Institutional child-abuse liability: common law and statutory exceptions

What the duty requires, and where the wording diverges

Two different wording standards apply, so check the exact Act. Victoria, New South Wales, Tasmania and the ACT use “reasonable care” or “reasonable precautions”. Queensland, South Australia and the Northern Territory use “all reasonable steps”. These are not interchangeable.

The duty can reach beyond employees. Victoria’s s 90(1) covers officers, volunteers, contractors and religious personnel, and extends through delegation of care under paragraphs (c) and (d). New South Wales’s s 6E is similar, adding carers authorised by a designated agency.

Exceptions limit this reach. Victoria’s s 91(6) excludes abuse “wholly unrelated” to the person’s association with the organisation, and s 91(7) applies this to delegations too. South Australia’s s 50E(2) and (3) do similar work.

Tasmania takes a different approach. Section 49H(3) presumes breach once the plaintiff shows the abuse occurred, that the association gave authority, trust or access, and that this was used to commit the abuse.

Scope also varies, and must be checked before the standard of care. Victoria’s Part XIII covers physical and sexual abuse as defined in s 88. Queensland covers sexual abuse or serious physical abuse. Western Australia’s Part 2A is limited to child sexual abuse.

The Northern Territory goes further in one way. Section 17D(2) imposes a duty to take all reasonable steps to prevent a child abusing another child under the institution’s care, supervision or authority.

Suing an institution that is not capable of being sued

Many defendant bodies are unincorporated, meaning the law does not treat them as a legal person capable of being sued.

In Victoria, such a body still counts as a relevant organisation if it nominates an associated legal person under s 92. Sections 92(2) and (3) allow this nomination even after the abuse happened. Liability is then treated as starting from the date of the abuse.

For public sector bodies, s 91(5) names the organisation as defendant if it can be sued, or the State if it cannot. The Note to s 93C refers to s 4 of the Legal Identity of Defendants (Organisational Child Abuse) Act 2018 (Vic). That provision applies to unincorporated non-government organisations controlling associated trusts, regardless of when the abuse occurred.

Other states use different approaches. In New South Wales, s 6K(1) allows proceedings against an unincorporated organisation in its own name, treating it as if it had legal personality.

In Queensland, s 33H lets the institution nominate a defendant. If there is no nominee, or the nominee lacks enough assets, a court may instead name the trustee of an associated (or formerly associated) trust as defendant. This includes cases where the trust was deliberately de-associated to shield its property.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by finding the right state or territory’s rules on institutional child abuse. Check whether the conduct fits that jurisdiction’s definition of abuse. Also check whether the child was under the institution’s care, supervision or authority at the time.

Work out the date of the abuse. This matters because the statutory duty and the statutory vicarious liability do not apply to the same time periods.

If using the duty route, follow the statute’s own order. First show abuse by an associated individual. Then make the institution prove it met its own Act’s standard, which may be reasonable precautions or all reasonable steps.

Check that jurisdiction’s carve-outs. These may include abuse happening in circumstances wholly unrelated to the person’s association with the institution. Also check the limits on who counts as akin to an employee.

Work out who can be sued. If the institution is unincorporated, this may mean working through nomination, appointment or associated-trust provisions before naming a defendant.

Finally, consider limitation periods, and whether there is an earlier judgment or settlement. Identify which court can set aside that earlier order or agreement. Plead the general-law routes as alternatives.

Self-check

Before you finish, check your work against these points.

Name the Act and the jurisdiction first. Do this before you state any legal standard.

Use the exact wording the Act uses. Say “reasonable precautions” or “all reasonable steps,” not your own version of it.

Check if the jurisdiction even has a statutory vicarious liability provision. Vicarious liability means an institution can be liable for someone else’s wrong. If it exists, check who the “akin to an employee” category leaves out.

Make sure the defendant can actually be sued in law. Not every entity has this capacity.

Work out which court can set aside the judgment or settlement blocking the claim. “Set aside” means the court cancels an earlier decision.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.