Specific performance and special value

The foundation: damages that fall short

In Dougan v Ley (1946) 71 CLR 142, the High Court upheld specific performance of an oral deal to sell a taxi, its registration and licence. The price was £1,850, with only a £10 deposit paid.

Dixon J explained the doctrine’s foundation: specific performance is ordered when damages would not fairly compensate the wronged party. Damages fail here because they would not leave the party as well off as if the contract were actually performed.

But for ordinary goods available on the market, Dixon J said damages are enough. The buyer or seller can simply go and buy or sell equivalent goods elsewhere, so they suffer no real loss needing special court intervention.

Williams J agreed, stating equity will not order specific performance where damages are an adequate remedy. He noted this is usually the case for personal property that can be readily bought on the market.

Land, and chattels of special value

Dixon J said contracts for the sale of land can always get specific performance. This is an order from the court telling someone to actually complete the contract, instead of just paying damages. He noted this remedy works against a defaulting buyer too, not just a defaulting seller.

For other property, like chattels (movable goods), the question is different. The court must decide when a buyer deserves the exact item, rather than just compensation.

The judges agreed chattels need something special for this remedy. Rich J spoke of items with exceptional or peculiar value to the buyer. Williams J described chattels that are unique, or special for some other reason.

Dixon J gave examples from older cases. These included objects of unusual beauty, rarity, and distinction. He also mentioned limited railway shares unavailable on the open market.

Dixon J drew a line, though. Shares that are commonly traded on the market do not count as special in this way.

Why the taxi-cab qualified

This was not a simple sale of a chattel, an item of personal property. Dixon J found it was really the transfer of a valuable privilege attached to the vehicle. That privilege was a special right, transferable only with the vehicle, and limited in number.

Three facts supported this view. The law capped how many vehicles could be registered and licensed as taxi-cabs. Most of the price seemed to be for the registration and licence, not the vehicle itself. The vehicle and licence were both essential to the buyers’ business.

Rich J said the registration and licence made the vehicle specially valuable, as a money-making machine. Williams J called it a composite contract: a chattel suited to a particular business, plus the licence needed to run that business.

Two more points favoured the buyers. It did not matter that they bought another taxi-cab afterward. Dixon J said this was not an election, a choice to accept a substitute and claim damages instead. Williams J compared it to buying similar land nearby; it would not affect their rights.

It also did not matter that other licensed cabs were available to buy elsewhere, according to Williams J.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by identifying the contract and what performance is sought. Say whether the subject matter is land, a unique or specially valuable item, or something you could just buy on the market instead.

For a chattel (a movable item of property), ask why damages (money compensation) would not put the claimant in as good a position. Consider how scarce the item is, how much of its price reflects the special feature, and how essential it is to the claimant’s purpose.

Consider whether the claimant buying a substitute matters. Use Dougan v Ley to explain why this does not, by itself, defeat the claim.

Ask whether the order would need ongoing court supervision, or whether it only requires specific, identifiable steps.

If a third party’s consent is needed, consider a conditional order, in the form Dixon J described.

Finally, address other discretionary factors, like delay, hardship and the claimant’s own conduct. These are covered in the Equitable relief article, not here.

Self-check

Before moving on, check your reasoning on these points.

Start with damages. Ask whether damages would have been enough to fix the problem. This is the basic starting point for specific performance, an order forcing a party to actually perform the contract.

Next, explain what made the taxi-cab special. Use the actual factors the judgments relied on, not just the label “unique”.

Treat those factors as a way of framing the issue, not as a fixed test set by the High Court.

Finally, deal with supervision and mutuality separately. These are two distinct objections to granting specific performance, so address each on its own.

Where the authority sits

Dougan v Ley is a High Court case from 1946. It came on appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

As a High Court decision, it binds lower Australian courts. The High Court itself can still reconsider its own past decisions.

No later case or statute shown here changes this on specific enforcement of contracts for goods. Specific performance is a court order making someone actually complete a contract, rather than just pay damages.

Rich J noted that an English sale of goods provision on specific performance did not apply in New South Wales at that time. So check current sale of goods legislation in the relevant jurisdiction, as it may affect a claim involving goods.

For more background, see the articles on equitable remedies generally, and on the limits of equitable intervention.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.