Vicarious liability and non-delegable duty

Vicarious liability: the relationship

Vicarious liability is a rule that makes one person legally responsible for another’s wrongdoing. It normally applies to employment relationships, not to independent contractors.

Courts used to decide which relationship existed by weighing many factors. These included control, who supplied equipment, delegation, public presentation, and payment method. This was the approach in Hollis v Vabu Pty Ltd.

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd changed this approach significantly.

Now, if the parties have a comprehensive written contract, that contract decides the relationship’s character. This only applies where the contract is not a sham and has not been varied, or changed later.

The decision looks at the rights and obligations the contract creates. It does not ask how the work was actually performed in practice.

The old multifactorial matters still matter, but only in a limited way. They are relevant only so far as they relate to the contract’s rights and duties, not as a broad inquiry into how the relationship worked in practice.

Vicarious liability: the course of employment

The tort must happen “in the course of employment” — meaning while the employee was doing their job. A careless act the employer authorised still counts. Even a careless act done in the wrong way may still count.

Deliberate wrongdoing is harder, because it rarely looks like the job itself. But that doesn’t automatically put it outside the course of employment — even a criminal act can sometimes fall within it.

For intentional torts, Prince Alfred College Inc v ADC (2016) 258 CLR 134 asks whether the employment gave the “occasion” for the wrong. This means the special role, authority, power, trust, control and intimacy the job gave the employee. The question isn’t whether the employer approved the act, but whether the job put the employee in a position that made the wrong possible that way. Just having the same opportunity as any co-worker isn’t enough.

Separately, under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s 15AA changes how “employee” is worked out, where it applies, from 26 August 2024. It asks for the “real substance, practical reality and true nature” of the relationship — not just the contract, but how it actually works in practice. A note says this responds to Personnel Contracting and Jamsek.

This doesn’t mean Personnel Contracting no longer matters generally. Section 15AA only applies “for the purposes of” the Fair Work Act, so the common-law test — the one vicarious liability depends on — is unaffected. Sections 15AB–15AD let a qualifying high-income person opt out of s 15AA entirely. Section 15AA(3) also switches it off for Divisions 2A and 2B of Part 1-3, and for Part 3-1 where that Part applies only because of s 30G or s 30R. So check which legal question you’re actually answering before picking a test.

Non-delegable duty

Some relationships create a non-delegable duty. This is a duty to ensure reasonable care is taken. You cannot discharge it just by hiring a competent contractor.

Schools and pupils, hospitals and patients, and employers and employees are established examples. In Kondis v State Transport Authority, the key idea was vulnerability: the person owed the duty depends on the defendant’s care. Burnie Port Authority v General Jones Pty Ltd applied similar reasoning to dangerous activities on land.

Until 2026, there was a limit. In New South Wales v Lepore, a majority held this duty could not apply to harm from an intentional criminal act. In 2026, the High Court overturned that limit in AA v The Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Maitland-Newcastle, deciding 5:2. Now, intentional conduct by the duty-holder or their delegate can breach the duty.

Two things still remain true. First, the duty is not absolute: there is no liability unless the duty-holder or delegate failed to take reasonable care. An intentional criminal act by a delegate can now count as that failure. Second, overturning the old rule did not decide AA’s own case. His damages were still capped under Pt 2 of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW).

Why the distinction changes the answer

These three legal routes can each fail for different reasons. That is why you must plead and analyse them separately.

Vicarious liability fails if the wrongdoer was an independent contractor, not an employee. This is true no matter how the employer itself behaved.

A non-delegable duty claim fails if the relationship does not attract that duty. It also fails if neither the duty-holder nor whoever it delegated the task to was careless.

Direct negligence (things like negligent selection, poor systems, or failing to supervise) can still be argued if the other two routes fail. But it needs its own proof of duty, breach, causation and damage, and can fail on its own terms. In Bird v DP (a pseudonym), the Diocese’s direct liability failed because the judge found it did not know, and had no reason to know, of the risk.

Finally, check the civil liability statutes. Some jurisdictions change how proportionate liability and contribution work, affecting how loss gets divided once liability is found.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by pinpointing the wrongdoer and the relationship. Is this person an employee, or an independent contractor working under a full written contract?

If there’s a full written contract, work out the relationship from its rights and obligations first. Don’t generally use how the work was actually carried out to interpret the contract. Conduct can still matter for things like formation, unwritten terms, sham arrangements, variation, waiver or estoppel.

Next, look at the conduct itself and how it connects to the work assigned. For deliberate wrongdoing, this connection question is usually resolved by asking about the role’s special features.

That means asking what the role actually gave the wrongdoer — authority, trust, control, or intimacy. The question is whether the role created the occasion for the wrong, not just an opportunity for it.

Separately, consider whether the relationship attracts a non-delegable duty (a duty that cannot be handed off to someone else). Since the case mentioned in the passage, this duty can extend even to a delegate’s intentional criminal act. But liability still requires a failure to take reasonable care, by either the duty-holder or the delegate. It is not automatic or absolute.

Where the facts support it, also plead the defendant’s own direct negligence as an alternative. This needs its own proof of duty, breach, causation and damage.

The High Court marked a limit on this in CCIG Investments Pty Ltd v Schokman (2023) 278 CLR 165. The majority said that if employment merely gave an opportunity for the wrongful act, the connection is “tenuous”. The key message: opportunity alone isn’t enough — ask whether the employment put the person in a genuinely special position.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.