Forum, stay and contract: when an Australian court takes or declines a case
Invoking jurisdiction by service
A court usually gains jurisdiction over a defendant by service of originating process. This means formally delivering the court documents that start the case.
Within Australia, the Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth) lets process issued in one State be served in another State (s 15(1)). Territories count as States for this purpose (s 5(1)). Service this way has the same effect as if served where the process was issued (s 12).
For service outside Australia, each court’s own rules decide when this is allowed. In Gutnick, the majority judges described Victoria’s scheme, where process could be served overseas without leave if the case involved damage suffered wholly or partly in Victoria, caused by a tort occurring anywhere.
A defendant who disputes the court’s jurisdiction can enter a conditional appearance. This lets them ask the court to stay the case or set aside service, without accepting jurisdiction.
Declining jurisdiction: the clearly inappropriate forum test
Once a court has jurisdiction, it may still decline to use it. Voth v Manildra Flour Mills Pty Ltd (1990) 171 CLR 538 sets the test for this.
The majority asked whether the local court is a “clearly inappropriate forum”. This means continuing the case here would be oppressive or vexatious. The focus is on whether the local court is inappropriate, not whether the foreign court is better.[^cite:voth-v-manildra-clearly-inappropriate-forum]
The majority found Lord Goff’s reasoning in Spiliada Maritime Corporation v Cansulex Ltd (an English case) helpful. That case asked whether another forum was “clearly more appropriate”. The Australian majority did not adopt that test, but thought it would usually give the same result. The two tests differ only where a foreign forum is more appropriate, yet the local one is not clearly inappropriate.
Two points are often misunderstood. First, the judges did not all agree on the reasoning. Brennan J preferred a different test but joined the majority test for the sake of certainty. Toohey J still preferred the forum non conveniens approach from Oceanic Sun Line Special Shipping Co Inc v Fay, though he agreed with the outcome.
Second, the result shows how the test works in practice. The Court thought Missouri was the more appropriate forum for a claim against a Missouri accountant. But it said this did not automatically make New South Wales clearly inappropriate. After weighing the connecting factors (which favoured Missouri) against the plaintiffs’ residence and advantages of suing at home, the Court stayed the case. The stay was conditional: the defendant could not plead a limitation defence in Missouri.
Voth used the old choice of law rule from Phillips v Eyre, which no longer applies to torts. In Regie Nationale des Usines Renault SA v Zhang (2002) 210 CLR 491, five Justices held that the double actionability rule does not apply to international torts in Australia ([60]). They held that the law of the place of the tort (lex loci delicti) governs foreign torts instead ([75]).[^cite:renault-v-zhang-qualifies-voth-cho]
A contract’s choice of law is not its choice of courts
Akai Pty Ltd v People’s Insurance Co Ltd shows why choice of law and choice of courts are different things. A New South Wales company insured with a Singapore insurer under a clause saying English law applied and English courts would hear disputes. The insurer wanted the New South Wales case stayed. This turned on the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth), s 8, which applies the Act to contracts whose proper law is, or would be but for a contrary clause, that of a State or Territory.
The High Court split 3:2 and refused the stay. Dawson and McHugh JJ dissented. They said choosing a law and choosing a court are different acts; only the second counts as submitting to that court’s jurisdiction. They saw clause 9 as a valid exclusive jurisdiction clause, which the Act did not stop.
The majority (Toohey, Gaudron and Gummow JJ) decided the appeal differently. Section 8 stops parties avoiding the Act by choosing another law. Ignoring the parties’ own clause, the applicable law was whichever had the “closest and most real connection” with the contract — here, New South Wales law. They rejected treating choice of law as a multi-step test, saying there is only one question: what law the parties chose, read from the whole contract. They then used s 52 of the Act, which voids clauses that unfairly limit the Act’s protection, to strike down the jurisdiction clause.
Both sets of judges agreed on the starting point: courts usually hold parties to a foreign jurisdiction clause unless there’s strong reason not to. In Akai, a specific statute overrode that starting point. The case does not mean Australian courts generally ignore foreign jurisdiction clauses.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by separating three different questions: does the court have jurisdiction, should it stay or transfer the case, and which law governs. Keep these separate throughout.
If the parties are from different States or Territories, check the Service and Execution of Process Act 1992 (Cth) ss 15 and 20 first. Also check the cross-vesting legislation. Only turn to common law after this.
If serving process outside Australia, find that specific court’s own rule allowing this. Do not assume other courts share the same rule.
For a stay sought on forum grounds, outside these statutory schemes, apply the Voth test. Ask whether the local court is clearly inappropriate, making the case oppressive or vexatious. Weigh the connecting factors. Note that a more suitable foreign forum alone does not satisfy this test.
For contracts, examine the choice of law clause and choice of courts clause separately. Ask whether a statute sets its own connecting factor, as s 8 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) did in Akai.
Finally, note that the High Court split in Akai. The Voth test comes from the joint reasons. The Akai result reflects the reasoning of Toohey, Gaudron and Gummow JJ, with a dissent.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.