Issue, rule, application and conclusion in a High Court judgment

A worked reading of Wyong Shire Council v Shirt showing what the issue, rule, application and conclusion steps look like in a High Court judgment, and how to avoid claiming more than the issue decided.

Learning level
Application
Jurisdictions
au-national, au-commonwealth
Subjects
legal-research-and-method
Topics
legal-reasoning-and-problem-solving

Learning outcomes

  • Frame the issue a court actually decided, separating it from conceded points and from the wider area of law.
  • Distinguish the rule a judge states from the way the judge applies it, and attribute each to the right judge.
  • Limit a conclusion to what the issue required, and check for legislation before relying on a common-law case.

Issue, rule, application and conclusion is usually taught as a way to write an answer, but it is also a way to read a judgment. The prior question is not who won but what question the court actually answered, because that decides which part of the reasons states the law and which part applies it. This article reads Wyong Shire Council v Shirt (1980) 146 CLR 40, a common-law negligence appeal from New South Wales decided by the High Court of Australia, through that sequence. It teaches method. It does not state the current breach test for any Australian jurisdiction, because where a civil liability Act applies its terms govern.

The facts the courts treated as significant

Mr Shirt fell while water-skiing on Tuggerah Lakes in January 1967 and struck his head on the lake bed, where the water was between three feet six inches and four feet deep. He said that he was an inexperienced skier and that he skied there because he read a sign reading “DEEP WATER” as meaning that the water beyond it was deep. An engineer employed by the Shire had put the sign up in May 1966, when dredging works in the lake were complete.1 A jury found for Mr Shirt, a majority of the Court of Appeal of New South Wales upheld the verdict, and the Shire appealed to the High Court.

Not every fact in that story did legal work. Mason J’s reasoning turned on a few: the sign could be read as marking deep water beyond it rather than in front of it, a skier reading it that way might ski where the water was shallow, and an inexperienced skier thrown into water that shallow might strike the bed (Mason J, 48).

The issue is narrower than the case

The case was about negligence, but the issue was not whether the Shire was negligent in general. The Shire conceded that it owed water-skiers a duty of care, so duty was not in dispute (Mason J, 44). Mason J then stated the question: whether it was “reasonably open to the jury” to find the Shire in breach (Mason J, 44). The Shire’s argument was aimed at one element of breach, the foreseeability of the risk of injury (Mason J, 48).

Stating the issue at that level matters. It tells you which of the court’s statements are doing the work, and it stops you from citing the case for propositions it did not have to decide.

The rule, and a dispute about the rule

The rule step is not always a recital of settled law. Here the court first had to resolve a disagreement about how to describe foreseeability. One view was Barwick CJ’s preference, in an earlier case, for a risk that was “not unlikely to occur”; the other view was that a risk is foreseeable if it is not far-fetched or fanciful, even though unlikely to occur. Mason J accepted the second view, on the basis that “foreseeability of the risk of injury and the likelihood of that risk occurring are two different things” (Mason J, 44-47).

Having chosen, he stated a two-step sequence for breach. The tribunal of fact “must first ask itself whether a reasonable man in the defendant’s position would have foreseen that his conduct involved a risk of injury to the plaintiff or to a class of persons including the plaintiff”, and then decide what a reasonable person would do in response, weighing the magnitude and probability of the risk against the expense, difficulty and inconvenience of precautions and any conflicting responsibilities (Mason J, 48). Foreseeability is the first hurdle and does not answer the question of breach (Mason J, 48).

That is the calculus as Mason J stated it. Aickin J said that he was in complete agreement with Mason J, and Murphy J gave short separate reasons. This article attributes the calculus to Mason J rather than to “the Court” for that reason.

Application: the same rule, two answers

Wilson J dissented, and he did not reject the test. He accepted the foreseeability test from The Wagon Mound (No 2) and asked whether the evidence could show that a reasonable person in the engineer’s position would have foreseen a real risk (Wilson J, 53-54). The difference was in application. Wilson J read the evidence as showing that the lake had long been used for water-skiing in shallow water, that nothing suggested to the engineer that this was dangerous, and that the signs were directed at people near the jetty who might wander into the channel. On that reading the possibility that the sign would be misread as Mr Shirt said was “not a real risk which ought to have been present to Mr. McPhan’s mind”, and he would have allowed the appeal (Wilson J, 54).

So two Justices could accept one rule and reach opposite conclusions. A student who learns the rule alone has learned half of the case. The other half is which facts moved each judge, and why.

The conclusion matches the issue

The Court dismissed the appeal. Mason J’s conclusion is carefully modest. Because it was not an appeal against a finding of fact, he did not find that a reasonable person “would necessarily have foreseen the risk of injury”. He held that the jury’s conclusion “was not unreasonable” and was open on the evidence (Mason J, 49). The conclusion answers the issue as framed (was breach reasonably open to the jury?) and no more. An answer that said the Shire was negligent because the sign was ambiguous would state a conclusion the case did not reach.

Where this case sits today

Shirt is a decision of the High Court, so it binds lower Australian courts, and the High Court can reconsider its own decisions. It is also a common-law decision, and legislation may now govern breach in your jurisdiction. New South Wales is one example. Section 5B(1) of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), as the High Court set it out in Adeels Palace Pty Ltd v Moubarak (2009) 239 CLR 420, provided that a person is not negligent in failing to take precautions against a risk of harm unless the risk was foreseeable, “the risk was not insignificant”, and a reasonable person in the person’s position would have taken those precautions.2 That judgment does not compare s 5B with Shirt, so the comparison is a question for you to work through for the jurisdiction in your problem. Identify whether a statute applies before you choose a framework, and see Negligence: breach of duty and Statutory modification of tort liability.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. State the issue as a question that the rule can answer, and leave out elements the parties have conceded or that are not in dispute.
  2. Check whether the rule is settled or contested. If courts have formulated it differently, say which formulation you apply and why.
  3. Pick out the facts that move the rule, and say how each one bears on a stated element.
  4. Apply the rule to those facts and consider the best argument the other way. Two decision-makers can accept the same rule and differ on application.
  5. Limit your conclusion to what the issue asked. Where the answer depends on how a fact-finder would view the evidence, say so.
  6. Check whether a statute displaces or modifies the common-law rule in your jurisdiction before relying on a common-law case.

Self-check

  • Have I stated the issue as a question narrower than the area of law?
  • Have I said which part of the reasons states the rule and which part applies it?
  • Have I attributed the rule to the judge or judges who stated it?
  • Does my conclusion claim more than the issue required?
  • Have I checked for legislation that governs breach in my jurisdiction?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.