Futter v Revenue and Customs; Pitt v Holt
Futter v Revenue and Customs; Pitt v Holt [2013] UKSC 26; [2013] 2 AC 108 (UKSC)
Trustees acted on professional tax advice, and a large tax bill followed that nobody had expected. When can a court undo a trustee’s decision on the ground that the trustees did not think properly about its consequences?
What happened?
Two appeals were heard together, both about trustees who made decisions that had unexpected tax consequences.
In Futter, Mr Futter settled two trusts in 1985. In 2004 he and Mr Cutbill became UK-resident trustees; Mr Cutbill’s firm gave tax advice. In 2008 the trustees made distributions clearly within their powers, correctly understanding stockpiled gains would be attributed to beneficiaries, but wrongly believing losses would offset them. This overlooked an amendment to the legislation, causing a large tax bill. Norris J held the deeds void, not voidable.
In Pitt, Mr Pitt was severely injured in 1990. His wife, as receiver, settled his damages on a discretionary trust in 1994 on financial advisers’ recommendation. The advice omitted inheritance tax, creating an avoidable liability. After his death, his representatives sought to set the trust aside. The deputy judge did so.
The Court of Appeal allowed both appeals.
What did the Court decide?
The Supreme Court (Lord Walker, all agreeing) dismissed the Hastings-Bass appeals in both cases. In Pitt, it set aside the settlement on the separate mistake ground.
Proposition
What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis
Principle analysis
Lord Walker said the name “the rule in Hastings-Bass” is misleading. Most now accept this.
He adopted a distinction drawn by the Court of Appeal. “Excessive execution” is where trustees go beyond their power entirely. “Inadequate deliberation” is where trustees act within their power, but fail to properly consider relevant matters.
For inadequate deliberation, Lord Walker held the error must be serious enough to amount to a breach of fiduciary duty (a duty of loyalty owed by trustees to beneficiaries). Falling short of the highest standards is not enough. Nor is it enough that a court would have decided differently. Only breach of duty justifies the court intervening, except in rare cases like an honest deadlock among trustees.
On consequences, he agreed with the Court of Appeal that a breach does not make the trustees’ act void automatically. Instead, it is voidable (able to be set aside) at a beneficiary’s request, unless it involved a fraud on the power.
He noted the Court of Appeal had not decided whether courts should intervene only where trustees would have acted differently, or merely might have. He said this gap was deliberate. The rule concerns trustees failing to properly decide, not what a court should then do about it. He declined to set a rigid rule on when courts should intervene, favouring flexibility.
Finally, Lord Walker addressed professional advice. Trustees may still breach their duties despite following skilled advice, if their decision was outside their powers or against general law. For decisions within their powers, he began stating a further principle, which the extract cuts off.
Ratio and obiter
Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.
Proposition 1
Ratio · Lord Walker, with whom Lord Neuberger, Lady Hale, Lord Mance, Lord Clarke, Lord Sumption and Lord Carnwath agreed
Read judgment: [68] (opens in a new tab), [73] (opens in a new tab)
The requirement of breach of fiduciary duty was the ground on which the Hastings-Bass issues in both appeals were decided against the appellants ([95]-[98]), so it was necessary to the result.
Obiter · Lord Walker, with whom Lord Neuberger, Lady Hale, Lord Mance, Lord Clarke, Lord Sumption and Lord Carnwath agreed
Read judgment: [73] (opens in a new tab)
The statements that the court may also intervene in exceptional circumstances, such as an impasse reached by honest and reasonable trustees, and in the past special case of maintenance of minors, concern situations that did not arise: neither appeal involved them.
Obiter · Lord Walker, with whom Lord Neuberger, Lady Hale, Lord Mance, Lord Clarke, Lord Sumption and Lord Carnwath agreed
Read judgment: [91]–[93] (opens in a new tab)
The consequence of a breach (voidable rather than void) and the refusal to fix a would-not or might-not test did not arise on the facts, because no breach of fiduciary duty was found in either appeal ([96]-[97]). Lord Walker records that counsel on both sides agreed with the Court of Appeal on the void or voidable point and says that in the absence of further argument it is unnecessary to add much to it ([93]).
Proposition 2
Ratio · Lord Walker, with whom Lord Neuberger, Lady Hale, Lord Mance, Lord Clarke, Lord Sumption and Lord Carnwath agreed
Read judgment: [80]–[81] (opens in a new tab), [88] (opens in a new tab), [95]–[97] (opens in a new tab)
The Hastings-Bass appeals failed because no breach of fiduciary duty could be found against trustees who had taken and followed apparently competent advice that was wrong ([95]-[97]); the statements at [80], [81] and [88] are the reasons given for treating that conduct as no breach, and the strict-liability and agency arguments were answered in them.
Obiter · Lord Walker, with whom Lord Neuberger, Lady Hale, Lord Mance, Lord Clarke, Lord Sumption and Lord Carnwath agreed
Read judgment: [88] (opens in a new tab), [75] (opens in a new tab)
Lord Walker’s suggestion of what the particular cases in Lord Truro LC’s statement may have included (maintenance of minors, and Kerr-type factual judgments) is expressed as a possibility and was not needed for the result, since neither appeal involved such a case.
Why does this case matter?
A tax bill that falls on a family after a trustee decision invites a sympathetic answer: the result is bad, so the decision should be undone. Examiners look for a student who tests the sympathetic answer against what the Supreme Court said and who is clear about the weight an English decision carries in Australia.
Exam and application relevance
In a problem, state the trustees’ decision, the power used, their inquiries, and the relief sought. Then cite Lord Walker by paragraph.
This UK Supreme Court decision is persuasive, not binding, in Australia.
Read Dawson-Damer [2025] UKPC 32 first. Pitt’s mistake ground is separate.
Check your understanding
In Futter, what had the trustees overlooked about the tax advice ([95])?
Why did Lord Walker not treat Mr Cutbill as personally in breach, despite his dual role ([96])?
What did he conclude about Mrs Pitt’s own position ([97])?