Writing a structured problem answer

The problem

A Commonwealth Act requires a delegate to refuse a licence unless satisfied two criteria are met. Criterion A needs the application made within 28 days of a previous licence ending, unless there are compelling reasons not to apply that rule. Criterion B needs the applicant to hold insurance, unless the delegate is satisfied arrangements to get it have been made.

Dana’s application was refused by a delegate, then refused again on review by the tribunal. The tribunal found no compelling reasons under criterion A. It assessed those reasons as at the date of Dana’s application.

The tribunal also found criterion B was not met. Dana admitted she had no insurance and no arrangements for it, though she said she intended to get some.

Dana accepts the tribunal misread criterion A. She now asks whether the decision can be set aside for jurisdictional error, meaning an error that goes beyond the tribunal’s legal power to decide.

The answer

Short answer: probably not. The tribunal made a legal error about criterion A. But its findings on criterion B likely mean the result would have been the same anyway. So the error is probably not material, and not jurisdictional (meaning it probably would not affect the tribunal’s power to decide).

The error on criterion A is accepted, so that is not argued. The real question is whether that error was material, meaning whether it affected the outcome.

In Hossain, three judges said a statute may require a “threshold of materiality” before an error becomes jurisdictional. This threshold can be set higher or lower depending on the statute.

In LPDT, six Justices gave the current guidance. They said an error is usually jurisdictional only if there was a realistic possibility the decision could have been different without it. The person challenging the decision must prove this using evidence, not just assumptions. The test asks if the outcome “could,” not “would,” have changed, and this is not a demanding standard. But if it can be shown the outcome would inevitably have been the same anyway, the threshold is not met. The answer assumes these same principles apply to the hypothetical Act here.

Applying this, the Act required refusal unless both criteria were satisfied. The tribunal found criterion B was not met, since Dana had no insurance, no arrangements, and her intentions were not enough. So even correcting the error on criterion A, criterion B still required refusal. This supports concluding the outcome would inevitably have been the same.

This mirrors Hossain, where the error made no difference because the other criterion could not have been satisfied anyway. Dana must show a realistic possibility of a different outcome, and on these findings, she probably cannot.

Why the answer is built this way

Here’s why the answer follows this structure.

It starts with the short answer. This lets the reader see the conclusion early.

The conceded error is noted, then set aside. Most of the answer focuses on materiality, since that is where the uncertainty lies.

The rule comes from the later, agreed statement. The earlier case shows how the rule applies. Using only the earlier formulation would be accurate but incomplete.

The rule is credited to the judges who stated it. The application then uses the facts, including the finding that criterion B was not met, to show why that finding resolves the issue.

The strongest counter-argument is included and answered using authority. Finally, the conclusion explains what the outcome depends on.

Common faults

Some students state the rule, then jump to a conclusion. They never show how the rule applies to the facts.

Others argue a point the problem already concedes. This wastes time and ignores the real issue in dispute.

Some state an old case’s rule without checking if the High Court later restated it. The law may have moved on since that case.

A good answer includes the counter-argument. Leaving it out, or picking a weak one, makes the analysis too easy.

Finally, avoid concluding with more confidence than the facts allow. The strength of your conclusion should match the strength of the facts.

Applying this in a problem question

First decide what you need to prove to answer the question. State your conclusion early, then list the issues in the order a court would deal with them.

Remove anything that is conceded or not disputed. Note any assumptions you make along the way.

For each rule, give its authority. Say whose reasoning stated it, and check whether it was later restated.

Apply the rule to the facts, element by element. Include the strongest argument against your own view.

Finish with a conclusion that shows what your answer depends on.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.