Registering foreign judgments under the Foreign Judgments Act 1991 (Cth)
How the Court of Appeal read these grounds
Nyunt v First Property Holdings Pte Ltd [2022] NSWCA 249 involved a Singapore default judgment, later assessed at about US$66 million, registered in NSW. The debtor was served and knew of the case, but chose not to defend it. Bell CJ wrote the reasons; the other judges agreed. As an intermediate appellate decision, it does not bind the High Court.
First, s 7(3)(a)(iii)’s prior agreement test looks only at what the debtor had agreed before the foreign case began. The creditor’s own conduct, like earlier Myanmar suits, is irrelevant. It did not undo the debtor’s submission to Singapore’s courts.
Second, a non-exclusive submission-to-suit clause (agreeing to one court’s jurisdiction without ruling out others) lets the creditor sue elsewhere too. The court said allowing other suits is central to such a clause.
Third, s 7(2)(a)(v) requires setting aside registration only where insufficient notice stopped the debtor defending, assuming the foreign court had jurisdiction under s 7(3). Knowing of the claim, but not its size, did not defeat registration.
Fourth, the public policy ground is narrow; an enforcing court will not review the foreign judgment’s merits. The court left open whether this ground could ever cover a denial of substantial justice in exceptional cases, but found no such denial, or gross denial of procedural fairness, here.
The common law when the Act does not apply
If the Act does not apply, a party can still enforce a foreign judgment by bringing an action at common law.
In Bao v Qu; Tian (No 2), Rothman J set out four requirements. This was a first instance decision, so it is persuasive, not binding. The requirements are: the foreign court had jurisdiction in the international sense (the right kind of power over the defendant); the judgment is final and conclusive; the parties are identical; and the judgment is for a fixed, liquidated sum.
The party seeking enforcement must prove these requirements. Once proven, the judgment is prima facie enforceable, meaning it is treated as enforceable unless successfully challenged.
The defendant generally cannot reopen the merits of the foreign judgment. Fraud is an exception to this rule.
Rothman J also held that even if the defendants conceded the foreign court had jurisdiction, the Court must still independently determine that jurisdiction itself.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by identifying the country and court that gave the judgment. Check whether current regulations extend Part 2 of the Foreign Judgments Act 1991 (Cth) to that court. Part 2 never applies to a New Zealand court judgment (s 5(10)).
Next, confirm the judgment is a final and conclusive money judgment. “Enforceable money judgment” excludes tax, similar charges, fines and penalties — except for New Zealand tax and recoverable Papua New Guinea income tax (ss 3(1), 5(4)). A pending appeal in the foreign court does not stop the judgment being final (s 5(5)).
If Part 2 applies, registration within six years is the correct route. Section 10(1) excludes bringing a separate action on the judgment instead.
Then work through the debtor’s grounds of challenge in the order set by s 7(2), testing jurisdiction against s 7(3)-(5). Note which grounds are mandatory, and that s 7(2)(b) is discretionary — the court may, but need not, refuse registration.
For notice and public policy grounds, apply the reasoning from Nyunt, but keep its limits in mind. This process is never an appeal on the merits of the foreign judgment.
If the Act does not apply, work through the four common law requirements and consider who bears the onus. Remember Bao v Qu is only a single-judge decision.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.