Akai Pty Ltd v People’s Insurance Co Ltd
Akai Pty Ltd v People’s Insurance Co Ltd (1996) 188 CLR 418
A Sydney company’s insurance policy says English law governs and disputes go to the English courts. The insurer asks the Sydney court to stay the claim. A federal Act says its protections cannot be contracted out of.
What happened?
Akai, a New South Wales company, was insured by People’s Insurance, a Singapore company, under a credit insurance policy. When a retailer failed, the insurer alleged breaches.
Akai sued in the Supreme Court of New South Wales and, the same day, in England.
Clause 9 chose English law and referred disputes to English courts. The primary judge stayed the NSW proceeding; the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, Kirby P dissenting. Akai appealed by special leave. Ask what could displace that clause.
What did the Court decide?
High Court allowed the appeal, 3–2, on 23 December 1996. It set aside the Court of Appeal and Commercial Division orders, dismissed the insurer’s stay motion, and awarded Akai costs. Dawson and McHugh JJ dissented.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
Toohey, Gaudron and Gummow JJ held that ss 52 and 8 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) show Parliament meant two things. First, parties cannot contract out of the Act. Second, the Act’s regime applies to contracts whose proper law is, or would be, that of a State or Territory.
The Act uses the proper law as the connecting factor. This is worked out objectively. Choosing another law does not break that connection. Here, New South Wales had the closest and most real connection to the Policy. So s 8 applied to it.
Their Honours said “an express provision to the contrary” in s 8(2) is not limited to an express choice of law clause. They also rejected a three-way split between express, inferred and objective choice. There is only one question: did the parties, on the contract’s proper construction, exercise their common law liberty to choose a governing law?
Dawson and McHugh JJ thought it unnecessary and premature to decide the proper law. They said the stay application could be resolved using the choice of courts clause alone.
On the stay, Toohey, Gaudron and Gummow JJ said courts start with a strong disposition to uphold a foreign jurisdiction clause, unless strong reasons favour a stay. A stay may be refused if the clause offends the forum’s public policy, whether from statute or case law.
Why does this case matter?
A contract with a clause naming an overseas court invites a short answer in a problem question: enforce the bargain, or do not. An examiner looks for the particular statute relied on, the facts that tie the contract to it, and a separate step for the stay.
Check your understanding
1. Which Justices’ reasons decided the appeal, and what connecting factor did they say the Insurance Contracts Act used for its operation?
2. How did Dawson and McHugh JJ distinguish a choice of law clause from a choice of courts clause, and what followed for the stay?
3. What did the later High Court decisions say about how far Akai goes?