Restrictive practices: the Commonwealth requirement and the State authorisation
The State and Territory half
Only five of the eight jurisdictions have authorisation schemes covered here, and each works differently. This section says nothing about New South Wales, Western Australia or the Northern Territory.
In South Australia, two officers share the authorising role. The Authorised Program Officer can approve level 1 practices, while the Senior Authorising Officer can approve level 1 or level 2 practices. Authorisation must stay within the Part, and must never be used as punishment, for others’ convenience, or to cover understaffing.
In Victoria, a regulated restrictive practice generally needs both an Authorised Program Officer’s authorisation and, for certain practices or persons, Senior Practitioner approval. This means two consents are needed for more intrusive practices, not two alternative paths. Emergency use is treated separately.
In Queensland, the task splits across two Acts. The Disability Services Act sets out the positive behaviour support plan and cumulative conditions for restraint in some services. The Guardianship and Administration Act then allows a guardian to be appointed for a restrictive practice matter, but this is only one consent route; the right approval process depends on the practice and setting.
The comparison that matters
Each state and territory handles restrictive practices differently. South Australia splits authorisation by level of practice, using an Authorised Program Officer and a Senior Authorising Officer. Victoria requires both an Authorised Program Officer and a Senior Practitioner for specified practices.
Queensland’s approach depends on the practice and setting. It may involve tribunal approval for containment or seclusion, or a guardian’s consent, under the guardianship Act, alongside plan requirements in the disability services Act.
The ACT uses a registration model, where a Senior Practitioner registers the plan. This covers three service sectors. Tasmania also uses a Senior Practitioner, authorising under its 2024 rights statute.
Two points matter here. First, job titles are not interchangeable across jurisdictions. South Australia’s Senior Authorising Officer, and the Senior Practitioner roles in Victoria, Tasmania and the ACT, each do different jobs under differently worded provisions.
Second, what gets authorised differs too. Sometimes it is a practice, sometimes a plan, and sometimes a decision made by a guardian for the person.
The purpose limits
Purpose limits are the most useful rules in this scheme. If a jurisdiction states one, you can resolve the common case without checking the process at all.
In South Australia, s 23M bans restrictive practices used as punishment or for the convenience of others. It also bans using them to make up for inadequate staffing, equipment or facilities. That last point matters: short-staffing never justifies a restrictive practice in South Australia, no matter what the paperwork shows.
Queensland has no single purpose limit like this. Instead it reaches a similar result through other means. Section 167 sets cumulative conditions (meaning all must be met) for restraint in respite and community access services. Section 150 adds separate content requirements for positive behaviour support plans.
A working order
Working through this problem means following a set order. First, identify whether the practice is regulated under s 6 of the Commonwealth Rules. This is the starting point before anything else.
Next, name the Commonwealth requirement correctly. It is a condition of registration that depends on State authorisation. It is not itself a Commonwealth authorisation.
Then turn to the relevant State or Territory scheme. Identify who the authorising officer is and what unit of authorisation applies. In Queensland, both relevant Acts must be named.
Purpose limits must be checked before the process is checked. A practice used merely for staffing convenience does not become lawful just because it has been authorised.
Finally, identify the enforcement route. This means registration conditions enforced against the provider, through the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commissioner. This includes the civil penalty in s 73J of the Act for breaching a condition.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.