Superannuation investment duties: strategy, best financial interests and the general-law inheritance

Best financial interests: the 2021 change

Before 1 July 2021, s 52(2)(c) told trustees to act “in the best interests of the beneficiaries”. The Treasury Laws Amendment (Your Future, Your Super) Act 2021 (Cth) changed this to “best financial interests”, in s 52(2)(c), s 52A(2)(c) and s 52B(2)(c).

The change applies to duties performed on or after 1 July 2021. It does not apply to contracts made earlier, unless later renewed or varied. The same amendments confirm the duty covers payments made to third parties (s 52(3A)).

The Act also changed proof requirements. Under s 220A, in civil proceedings over s 54B(1) and s 52(2)(c), courts presume the trustee did not act in beneficiaries’ best financial interests. The trustee can rebut this with evidence; if so, the Regulator must still prove the contravention on the balance of probabilities. This means the trustee only carries an evidential burden (a duty to point to some evidence), not the full legal burden. This presumption applies only to conduct on or after 1 July 2021.

Did the new wording actually change the law? The passage notes three things, then leaves a fourth unresolved.

First, in Australian Prudential Regulation Authority v Kelaher, Jagot J accepted a submission that where a trust’s purpose is financial, “best interests” usually means “best financial interests”. This drew on the English case Cowan v Scargill, which is not binding in Australia.

Second, in Australian Securities and Investments Commission v AustralianSuper Pty Ltd, Hespe J said the 2021 amendment aimed to clarify that financial interests—not non-financial ones—must be the determining factor for trustees. This was a statement about the purpose of the amendment, not a ruling applying it.

Third, the same case suggests the wording made little practical difference on its facts, though the passage does not finish explaining how.

How the best interests test is applied

Kelaher is the fullest explanation of this duty, though it deals with the covenant’s earlier wording. A covenant here means a promise written into the trust deed or law.

Jagot J held the test is objective. This means it looks at the trustee’s position at the time of the decision, not with hindsight.

Her Honour noted there is often more than one course of action that serves the beneficiaries’ best interests ([55]).

A decision breaches the covenant if it cannot be reasonably justified as in beneficiaries’ best interests, judged objectively on the facts at the time. A decision that can be reasonably justified does not breach it ([64]).

There is one exception: if it is proved the trustee’s actual, subjective purpose was contrary to beneficiaries’ best interests, the decision breaches the covenant even if objectively justifiable ([63]).

Finally, simply showing that more information could have been gathered does not, alone, make an otherwise objectively sound decision a breach ([53], [58]).

Applying this in a problem question

Start by identifying which covenant applies. Investment complaints engage s 52(6) and the care covenant in s 52(2)(b). Complaints about favouring another interest engage s 52(2)(c), and s 52(2)(d) if there’s a conflict.

Next, fix the date, since the standard changed over time. Pre-1 July 2013 conduct is judged by the ordinary prudent person standard. Pre-1 July 2021 conduct is tested against “best interests”. The s 220A presumption only applies to breaches from 1 July 2021.

Then test the strategy. Ask whether there was a strategy for the whole fund and each option, whether it addressed every s 52(6)(a) matter, and whether it was reviewed and followed. SPS 530 explains what a sound framework contains.

Judge the decision prospectively, meaning by what was known or knowable then, not hindsight. Ask whether the course was reasonably justifiable as in members’ best interests, not whether it lost money (Kelaher [55], [64]; Elder’s Trustee at 448).

Separate benefit decisions from investment decisions. A decision on a member’s claim attracts the Finch duty to inform. Kelaher declined to extend that duty to a large fund’s everyday investment decisions.

Finally, flag what’s unresolved. If a non-financial consideration was relied on, note the 2021 wording’s effect isn’t settled here. Argue it from the text, AustralianSuper’s stated purpose, and Kelaher’s earlier “normally” formulation.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →