Declarations: a real controversy and a discretion
What a declaration is for
In Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission, the Commission had reported on gaming machine regulation. It recommended the Ainsworth companies be kept out of the industry in Queensland. They were never told of its interest in them, and never given a chance to respond.
They sought certiorari (an order quashing a decision) and mandamus (an order compelling a duty to be performed). The Court held mandamus was misconceived, since the Commission had no duty to investigate as claimed. Certiorari was unavailable too, because the report had no legal effect.
Still, the appellants had a remedy. The report had damaged their reputations in practice, even without legal effect.
The Court declared that the Commission failed to observe procedural fairness in reporting adversely on them. This shows what a declaration does: it commands nothing, and does not say the report was wrong.
Justice Brennan agreed, but separately. He said such a declaration cannot say the report was actually wrong, because the court was not reviewing the report’s merits.
A wide jurisdiction and a discretion that is not mechanical
In Forster v Jododex Australia Pty Ltd, a company wanted the Supreme Court to declare its exploration licence had been validly renewed. A rival’s claim to the land was waiting on a warden’s inquiry, and the declaration would resolve that dispute.
Gibbs J made three points, later agreed to by Stephen, Mason and Walsh JJ. First, courts have a very wide power to make declarations. A statute only removes this power if it says so clearly.
Second, the court’s discretion (its choice whether to grant a declaration) should not be limited by strict rules. But the Dunedin requirements should usually be met first. Beyond that, little more guidance exists.
Third, a plaintiff should not be refused a declaration just because another remedy, like prohibition, is also available.
Gibbs J also considered whether courts should intervene while another body’s proceedings are pending. Despite hesitation, the issues here were purely about interpreting a statute and a document, were difficult, and involved valuable rights. Weighing this, the original decision to grant the declaration was not an improper use of discretion.
The High Court dismissed the appeal. Gibbs J actually disagreed on a separate point about timing, so his view was not the court’s final outcome—but the other judges agreed with his reasoning on the declaration issue.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by naming the legal right or duty in dispute. Write out the declaration you want, clearly enough to actually resolve that issue.
Then test it against the controversy requirements. You need a real question, a real interest, and a proper contradictor — someone with a genuine interest in opposing the declaration.
Check whether the question is merely hypothetical. A declaration should instead have foreseeable consequences for the parties involved.
Think about other proceedings or remedies that might be available. But having another remedy does not, by itself, stop a declaration being granted.
Identify which court’s power you are relying on. Check the statute or rules that apply in that particular court.
If a decision-maker failed to give someone a hearing, ask what the declaration would actually achieve. This matters especially where no writ — a court order compelling action — is available.
Self-check
Before finishing, check you have found a real controversy. A real controversy is an actual legal dispute, not just general curiosity about the law.
Check you have described the Dunedin requirements correctly. They are general guidance only, not a complete, fixed rule.
Check you have stated what Ainsworth and Forster each decided. Make sure you name the correct court and bench for each case.
Check you have noted that this summary does not cover the specific statutes and rules on declarations in the relevant court.
Where the authority sits
Ainsworth and Forster are both High Court decisions. This means they bind lower Australian courts, and the High Court itself can later reconsider them.
Ainsworth came from the Supreme Court of Queensland on appeal. Forster came from the Supreme Court of New South Wales.
This section does not establish what happened after these decisions. It also does not cover whether a statute might affect declaratory power in a particular court. Students should check both of these points themselves.
For more on equitable orders generally, see Equitable relief.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.