Leases: dealings, breach and termination
Assigning or subletting: whose consent, and on what terms
Many leases say a tenant cannot assign, sublet or part with possession without the landlord’s consent. Statute limits this in five jurisdictions: NSW (Conveyancing Act 1919 s 133B(1)(a)), Victoria (Property Law Act 1958 s 144(1)), Queensland (Property Law Act 2023 s 142(3)), WA (Property Law Act 1969 s 80(1)) and the NT (Law of Property Act 2000 s 134(1)(a)(i)).
In each, consent must not be unreasonably withheld. Queensland states this directly; the other four treat it as an implied proviso attached to the covenant. The NT rule applies only to leases of at least one year (s 134(8)).
Four of the five — not Queensland — also let the landlord recover reasonable consent expenses, meaning legal or other costs of dealing with the request. NSW s 133B(1)(a), Victoria s 144(1), WA s 80(1) and NT s 134(4) each preserve this right, in near-identical wording.
Queensland’s s 142 says nothing about the landlord’s costs of deciding. So in Queensland, any claim for consent expenses must come from the lease itself, not the statute.
Whether parties can contract out of the unreasonableness proviso depends on each section’s own wording. The NSW, Queensland and NT provisions apply despite any contrary term in the lease.
Where the residential and commercial tenancy statutes take over
The general property rules above often don’t apply to an ordinary home. Each jurisdiction has its own residential and commercial tenancy statutes that override the general law, though not always completely.
In South Australia, the Landlord and Tenant Act 1936 does not apply at all to a residential tenancy agreement (s 3A). Note that s 3A’s definition still refers to an old repealed Act, so its wording is outdated.
In the Northern Territory, the override works provision by provision, not Part by Part. Section 114(1) says that if a leases Part provision and a provision under certain other listed Acts both could apply, the other Act wins and the Part provision doesn’t apply. The rest of the leases Part keeps operating normally.
Section 114(2) then lists which sections apply to residential tenancies and which apply to business tenancies. For example, s 134 applies to business tenancies but not residential ones, while s 137 is switched off for both.
In Queensland, the forfeiture and relief division does not apply to a housing lease, a residential tenancy, a resources lease, or a State land lease. Forfeiture means the landlord ending the lease early for breach; relief is court assistance against that outcome.
The detailed content of these tenancy statutes isn’t covered here. When solving a lease termination problem, first work out which Act actually governs the tenancy.
Contract principles, repudiation and the landlord’s damages
Landlords are not limited to forfeiture under the lease. In Progressive Mailing House Pty Ltd v Tabali Pty Ltd, Mason J held that ordinary contract principles apply to leases. This includes terminating for repudiation (a serious breach showing one party will not perform) or fundamental breach. An express termination clause in the lease does not exclude this common law right, though the parties can still regulate how it is used. Other judges agreed, the appeal was dismissed, and no judge dissented. As a High Court decision, it binds lower courts, though the High Court may later reconsider its own rulings.
Brennan J added an important limit on damages. A landlord can only recover damages for loss of the lease’s benefit if the tenant repudiated before the lease was determined (ended), not merely before the original term would have expired naturally. Determination includes early termination. Proving a rent default alone does not necessarily prove repudiation. This limit came from Brennan J specifically — Wilson J’s separate comments concerned a different issue (whether completed works were a condition of paying rent), not this rule.
This is no longer the complete law on loss-of-bargain damages. In Gumland Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Duffy Bros Fruit Market (Campbelltown) Pty Ltd, the High Court allowed an appeal and awarded such damages even though it could be accepted there was no repudiation and no fundamental breach. The joint judgment relied on AMEV-UDC: the damages limitation applies only where termination follows a non-fundamental breach under a contractual right. It does not apply where there is fundamental breach, breach of an essential term, or repudiation. The judgment also noted Mason J’s definition of “fundamental breach” from Tabali.
Applying this in a problem question
First work out the jurisdiction, then which Act applies: the general property statute, the residential tenancies statute, or a retail/business tenancies statute. The displacement provisions decide this before breach is considered.
Check whether the notice provision covers this lease and breach. A term of a year or less is excluded in NSW, NT and ACT. Old forfeiture law for non-payment of rent survives in NSW, Victoria, WA, Tasmania, ACT, and (via s 12(5)) SA, which has its own rent relief under s 9; Victoria and WA each qualify this. Breach of the assignment covenant is excluded from the provision in WA and Tasmania.
Test the notice against the subsection: does it state the specific breach, require remedy if possible, and address compensation? A compensation demand is needed regardless of intent to claim in Victoria, WA, Tasmania, SA and ACT, but only if compensation is actually claimed in NSW, Queensland and NT. Queensland also needs the approved form, a stated reasonable period to remedy, and a statement of intent to terminate.
Ask whether re-entry without court is possible. In NT, only if the tenant abandoned or voluntarily gave up possession (s 137(1)(b)). In Queensland, after an unheeded notice to remedy, by peaceable re-entry, or else written demand then possession proceedings (s 157(2)); no notice or court is needed where the lessor reasonably believes possession was given up (s 156).
For consent disputes, quote the statutory proviso, then ask if the lease can exclude it. It cannot in NSW, Queensland or NT. It can in WA and in Victoria, except for licensed premises leases under s 144(2), where it cannot. In Victoria, first check if the Retail Leases Act 2003 (Vic) applies: s 60(2) disapplies s 144, and s 60(1) gives its own grounds.
Finally, consider relief against forfeiture (a court order reversing termination), the sub-tenant’s separate application for it, and any time limit involved.
Self-check
Before moving on, check a few things.
Name the actual Act, section and jurisdiction you are relying on. Do not just call it “the forfeiture provision”.
Check whether a tenancies statute overrides the general property legislation in this situation.
Ask whether the lease’s term, or the type of breach, takes it outside the usual notice requirement in this jurisdiction.
Finally, in Tabali, work out whose judgment you are actually relying on. There are five separate judgments in that case.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.