Health Ombudsman v Antley

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal · 2016

Administrative LawHealth Disability And Elder LawProfessional DisciplineHealth And Community Services Complaints

Health Ombudsman v Antley [2016] QCAT 472

A nurse who stole and forged prescriptions faces six charges before a tribunal, and the regulator does not succeed on all of them. Is the regulator entitled to its costs, and can a charge rest on the way she behaved after the offending?

What happened?

Lara Antley, a 39-year-old registered nurse, started at ICON Cancer Care in April 2014. She stole a script pad, forged two Endone prescriptions, and presented them at three pharmacies. A pharmacist’s mandatory complaint followed; her employer dismissed her in July 2014. In August 2014 she pleaded guilty to fraud and stealing, fined $500, no conviction recorded. She said she meant to self-medicate severe pain. The Nursing and Midwifery Board imposed conditions, then she surrendered her registration in 2016, though the complaint still proceeded. QCAT received six charges in December 2015. She later withdrew from participating; the matter was decided on the papers. The Ombudsman sought a nine-month disqualification, reprimand and costs.

What did the Court decide?

QCAT, with three assessors, found professional misconduct on charges 1–4, unprofessional conduct on charge 5, no case on charge 6. Reprimanded, disqualified nine months, no costs.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

Judicial Member Thomas, with three assessors, found the nurse’s conduct seriously wrong. Stealing blank prescriptions, forging them for Endone, and obtaining the drug was “totally unacceptable for any practising nurse.” This satisfied the professional misconduct charges against her ([42]).

He also found unprofessional conduct on charge 5, failing to notify the National Board of criminal charges. He noted this type of charge is secondary to the original misconduct. It usually only adds “a relatively minor aggravation” to the overall conduct ([31], [37]).

On sanction, he said protecting public health and safety, and maintaining public trust, are basic considerations. General and personal deterrence are “highly relevant” ([43]). He noted cancellation, suspension or postponement cases usually range from six months to three years ([46]).

General deterrence is unlikely unless a loss of registration of at least 12 to 18 months is known to be probable. He said the proposed nine months “tends to be on the light side” but still “falls within the proper range.” This was because more than seven months’ registration had already been lost through surrender ([49], [50]). With the assessors’ advice, he ordered a reprimand plus disqualification from applying for registration for nine months ([48], [50], [84]).

In a later decision, the same Judicial Member corrected an error: two prescriptions were forged, not ten ([19]). He said the reasons lacked enough detail to be used effectively as a precedent on sanction, and no amendments could be made to them ([20]).

On costs, he noted that s 195 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law Act 2009 (Qld), which let the Tribunal make any costs order it considered appropriate, was repealed in 2013. He assumed this repeal was deliberate ([56]-[58]). The result is that parties must bear their own costs unless the “interests of justice require” otherwise—the general QCAT approach, now applicable to health disciplinary matters ([59]).

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Proposition 1

Ratio · Judicial Member Thomas (Hon J B Thomas AM QC), assisted by assessors

Read judgment: [31] (opens in a new tab), [37] (opens in a new tab), [42]–[50] (opens in a new tab)

These paragraphs are the stated reasons for the findings on charges 1 to 5 and for the reprimand and nine-month disqualification ordered at [84]. The decision is that of one Judicial Member of a Tribunal at first instance, sitting with assessors, so it is persuasive and does not bind other decision-makers. The later remarks in the same Judicial Member’s decision of 2 May 2018 ([2018] QCAT 147 at [19], [20]) are about this decision, not part of its reasons.

Proposition 2

Ratio · Judicial Member Thomas (Hon J B Thomas AM QC), assisted by assessors

Read judgment: [57]–[59] (opens in a new tab), [61]–[65] (opens in a new tab), [69]–[72] (opens in a new tab), [78]–[83] (opens in a new tab)

The default rule that follows from the repeal of s 195, the countervailing considerations, and the conclusion that the interests of justice did not require a costs order are the grounds of the costs order made at [83] and [84]. The Judicial Member qualified them at [52] as given without adversarial submissions, which is why the decision is best treated as persuasive.

Obiter · Judicial Member Thomas (Hon J B Thomas AM QC), assisted by assessors

Read judgment: [76]–[77] (opens in a new tab)

The observations about factors that may favour a costs order, and about the limits he would have placed on costs had he been inclined to make an order, are expressed as what may exist in other cases or what would be needed if he were otherwise inclined, and he did not make a costs order.

Proposition 3

Ratio · Judicial Member Thomas (Hon J B Thomas AM QC), assisted by assessors

Read judgment: [32]–[39] (opens in a new tab)

The conclusions that charge 6 was too broad, was unsupported by Re Hampton and lacked particulars are the grounds for the finding that there was no case to answer on it ([84], order 1(c)). The remark at [36] that particulars are not uncommon in charges, and the Wakelin example, illustrate the reasoning.

Why does this case matter?

This case tests two shortcuts: assuming a winning regulator gets costs, and assuming bad conduct after an offence proves a charge. Not every charge succeeded.

Check your understanding

What did charges 1-6 allege, and how did the Tribunal rule on each?

What orders followed on sanction and costs, and whose advice shaped them? Why did charge 6 fail, and what did the Tribunal say about costs submissions it lacked?

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail. The full case note is the complete statement.