Section 109 and inconsistency between Commonwealth and State laws
What the section says, and what it assumes
Section 109 deals with clashes between State and Commonwealth laws. It says that if a State law is inconsistent with a Commonwealth law, the Commonwealth law wins. The State law is invalid, but only to the extent of the inconsistency.
Covering clause 5 backs this up. It makes Commonwealth laws binding on courts, judges and people in every State, regardless of State law.
Section 109 assumes both laws are valid in the first place. Where Commonwealth and State powers overlap, the High Court has said inconsistency is not about constitutional limits. It is about how the two laws actually operate together. So the Commonwealth law’s validity must be settled first.
Section 109 also assumes we are comparing “laws” broadly, not just Acts of Parliament. In Jemena Asset Management (3) Pty Ltd v Coinvest Ltd, the High Court held that s 109 can apply to things like industrial awards or other legislative instruments made under a statute, not just the statute itself. The Court described the test as comparing any two laws that create rights, privileges or powers, and duties or obligations.
Direct collision applied: compensation and conspiracy
Telstra Corporation Ltd v Worthing involved a worker injured in 1993 while employed by Telstra. He claimed under the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW). The Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) had its own compensation scheme.
The two schemes differed. Weekly payments were worked out differently and ran for different periods. The federal Act paid for permanent impairment only above a 10 per cent threshold, and each scheme capped the amount. Interest was available under the State Act but not the federal Act.
The High Court held that applying the State law “would qualify, impair and, in some respects, negate the application of federal law”. It was “no answer that the subject-matters of the two laws are not co-incident”, because the State law “would deny or vary a right, power or privilege conferred by the federal law”. The Court of Appeal had also asked whether the federal law covered the field. That step was unnecessary once direct inconsistency was shown.
Dickson v The Queen applies the same reasoning in criminal law. Customs seized cigarettes and stored them in a Victorian warehouse. It was accepted they were in the Commonwealth’s possession for the Commonwealth theft provision.
The appellant was convicted of conspiracy to steal them under s 321 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic). Conspiracy means an agreement to commit an offence. The Victorian offence was complete once the agreement was made.
The Commonwealth conspiracy provision, s 11.5 of the Criminal Code (Cth), was narrower. It applied only where the primary offence carried more than 12 months’ imprisonment or a fine of 200 penalty units or more. It required an overt act, that is, a step taken to carry out the agreement. It imposed no liability on someone who withdrew before an overt act and took all reasonable steps to prevent the primary offence.
The Court held the State law “alters, impairs or detracts from the operation of the federal legislation and so directly collides with it”. It allowed the appeal and quashed the conviction, finding it unnecessary to consider covering the field.
In its reasoning, the Court noted that the different modes of trial strengthened the case for inconsistency. Section 80 of the Constitution requires a unanimous verdict on a trial on indictment for a Commonwealth offence. It also stressed that s 109 matters to the citizen, who would otherwise face concurrent duties.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by checking both laws are valid on their own. The Commonwealth law needs a head of power to support it. The State law must be valid in its own right too.
Next, identify the Commonwealth source. This can be a statute, or an instrument made under a statute, as long as it has the force of Commonwealth law.
Then test for direct inconsistency. Ask whether the State law would impose a greater obligation, attach liability the Commonwealth law excludes, or deny or change a right the Commonwealth law gives. Any such change must be significant, not trivial. The fact both laws could be obeyed at once does not resolve this.
If there’s no direct inconsistency, ask whether the Commonwealth law “covers the field” — meaning it’s meant to be a complete statement on that topic. Define the field narrowly, note what the Commonwealth law leaves untouched, and check for any express statement about whether it is exhaustive.
Finally, state the outcome precisely. The State law is invalid only to the extent of the inconsistency, so identify which part, if any, still survives.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.