Theories of justice: equal treatment and the purposes of punishment
Aristotle: two kinds of justice and a proportion
Aristotle describes two kinds of justice. One deals with distributing honour or money among people who share in a community. The other works to fix things up, or “rectify,” wrongs between individuals.
Aristotle says just treatment must be “intermediate and equal and relative.” This does not mean treating everyone identically. It means keeping a proportion that fits the particular people and things involved.
He also notes that paying someone back in kind, “reciprocity,” is not the same as rectifying a wrong. For example, if an official wounds someone, that official should not simply be wounded back. But if someone wounds an official, that person should be wounded and punished further.
This shows that response to a wrong depends on who is involved, not just on matching the harm done.
When the purposes of punishment conflict: Veen (No 2)
Veen v The Queen (No 2) (1988) 164 CLR 465 involved a life sentence for manslaughter based on diminished responsibility. The High Court held that a sentence should not be increased beyond what fits the crime just to guard against future reoffending.
But the Court said protection of society can still be weighed as one factor among others. This echoes a debate about retribution: the idea that punishment should match the wrong done. Some theorists think retribution should stop punishment being extended to protect society or reform the offender.
The Court listed the purposes of punishment: protecting society, deterrence, retribution, and reform. It said none of these can be looked at alone, and they sometimes pull in different directions. This balancing approach was later applied in Bugmy v The Queen [2013] HCA 37, which relies on Veen (No 2) for this point.
The philosopher Mill identified a similar problem. He said no single justification for punishment can satisfy justice without conflicting with another. His solution was to base justice entirely on utility (overall welfare).
The High Court does not adopt Mill’s solution. Instead, Veen (No 2) sets proportionality as an upper limit, without choosing one single theory. The article suggests this lets courts weigh multiple justifications together, with just deserts acting as a ceiling on the sentence.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out which justice argument is being made. It could be equal treatment of like cases, or a purpose of punishment.
For equal treatment, explain what makes the cases alike or different, as required in Wong at [65] and Hili at [49]. Don’t argue from numbers alone. Hili at [48] says numbers alone don’t show consistency.
For purposes of punishment, name the purposes involved. Say which way each one points, using Veen (No 2) at [13].
Remember the limit in Veen (No 2) at [8]. A sentence must not exceed what is proportionate to the crime, even to protect society.
Finally, state the jurisdiction and statute involved. Wong and Hili concern federal offenders sentenced in New South Wales. Veen (No 2) concerns a New South Wales sentence. None of these three cases applies to sentencing generally.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.