Trustees’ discretions: genuine consideration and the review of trustee decisions

What genuine consideration required in *Finch*

The trial judge, Byrne J, discussed good faith but found no bad faith by the trustee. The High Court read this as meaning the trustee failed to give “genuine” consideration, because it did not make enough inquiries.

Byrne J found three inquiry failures. The trustee did not ask about the member’s last months with his employer. It did not look further into material suggesting his later jobs were a failed rehabilitation attempt. It also relied on a reported statement that a job was “a real job”, without letting the member respond.

The High Court held the Court of Appeal’s criticisms of this reasoning failed. Byrne J’s view that the trustee breached its duty of inquiry stood.

The High Court said it would be “bizarre” if knowingly excluding relevant information were not a breach of duty. Failing to seek information needed to resolve conflicting material was also a breach. This applied where a deed gave a power to consider information, coupled with a duty to do so.

What follows from a flawed decision

In Finch, the High Court did not decide the member’s claim itself. The trustee had failed to observe due process by not giving genuine consideration to the decision. There was no bad faith, and a decision for the member was not the only possible outcome.

Because of this, the High Court sent the matter back to the trustee to reconsider. This is called remitting the matter. A flaw in how the decision was made led to a fresh decision by the trustee, not a substitute decision by the court.

English case law, which is persuasive only and not binding in Australia, offers extra guidance. Lord Walker agreed that when trustees breach their duties but still act within the power given to them, the act is not void (automatically of no effect). Instead it may be voidable, meaning a beneficiary harmed by it can ask a court to set it aside.

This does not apply if the trustees’ act amounts to a fraud on the power, meaning they used the power for an improper purpose.

Lord Walker distinguished this situation from two others. An act outside the power altogether is called “excessive execution”. A decision within the power made without proper consideration is called “inadequate deliberation”.

English limits on inadequate deliberation (persuasive only)

This is an English case, only persuasive in Australia. Futter; Pitt v Holt dealt with tax-planning trusts and the rule in Re Hastings-Bass. Lord Walker set limits on that rule.

He said poor deliberation must be serious enough to breach fiduciary duty. Falling short of the “highest possible standards” is not enough on its own.

He also held trustees should not face strict liability if they honestly get and follow professional advice that turns out wrong, provided the decision was within their powers.

Quoting Re Beloved Wilkes’s Charity, he said courts only check honesty, integrity and fairness of the process. Courts generally won’t review whether the conclusion itself was correct, except in particular cases, such as those needing a specific factual finding.

This is not necessarily the Australian position. In Finch, the court left open whether a superannuation trustee must form a “fair and reasonable” opinion, or even a “correct” one (at [66]). Whether Australian courts accept the English limits on Hastings-Bass isn’t addressed here.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out what kind of decision the trustee made. Was it picking among objects under a wide discretion, or forming an opinion about whether a beneficiary meets a condition? Say which, following Finch at [29]-[36].

If it is a wide discretion, use the Karger v Paul formulation. Note it was quoted by the Court of Appeal in Finch at [28], but came from a single-judge decision. The High Court left open how far it reaches, at [65].

Then check what the trustee actually did. What did it ask itself, what information did it have, and did it put adverse material to the beneficiary? Compare this to the failures found in Finch at [44]-[49]. Remember those failures were specific to one superannuation deed.

If the decision instead involves forming an opinion outside superannuation, you can only argue by analogy from Finch at [66]. Finch did not decide how far this duty extends beyond that deed.

Be cautious about the consequence of a flawed decision. In Finch, the matter was remitted to the trustee, based on its own facts. The English idea of treating such decisions as “voidable” (capable of being set aside) is only persuasive, not binding.

If the trustee relied on professional advice, note that Futter; Pitt v Holt is persuasive only. It also requires that the trustee’s failure amount to a breach of fiduciary duty (a breach of its duty of loyalty and proper care to beneficiaries).

Self-check

Check your answer against four things before you finish.

First, say clearly whether the decision involves a wide discretion, or an opinion forming part of a duty. Rely only on what the High Court actually decided, not more.

Second, remember the Karger v Paul statement appears only as quoted in Finch. Don’t treat it as something the High Court itself held.

Third, label any English case statements as persuasive only. They are not binding here.

Finally, note what Finch left open, at paragraphs [65] and [66]. Don’t claim those points were settled.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.