General deductions: incurred in gaining or producing income

*Lunney*: a prerequisite is not enough

In Lunney v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1958), an employee and a dentist each claimed fares between home and work as deductions. By a four-to-one majority, the Court held these fares were not deductible.

Dixon CJ said the rule against deducting such fares had been settled for two generations. He said only Parliament, not the Court, could change it.

Williams, Kitto and Taylor JJ held that being “incidental and relevant” to earning income is not enough on its own. An expense being a prerequisite to earning income does not mean it is incurred in gaining that income. They treated the fares as personal or living expenses, at most a necessary consequence of living in one place and working in another.

McTiernan J dissented, and would have allowed the deduction.

*Payne*: travel between two places of work

Payne: travel between two places of work

In Commissioner of Taxation v Payne, a pilot tried to deduct travel costs between his deer farm and the airport. The High Court held, 3:2, that this was not deductible under s 51(1).

The majority reasoned the travel was between two separate, unrelated income-earning activities. It was not part of either activity, just travel to get into position to start work — similar to travelling from home to work. They said this distinction applies generally, not just to travel expenses.

The dissenting judges, Gaudron and Gummow JJ, would have limited the earlier Lunney principle more narrowly. They said it only covers travel between a single workplace and a person’s home.

The 1997 Act now has s 25-100. It lets an individual deduct transport costs for travel directly between two places, if they were earning assessable income at the first place and went to the second to do the same. This does not apply if one of the places is where the person lives, and further limits appear in s 25-100(3) and (4). Payne only decided the s 51(1) position — not how s 25-100 would apply — and the farm in that case was the taxpayer’s home.

Reading the cases together

These cases are not a formal test. They are grouped to help you think through the same questions each time.

Ask what activity produces the income. Ask if the expense was incurred during that activity, not just before it starts. Then check if s 8-1(2) blocks the deduction anyway.

The High Court’s decisions bind lower courts. But the High Court itself can later reconsider and change its own rulings.

Payne was decided three judges to two. The dissent (the disagreeing judges) read the earlier case of Lunney more narrowly than the majority did.

Anstis dealt with a question the Court itself called unusual. It does not mean study expenses are generally deductible. For later years, s 26-19 has changed the outcome for youth allowance specifically.

Applying this in a problem question

First, identify the loss or outgoing, and the income it is said to gain or produce.

Next, ask what produces that income, then whether the outgoing’s occasion lies in it. This test comes from Ronpibon Tin. A cost that is only a precondition of earning income is not enough, as the joint judgment in Lunney held.

For travel, separate home-to-work travel, which Lunney denies a deduction for, from travel between two workplaces. In Payne, a three-to-two majority denied a deduction under s 51(1) for travel between unrelated activities. The dissent would not extend Lunney that far. Then check s 25-100, which excludes cases where one place is the person’s home.

Check s 8-1(2) for capital, private or domestic outgoings, exempt income, and other provisions. This includes s 26-19, for outgoings incurred in gaining a rebatable benefit. State which limb of s 8-1 applies.

If an outlay serves two purposes, consider apportioning it by a fair and reasonable assessment. Also check whether a specific deduction provision or Division 27 applies instead.

Finally, never state a rate or dollar figure. Always say which provision and which case under s 51(1) or s 8-1 supports each step.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.