Proportionate liability and concurrent wrongdoers in New South Wales
What Part 4 changes
Under common law, a negligent defendant can be treated as the sole cause of loss. That defendant bears the whole loss but can seek contribution from other wrongdoers. If those others cannot pay, the sued defendant carries that risk.
In Hunt & Hunt Lawyers v Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 10, the joint reasons described Part 4 as changing this. Under proportionate liability, the risk that another wrongdoer cannot pay shifts to the plaintiff instead.
Section 35(1) is the key provision. For an apportionable claim, a concurrent wrongdoer’s liability is limited to a just proportion of the loss. The court decides this by looking at how responsible that defendant was. Judgment cannot exceed that proportionate amount.
Who counts as a concurrent wrongdoer: *Hunt & Hunt*
In Hunt & Hunt v Mitchell Morgan, Hunt & Hunt drafted a mortgage and loan agreement for a lender. A fraudster forged the borrower’s signature. The loan agreement was void, so the mortgage secured nothing. The fraudsters were bankrupt, and Hunt & Hunt’s negligence was not disputed on appeal.
The issue was whether the fraudsters were “concurrent wrongdoers” with Hunt & Hunt under s 34(2), which would limit the solicitors’ liability.
The majority (French CJ, Hayne and Kiefel JJ) said yes. They applied s 34(2) in two steps. First, they identified the relevant “damage”: the lender’s inability to recover its money, not the earlier ineffectiveness of the security. Second, they asked whether the fraudsters’ conduct also caused that damage. They held it did, materially contributing to the loss, even though Part 4 does not require one wrongdoer to contribute to the other’s wrongdoing.
The majority also distinguished deciding who counts as a concurrent wrongdoer from deciding the proportion of liability, saying the latter involves broader value judgments. They restored the trial judge’s finding that Hunt & Hunt was liable for only 12.5 per cent of the loss.
Bell and Gageler JJ dissented. They would have required the other person to be legally liable for the same harm, and defined the harm differently: the lack of security itself, not the inability to recover. On that view, the fraudsters did not cause that harm, so Hunt & Hunt was not a concurrent wrongdoer.
The majority’s reasoning binds lower courts; the dissent does not, but shows the key disagreement about defining “the damage” when a defendant’s duty was to guard against another’s wrongdoing.
Applying this in a problem question
This is New South Wales law. First check whether s 3B excludes the civil liability you are dealing with.
Next, ask if the claim is an “apportionable claim” under s 34(1). Treat paragraphs (a) and (b) separately: s 34(1)(a) excludes claims arising from personal injury, but s 34(1)(b) does not. Also check s 34(3A) and the excluded concurrent wrongdoers listed in s 34A.
Then identify the actual damage or loss claimed, not the damages amount, as the joint reasons in Hunt & Hunt did. Ask whether someone else’s acts or omissions also caused that damage. Where the defendant’s duty was to protect the plaintiff from another person’s wrongdoing, note that Bell and Gageler JJ dissented on this point in Hunt & Hunt; the majority view is binding on lower Australian courts.
Check whether the defendant’s liability is non-delegable or vicarious. If so, consider s 5Q and s 39(a), and only rely on Pafburn for the kind of claim it actually decided.
Finally, if the defendant is a concurrent wrongdoer, apply s 35(1). The court excludes any proportion of loss caused by the plaintiff’s contributory negligence, and may take into account wrongdoers who are not parties to the case (s 35(3)). Under s 36, a defendant held liable under Part 4 cannot be forced to contribute to, or indemnify, another concurrent wrongdoer for that same apportionable claim.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.