructions Pty Ltd [2019] HCA 32; (2019) 267 CLR 560

A builder whose contract was wrongly terminated claimed the value of the work instead of the contract price. Can a restitutionary claim outrun the bargain?

What happened?

Paterson Constructions built two townhouses for the Manns under a domestic building contract that provided for progress payments by stage. The owners requested variations, which the builder carried out without the written documentation the Domestic Building Contracts Act 1995 (Vic) required. The relationship broke down, the owners repudiated, and the builder accepted the repudiation and claimed on a quantum meruit for the value of all the work.

What did the Court decide?

The High Court allowed the appeal and sent the matter back for reassessment. Which stages had in fact been completed remained uncertain: “it is not entirely clear which stages had been completed” ([178]). The progress payments covered the two-townhouse development, complicating the significance of a final payment made for one townhouse. For the variations, the statute provided the exclusive route.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

A restitutionary claim following termination is not a route around the parties’ contractual allocation of value; the contract remains central to whether relief is available and to how it is measured.

The dividing line is whether a contractual right to payment had accrued. For completed stages, the builder was confined to contractual recovery or damages; for incomplete stages a majority allowed restitution as an alternative to damages. Restitution here was constrained by the contract price. Gageler J stated the ceiling without qualification, while Nettle, Gordon and Edelman JJ reserved the possibility of departure where confinement to the contractual measure would be unconscionable. No circumstances warranting departure were suggested in this case.

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Ratio · Nettle, Gordon and Edelman JJ

Read judgment: [177] (PDF p 74) (opens in a new tab), [215] (PDF p 96) (opens in a new tab), [217] (PDF p 97) (opens in a new tab)

These passages determine the builder’s available remedies and the basis for reassessment on remitter: completed stages carry contractual payment rights; incomplete stages permit restitution or damages; restitution here must respect the contract rates. Those conclusions were necessary to deciding the appeal. Gageler J also allowed restitution for work without accrued payment rights subject to a contract-price ceiling, giving that outcome a majority, although the reasons differed.

Separate reasoning · Gageler J

Read judgment: [102] (PDF p 43) (opens in a new tab)

Concurring in the result, Gageler J retained restitution for work without accrued payment rights but imposed an unqualified ceiling equal to the portion of the contract price attributable to the services. This distinct route supports the limit applied here without adopting the joint reasons’ reservation of a possible exception.

Separate reasoning · Kiefel CJ, Bell and Keane JJ

Read judgment: [19]–[20] (PDF p 15) (opens in a new tab)

Their Honours concurred in allowing the appeal but dissented on the availability of restitution for incomplete stages. They treated both accrued payment rights and the right to damages for loss of bargain as excluding the proposed restitutionary alternative. Their broader contractual approach was not adopted by the four judges who allowed restitution for work without accrued payment rights.

Obiter · Nettle, Gordon and Edelman JJ

Read judgment: [216] (PDF p 97) (opens in a new tab), [217] (PDF p 97) (opens in a new tab)

The possibility that unconscionability might justify recovery beyond the contractual measure was unnecessary to the result: no circumstances warranting departure were suggested in this case. This reservation qualifies their formulation but does not decide when an exception would succeed or establish a majority-approved exception.

Why does this case matter?

The choice of remedy had substantial financial consequences for the owners and the builder. The dispute also shows why payment records need to be read alongside the building contract: a payment labelled final for one townhouse did not settle how far the development as a whole had progressed through its stages.

Read the judgments for how divided the reasoning is. The outcome commanded a majority; the route to it did not, and later argument in this area is still largely about which reasoning to follow.

Exam and application relevance

Prepare a chronology of the work, payment claims and termination. Identify what the stage descriptions cover: one building or the development as a whole. Keep the variations separate and examine the statutory requirements. When discussing the judgments, distinguish agreement in the result from agreement in reasoning.

Check your understanding

How does the contract affect the availability and measurement of the builder’s restitutionary claim after termination?