Superannuation trustees: the SIS Act covenants and their enforcement
Who the trustee is and what the Act regulates
The Act mainly aims for prudent management of certain superannuation funds, approved deposit funds and pooled superannuation trusts (s 3(1)).
A regulated superannuation fund has a trustee, and that trustee is either a constitutional corporation under the fund’s rules, or the fund’s rules make old-age pensions its main purpose. The trustee must also elect for the Act to apply (s 19).
A registrable superannuation entity (RSE) covers regulated superannuation funds, approved deposit funds and pooled superannuation trusts. Self managed superannuation funds are excluded (s 10(1)).
A person generally cannot be or act as trustee of an RSE without an RSE licence, whether alone or as part of a licensed group. Breach of this rule is an offence (s 29J(1), (3)). If a body corporate is trustee, it must be the sole trustee (s 29J(4)).
A licensed trustee is called the RSE licensee. APRA administers RSE licensing (s 6(1)).
The governing rules mean the trust deed plus any other written or unwritten rules governing the fund (s 10(1)). The Act overrides these governing rules whenever they conflict (s 7).
The trustee covenants in s 52
Section 52 of the SIS Act sets out trustee covenants. If an RSE’s governing rules don’t already include these covenants, the law treats them as included anyway (s 52(1)). So every trustee is bound by them, regardless of what the deed says.
The core covenants require trustees to act honestly (s 52(2)(a)), and to exercise the care, skill and diligence of a prudent superannuation trustee (s 52(2)(b)). Trustees must also act in beneficiaries’ best financial interests (s 52(2)(c)).
Where conflicts arise between beneficiaries and others (including the trustee itself), the trustee must prioritise beneficiaries and follow prudential standards on conflicts (s 52(2)(d)). Trustees must also act fairly between and within classes of beneficiaries (s 52(2)(e), (f)).
Other covenants require keeping entity assets separate, avoiding improper fettering of trustee functions, managing reserves under a strategy, and giving beneficiaries access to prescribed information (s 52(2)(g)-(j)).
Section 52(3) defines a “superannuation trustee” as someone whose profession or employment includes acting as trustee and investing beneficiaries’ money. The best-interests covenant also covers third-party payments made by or for the entity (s 52(3A)). The conflicts covenant overrides conflicting duties that executive officers or employees owe under Part 2D.1 of the Corporations Act (s 52(4)).
Section 52 also imposes further covenants on investment, insurance, risk management, retirement income, member outcomes and MySuper (s 52(6)-(14)), but these are not covered here. Each covenant applies alongside every other covenant in ss 52 to 53 (s 51A).
The sole purpose test and arm’s length investment
Trustees must run a superannuation fund only for core purposes, or core purposes plus listed ancillary ones (s 62(1)). Core purposes mean paying benefits to a member at retirement or a set age, or to their legal representative or dependants if they die earlier. Ancillary purposes include benefits for leaving work due to ill-health, and anything else the Regulator approves in writing (s 62(1)(b)). This rule applies to every regulated fund, including self-managed funds. Breaching s 62(1) can bring a civil penalty — a court-ordered fine for breaking the law (s 62(2)).
A separate rule covers investments. A trustee or investment manager can only invest if the deal is at arm’s length — meaning the parties act independently, not favouring each other — or on terms no better for the other side than that. This duty is also a civil penalty provision (s 109(1), (2)).
How the covenants sit on the general law
This builds on trustee duties, fiduciary obligations, and directors’ statutory duties. The covenants write several of these duties into every RSE’s rules and raise the standard of care.
In AustralianSuper, Hespe J said the prudent superannuation trustee standard started on 1 July 2013. It raised the older “ordinary prudent person” standard. The s 52(2)(b) covenant covers all trustee acts and decisions, not just investing, and overrides any inconsistent express term, because of s 7.
In Kelaher, Jagot J held the higher standard only applies to conduct after 1 July 2013. Whether it is met depends on the circumstances, judged forward-looking, not with hindsight. It does not make a trustee a guarantor against all loss or impose strict liability (liability without fault).
Kelaher was decided under the covenants as they stood before 1 July 2021. From that date, Schedule 3 to the Your Future, Your Super Act requires trustees and directors to act in beneficiaries’ “best financial interests” (ss 52(2)(c), 52A(2)(c)). This applies to duties and powers from that date, except for contracts made earlier. New s 220A presumes, in civil proceedings over a s 54B(1) contravention tied to s 52(2)(c), that the trustee failed this duty unless it proves otherwise.
General law duties still apply alongside the covenants. In Finch v Telstra Super, the High Court said a trustee’s decision can be reviewed if it was not properly informed. The duty to be properly informed is stricter in superannuation trusts than in ordinary trusts of the Karger v Paul kind.
Applying this in a problem question
To apply this to a problem question, first classify the fund. Is it an RSE (a registered fund) or a self managed fund? This decides whether ss 52 and 52A apply, or ss 52B and 52C, and who checks the sole purpose test (the rule that the fund must be run only for retirement purposes).
Next, identify who acted and when. A trustee’s conduct is judged under s 52, a director’s under s 52A. For conduct before 1 July 2013, the older “ordinary prudent person” standard applies (Kelaher [37]), and until 30 June 2021 the covenant used the words “best interests”.
Then match the conduct to the right covenant. This is judged on what was known at the time, not with hindsight. A loss to members does not, by itself, prove a breach (Kelaher [6], [40]).
Check the fund’s purpose and dealings too. If the fund is run for something beyond its core and ancillary purposes, s 62 applies. If an investment was not made on arm’s length terms (normal market terms between unrelated parties), s 109 applies.
Finally, choose the right legal route. A regulator may seek a declaration (a court statement that the law was breached) and, for a serious contravention, a penalty. A member who suffered loss can sue under s 55(3), generally within six years. Suing a director under s 52A(2) needs the court’s leave within six years, and the case must then start within whatever time the court sets. A prosecution requires a dishonest contravention done to gain an advantage, or with intent to deceive or defraud (s 202(1)).
For example, if a trustee leaves many members with duplicate accounts paying double fees, and breach of s 52(2)(b) or (c) is shown, AustralianSuper’s position treats each affected member as a separate contravention. APRA or ASIC may pursue this, and an affected member may recover their loss under s 55(3).
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.