Defences
Contributory negligence
Contributory negligence happens when the plaintiff did not take reasonable care for their own safety, and this helped cause their harm. Courts judge the plaintiff the same way they judge a defendant: by asking what a reasonable person would have done, looking forward, using the same statutory principles.
At common law, contributory negligence was a complete defence — it stopped a claim entirely. Legislation in every State and Territory changed this to a reduction of damages instead. Courts reduce damages by what is just and equitable, based on the plaintiff’s share of responsibility, though the wording differs between jurisdictions (Western Australia, for example, refers to the degree of the plaintiff’s negligence). Students should check the specific jurisdiction’s Act.
This apportionment considers both how much each party is to blame and how much their conduct actually caused the harm. This comes from Joslyn v Berryman.
Most jurisdictions now let courts reduce damages by 100 per cent if that is just and equitable. This can produce the same result as the old complete defence, in an extreme case. Some jurisdictions also presume contributory negligence where the plaintiff was intoxicated, or relied on someone they knew was intoxicated.
In New South Wales, there is a specific rule for motor accidents. If an adult passenger knew, or should have known, the driver was impaired by alcohol or drugs, courts must find contributory negligence — unless the passenger could not reasonably have refused to be a passenger in the circumstances. This rule appears in two Acts, worded the same way.
Joslyn was decided under the earlier Act’s provision. The passage notes that later provisions are marked as corresponding to it. The change between these provisions reflects which Act applies to the accident’s date — it does not mean courts rejected the reasoning in Joslyn.
Voluntary assumption of risk
Voluntary assumption of risk is a full defence, but it is hard to prove.
The defendant must show the plaintiff knew about the specific risk involved. The defendant must also show the plaintiff fully understood that risk and freely accepted it.
Knowing about danger in general is not enough. Simply continuing an activity is not enough either.
Because this is so hard to prove, the defence rarely works by itself. Statutory obvious risk provisions now modify and add to this defence.
Obvious risk and dangerous recreational activities
Statutes offer the main defence here, though rules vary between jurisdictions.
A plaintiff is presumed to have known about an obvious risk. This is a presumption, meaning the plaintiff must prove otherwise to beat it.
Defendants generally don’t need to warn of obvious risks, though there are exceptions.
A defendant is not liable if harm comes from an obvious risk of a dangerous recreational activity. This applies even if the plaintiff didn’t actually know about the risk, and it can defeat a claim entirely.
The hard part is deciding what counts as a “dangerous recreational activity,” and how the risk is defined. These questions decide cases, and answers differ by jurisdiction.
Illegality
There is no blanket rule stopping a criminal from suing. Being a criminal does not automatically bar a legal claim.
Instead, the law uses a coherence principle. Courts deny a duty, or allow a defence, only where accepting the claim would clash with the purpose of the criminal law.
The clearest example is a joint criminal enterprise. This means people committing a crime together. If the injury arose from that joint crime, the claim may be denied.
Some Australian jurisdictions also have statutes. These laws deny or limit damages where the harm happened during a serious offence.
Defences to the intentional torts
Consent is a defence if the plaintiff agreed to the contact or entry. But consent gained by fraud about the nature of the act is not real consent, and consent does not cover acts beyond its scope. Whether someone has capacity to consent is a separate question, and for medical treatment statute partly governs this.
Self-defence and defence of another require the response to be necessary and reasonable. The test differs between jurisdictions. In New South Wales, the defendant must believe the conduct was necessary for protection, and it must be a reasonable response as the defendant saw the circumstances (Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) s 52(2)).
Defence of property can justify reasonable force to protect it, but jurisdictions limit this. In New South Wales, s 52(3) says this defence does not cover force meant or reckless to kill, when the only aim is protecting property or dealing with a trespasser.
Necessity is a defence where an emergency justifies what would otherwise be trespass. Courts judge this objectively and interpret it narrowly.
Lawful authority is a defence based on legislation, such as powers of arrest, detention and search under that jurisdiction’s law and their conditions. It can also arise under surviving common law powers. The particular power relied on, and its conditions, must be identified.
Limitation periods
You must sue within the limitation period set by statute. This is not a defence on the merits, but it still ends the claim completely.
Limitation periods vary by type of claim and by jurisdiction. For personal injury, time often starts from when the injury was discoverable, not when it happened.
Courts can sometimes extend these periods. Some jurisdictions have also scrapped limitation periods entirely for child sexual abuse claims.
Always check the relevant Act. These rules differ too much to safely generalise.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.