Natural law arguments in Australian courts

The classical claim, in Aquinas’s words

Aquinas, a medieval philosopher, set out a key natural law idea in the Summa Theologiae. Human law only counts as true law when it comes from natural law. If it departs from natural law, it becomes a “perversion of law” rather than real law.

Aquinas says human law can derive from natural law in two ways. First, as a direct conclusion from a principle, like the rule against killing. Second, by “determination” of a general principle, where legislators fill in details.

An example of determination is punishment. Natural law says wrongdoers should be punished, but it does not fix the method. Choosing the particular penalty is left to human judgment.

This second method gives legislators real freedom to make choices. Because of this flexibility, the passage calls this version the “strong form” of Aquinas’s claim.

Litigants most often rely on this strong form. They use it when arguing a statute is so unjust that it should not count as law at all.

Aimed at a statute: Durham Holdings

In Durham Holdings Pty Ltd v New South Wales [2001] HCA 7, a NSW statute acquired a company’s coal. It capped compensation well below the assessed value. The company argued a State Parliament’s lawmaking power has limits under common law.

The High Court refused special leave to appeal. So these are not a decision on the merits, just reasons from six Justices on why leave was refused.

The joint reasons (Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ) accepted at [14] that some limits on State legislative power exist outside the constitutional text. But they held this particular limit wasn’t implied by the federal structure. The Court of Appeal had rightly left settled law on State power undisturbed. These limits come from the Constitution’s text and structure—a different idea from saying unjust law isn’t really law.

Kirby J, writing separately, outlined the company’s argument at [41]-[48]. This included New Zealand judicial comments that some common law rights lie “so deep” Parliament cannot override them. At [52] he noted an earlier case (Union Steamship Co of Australia Pty Ltd v King) had left this question open for State Parliaments, and no case supported the company’s position.

At [43] he quoted a scholar: many lawyers once believed Parliament was bound by natural or divine law, but there’s no real evidence courts were ever thought to have authority to enforce it. He concluded at [62] that the “so deep” rights idea has “few adherents.” At [77] he said the complaints were political, not legal, in nature.

Callinan J, at [79], reserved his opinion—he didn’t decide whether unexpressed limits on State power exist.

Overall: the High Court hasn’t accepted that a validly made State law can be invalid merely for being unjust. Whether unexpressed common law limits exist remains an open question. This case only concerns State legislation—it says nothing definite about Commonwealth laws.

Aimed at the common law: Mabo (No 2)

Courts can change common law rules they made themselves, so justice arguments work better here. In Mabo v Queensland (No 2) [1992] HCA 23, six judges held the common law recognises native title.

Justice Brennan said that if earlier cases were right, the common law had wrongly stripped Indigenous people of rights to their land. He called such a law unjust by any civilised standard.

But Brennan J set a limit. Courts cannot adopt new rules just because they match modern justice, if doing so would fracture the skeleton of principle (the basic structure holding the law together). A rule can only be overturned if it seriously offends justice and human rights, and if removing it would not cause disproportionate disturbance to the law.

Brennan J never called this reasoning “natural law” himself; that label is the article’s own description. The point here is that justice gave a reason to reconsider an existing rule. It did not mean the old rule was never really law.

Native title law has since changed. In Members of the Yorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v Victoria (2002), the High Court said native title is not purely a common law creature. It now depends on the statutory definition in s 223(1) of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth), though Mabo (No 2) had established that traditional rights survived the Crown gaining sovereignty.

This passage does not explain the current law of native title in detail; that is covered elsewhere.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out what the argument targets: a statute, a common law rule, or how a statute should be read.

If it targets a statute, remember Durham Holdings is only reasons on a refused special leave application. It concerned a State Parliament, not Commonwealth legislation. Do not treat it as a binding holding about Commonwealth power.

If it targets a common law rule, apply the Mabo (No 2) questions at [29]. Ask whether the rule seriously offends justice and human rights, whether it is essential to the legal system, and whether overturning it would disturb the law disproportionately.

If the argument is that a statute should be read to protect a fundamental right, this is really a question of statutory meaning, not natural law. See the related article on positivism, validity and justice.

Finally, state clearly which version of the natural law claim is being used: the strong Aquinas-based form, or the more modest form that only gives a reason to reconsider a rule.

Self-check

Before submitting, check three things.

First, say what your argument targets. Is it a statute, a common law rule, or a particular reading of one of these?

Second, check your case references. Make sure you attribute statements in Durham Holdings and Mabo (No 2) to the correct Justices. Also note that Durham Holdings was a refusal of special leave, not a full decision on the merits.

Third, do not use these cases to state the current law on native title or on Commonwealth legislative power.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.