Restrictive practices: the Commonwealth requirement and the State authorisation

How the Commonwealth NDIS rules condition registration on State authorisation of a regulated restrictive practice, and how the South Australian, Victorian, Queensland, ACT and Tasmanian authorisation schemes differ.

Learning level
Application
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, act, qld, sa, tas, vic
Subjects
health-disability-and-elder-law
Topics
restrictive-practices-and-behaviour-support, health-disability-and-elder-law-framework

Learning outcomes

  • Explain why the Commonwealth rules condition a provider’s registration rather than authorising a restrictive practice.
  • Identify the authorising officer and the unit of authorisation in each of the five State and Territory schemes stated here.
  • Name both Queensland instruments when answering a Queensland restrictive practices question.
  • Apply the statutory purpose limits before the process requirements.

A regulated restrictive practice used by an NDIS provider engages two bodies of law at once. The Commonwealth makes its use a matter of the provider’s registration conditions, keyed to State and Territory authorisation; the State or Territory supplies the authorisation itself. Where the State or Territory has an authorisation process, neither half is sufficient on its own, and an answer that names only one of them is wrong.

This article explains the join, then compares the State and Territory authorisation schemes that were established in the linked articles.

The Commonwealth half

The National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) defines restrictive practice broadly in s 9, so the narrower category that actually matters — the regulated restrictive practice — is a creature of the Rules rather than of the Act.1

The National Disability Insurance Scheme (Restrictive Practices and Behaviour Support) Rules 2018 (Cth) define the five regulated restrictive practices in s 6, and ss 8(2), 9(2)(a), 10(2)(a) and 11(2)(a) make their use a matter of the conditions of a registered provider’s registration, keyed to State and Territory prohibition and authorisation.2

Two consequences follow.

First, the Commonwealth does not authorise anything. It conditions registration on compliance with whatever the State or Territory requires. So where there is a State or Territory authorisation process, the Commonwealth instrument requires the use (other than a single emergency use) to be authorised in accordance with it; it does not tell you how to get that authorisation.

Second, the enforcement consequence flows from registration. Using a regulated restrictive practice without the required authorisation is a breach of a condition of registration, enforced against the provider by the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commissioner, and a registered provider that breaches a condition of its registration contravenes s 73J of the Act, a civil penalty provision.1 Neither is, by that route, a criminal or civil wrong against the participant.

The State and Territory half

Five of the eight jurisdictions have an authorisation scheme established in the linked articles, and they are built differently. This section does not state the position in New South Wales, Western Australia or the Northern Territory: no authorisation instrument for those jurisdictions was established in the linked articles, and nothing is asserted here about whether one exists.

South Australia — two officers. Part 6A of the Disability Inclusion Act 2018 (SA) splits authorisation between an Authorised Program Officer, who may authorise level 1 practices (s 23N), and the Senior Authorising Officer, who may authorise level 1 or level 2 practices (s 23O).3 Section 23A(4) states the limit: nothing in the Part authorises the use of restrictive practices other than in accordance with this Part. Section 23M limits the purposes, expressly forbidding use as a punishment or for the convenience of others, or to address inadequate levels of staffing, equipment or facilities.

Victoria — authorisation plus approval. Except as provided for in ss 137 and 145 (s 145 deals with emergencies), s 135 of the Disability Act 2006 (Vic) prohibits use of a regulated restrictive practice unless both an Authorised Program Officer’s authorisation under s 136 is in force and, for specified forms or for specified persons or classes of persons, the use has been approved by the Senior Practitioner (s 143).4 Victoria therefore has two consents for the more intrusive practices, not two routes.

Queensland — through a guardianship appointment. Queensland splits the work across two Acts. The Disability Services Act 2006 (Qld) supplies the plan requirements — s 150 defines a positive behaviour support plan and its required content — and sets cumulative conditions on the use of restraint in respite and community access services (s 167).5 The Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (Qld) then supplies the consent: chapter 5B provides for the appointment of a guardian for a restrictive practice matter, which is one consent route among others: the approval and consent arrangements depend on the practice and the service setting, so check the current Queensland scheme for the practice in question.6 Naming only one of the two Acts is the standard Queensland error.

Australian Capital Territory — a registered plan. The Senior Practitioner Act 2018 (ACT) defines a restrictive practice by primary purpose (s 7(1)(a)) and also expressly includes five forms (s 7(1)(b)), and its reach is unusually wide: s 8(1) binds providers of education, disability and child protection services.7 Section 10 prohibits use except under a registered positive behaviour support plan or on the emergency route, and s 10A requires reporting within five days of a use on the emergency route.

Tasmania — inside the 2024 statute. Section 52 of the Disability Rights, Inclusion and Safeguarding Act 2024 (Tas) provides for the Senior Practitioner to grant written authorisation for the use of restrictive practices (see also s 58(1)(g)), within an Act that also carries the CRPD-based principles (s 8(1)) and inclusion planning duties (ss 12 and 18).8

The comparison that matters

JurisdictionWho authorisesStructure
SAAuthorised Program Officer; Senior Authorising OfficerSplit by level of practice
VicAuthorised Program Officer and Senior PractitionerBoth required for specified practices
QldDepends on the practice and setting, including tribunal approval (containment or seclusion) and consent of a guardian for a restrictive practice matterApproval or consent under the guardianship Act; plan requirements in the disability services Act
ACTSenior Practitioner, by registering the planRegistration model; covers three service sectors
TasSenior PractitionerAuthorisation within the 2024 rights statute

Two observations. The office titles are not interchangeable: South Australia’s Senior Authorising Officer, Victoria’s and Tasmania’s Senior Practitioner, and the ACT’s Senior Practitioner do different jobs under differently worded provisions. And the unit of authorisation differs — a practice, a plan, or a decision made by a guardian on the person’s behalf.

The purpose limits

Where a jurisdiction states purpose limits, they are the most useful provisions in the scheme, because they dispose of the common case without any inquiry into process.

South Australia’s s 23M forbids use as a punishment or for the convenience of others, or to address inadequate staffing, equipment or facilities. The last of those is the one to notice: a restrictive practice used because the service is short-staffed is unlawful in South Australia whatever the paperwork says.

Queensland reaches a similar place differently, through the cumulative conditions in s 167 on restraint in respite and community access services, and through the positive behaviour support plan content requirements in s 150.

A working order

  1. Identify the practice as regulated under s 6 of the Commonwealth Rules before anything else.
  2. Name the Commonwealth requirement correctly: a condition of registration keyed to State authorisation, not a Commonwealth authorisation.
  3. Go to the State or Territory scheme and identify the authorising officer and the unit of authorisation.
  4. In Queensland, name both Acts.
  5. Check the purpose limits before checking the process. A practice used for staffing convenience does not become lawful by being authorised.
  6. Identify the enforcement route: registration conditions against the provider, through the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commissioner, including the civil penalty in s 73J of the Act for breaching a condition.

Self-check

  • Have I said that the Commonwealth conditions registration rather than authorising the practice?
  • Have I named the correct authorising office, in the correct jurisdiction’s words?
  • Have I applied the purpose limits before the process requirements?
  • Have I avoided asserting the position in a jurisdiction this article does not state?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.